Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Routin Arc In End Grain

Posts

Routin Arc In End Grain

#1

Routin Arc In End Grain

Tom Rex

I am trying to route a semi-circle (arc) in the end of a 1 ¼” piece of wood.

I’ve tried pine and red oak.

I have a template that I am following and I’m using a ½” pattern bit with 2 cutters and a bearing on top.

There is a flat surface on the board before it gets to the arc.

It blows out the arc when I am going around the arc.

I have the wood between me and the router bit starting on the left side of the straight edge moving the wood to the left.

When I get to the arc it goes well until I get about halfway around then the bit grabs the wood an butchers it.

Teach me how to rout this arc.

What am I doing wrong?

What speed should I be running the router for pine? For red oak?

What direction should I be going when I get to the arc?

Thanks for your help,

T Rex

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

#2

Dale Lenz

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

Dale Lenz

What's your depth setting during your pass? Not sure a pattern bit is the best thing(?). Might need to remake your template and use a spriral bit(?).

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

#3

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

Tom Rex

The thickness is 5/8.

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

#4

Dale Lenz

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

Dale Lenz

If you are trying to hog out 5/8" with a single pass, thats over 200% to much. Try, 1/16" to 3/32"/pass.

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

#5

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

Tom Rex

How do you follow a template and take only part of wood out?

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

#6

Moses Yoder

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

Moses Yoder

You can't. What I would do is mark the cut with a pencil, then band saw very close to the mark. Now clamp your piece with template on a very sturdy workbench, put the bit in a hand held router, and carefully climb cut to the template. The other option is to take the pieces to a cnc shop and have them do it.

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

#7

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

Jesse Cloud

Thats the problem trying to route a shape with a template and a flush trim bit. The grain changes direction and when you are fighting the grain, you are likely to get chip out.

If have a shaper that can change rotation direction (or have a friend who has one) you can accomodate this by changing the way the bit spins. The alternative, as suggested above is to take shallow climb cuts until you get close to the template.

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

#8

Dale Lenz

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

Dale Lenz

>How do you follow a template and take only part of wood out? <

Maybe I'm not understanding the question. But I've been template cutting for years using a router and always take multi passes of an 1/8" or so every pass.

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

#9

I Hate It When That Happens

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Tom,

I had the exact problem with end grain and blow out, and ruined a fair amount of good stock and repeated set up time. I decided to use the band saw and to get close as possible to the layout line. Then I dug out my spindle sander and used that to gain conformance. Since the curve was to have an profile, I bought another 1/4" cove bit which was "as new" sharp and did it by increments. It was a frustrating experience, and I blew out more stock before getting an item which fit and worked.

George

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

#10

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

If the edge is not profiled, ditch the router in favor of either the band saw or a jig saw to cut to the lay-out line , then spindle sand/shape (dedicated or just the drum-on-the-drill-press variety. When you cut into the end grain as a router bit must, the fibers bonds will not be strong enough to cut cleanly.

If the edge is to be profiled, post a pic of the piece and your intended design for more detailed advice.

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

#11

Forgot what it's called

Howard

Imagine a router pattern bit on steroids, 3” diameter. But instead of a cutter it uses 3 inch diameter sanding cylinders. You would use it in a drill press with the pattern below the work. This might work for you.

I can't think of the name or manufacturer but I found it a couple of years in catalogs for musical instrument makers.

Howard

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

#13

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

What you are experiencing is not uncommon. The solution is relatively simple. Take light cuts as others have suggested and climb cut the problem area. Since you have a template you don't have to worry about taking off too much. You can just hand guide the router in the thicker stock areas to remove a little material. Make multiple passes until the bearing touches the template. Most important when the router gets half way around your arc you need to stop and move the bit to the far side of the reversed grain area and cut back toward the area you started to cut. This is known as climb cutting.

When climb cutting the router bit cutting action is going to tend to pull the router into the uncut area so it is extremely important that you have a good grip on the router to hold it back and that your work piece is securely anchored. Take very light cuts only. Don't try to climb cut the entire piece, just the problem area otherwise you will have the same problem on the other half of the arc you are cutting.

Lee

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

#14

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

Tom Rex

You wouldn't do this on a router table?

What speed should I have the router set on?

Would it be better to have a larger than 1/2" bit?

Do I need a spiral bit (they don't have a bearing)?

Thanks,

T Rex

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

#15

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

Kurt

Make your template out of 1/2" or 3/4" sheet goods - MDF or plywood. Then get a top bearing pattern bit like this one:

http://www.mlcswoodworking.com/orderstatus/html/smarthtml/pages/katana_bits3.htm

Item # 16509 1/2" diameter X 1/2" cutter length.

You could run the bit's bearing on the template without even cutting if you wanted to and used 3/4" material. Then take multiple shallow passes.

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

#16

Re: Routin Arc In End Grain

Rick Christopherson

Handling a cut with a router bit is not much different than doing the same with a chisel. You need to alter your direction depending on the direction of the grain. Most woodworkers understand that climb-cutting gives better results along the length of a piece of stock, but many don't realize that for the same reasons, it is poor across the grain. When you are routing a circle, the direction that the cutter tip is impacting the wood fibers makes a huge difference. For example, climb-cutting across the endgrain compresses the fibers and leaves a poor edge. Push-cutting as the grain is flowing "uphill" will result in rapid tearout.

It requires more than a single pass, but you need to change the feed direction as you work your way around a circle. In the image below, note that the quadrants are not at 90 degrees to the wood grain direction.


img