Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

some engineerng help, please

Posts

some engineerng help, please

#1

some engineerng help, please

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

I am building a scissors lift table out of left over plywood and other left over treasures. It is a double scissor lift to gain sufficient lift for my purposes. My lift mechanism is a threaded rod and I need access to it. I took the principle from a car jack. I have the threaded rod horizontally through the middle (where the two scissors intersect) doing what is best described as a dead lift. As least to me. When I look at commercial scissors lifts, a hydraulic cylinder is at an angle doing more 'lifting' than 'pulling.'

The whole assembly worked fine until I added the top table. I may have exceeded the lifting weight limit. That won't do. This little marvel is intended to lift things I no longer can.

Any engineers in the crowd that can tell me where I might find some information? Will angling the rod from the top of one end to the middle of the other end of the top scissors increase the load capacity? If not, what will?

I quit for the night, but I checked all connections for easy movement, nothing seems to be binding. Tomorrow I will remove the top table and try again, but some direction would be good.

Thanks.

Re: some engineerng help, please

#2

Re: some engineerng help, please

Rick Christopherson

The problem with a scissor action is that when at its lowest position, your leadscrew is acting across a nearly straight line joint. Not only is the leadscrew trying to compress a non-compressible link, but the ratio of compression to lift is very high (i.e. the leverage to move is very low.)

The easiest solution is to never permit the scissor arms to fully collapse, but of course this also means your lift can't go very low.

A more complex solution is to add a compound action between the leadscrew and the scissor that causes the initial travel of the leadscrew to act more in the vertical direction to more easily move the scissor arms out of their near parallel position. I don't have an immediate solution for you, but maybe to plant a seed for more thinking is to consider that the first inch or two of leadscrew travel does not engage the scissor arms. Instead use this part of the leadscrew travel to pull against another set of links.

Re: some engineerng help, please

#3

Steve Strickland

Re: some engineerng help, please

Steve Strickland

Scissor lifts like car jacks have the lead screw in the hinge. This means that all leverage comes from the screw.

Put the lead screw at the bottom of the scissors, which now form an X shape. Now when you lengthen the bottom arms longer than the upper arms you are increasing your leverage. It's a simple calculation for foot-pounds of torque. When you decrease the feet part you increase the pounds part.

Let's say the X is 4 feet long on each arm and it pivots in the center. You apply 10 pounds of force to the bottom arms. The leverage ratio is 1 to 1 so you get 10 pounds of force on the upper arms. Now let's move the pivot so that the lower arms are 3 feet long and the upper arms are 1 feet long, a ratio of 3 to 1. Now when you apply 10 pounds of force to the bottom arms 30 pounds of force is applied to the upper arms. You have tripled your lifting capacity simply by moving the pivot. In exchange you have to screw the lower arms 3 time farther for a foot of lifting distance.

Finer screw threads will also provide more lift because you are shortening the feet part with each turn while adding more turns.

It's foot-pounds from the pivot for all levers. Just move the pivot to convert feet on 1 side into pounds on the other.

Taking the example above:

10 pounds x 2 feet = 20 ft/lbs of torque on the lower arms

then

20 ft/lbs / 2 feet = 10 ft/lbs of torque on the upper arms

Move Pivot:

10 pounds x 3 feet = 30 ft/lbs of torque on the lower arms

then

30 ft.lbs / 1 foot = 30 ft/lbs of torque on the upper arms.

Re: some engineerng help, please

#4

Re: some engineerng help, please

Pat Evans

I just logged on to post about only having two hands and needing methods of doing the work of four. To lower double glass panes down into a caulk bed in a window frame, I built this lift. I had to add stabilizing dowels to get mine to work, but I'm only lifting maybe 30 lbs. and only about 4".

How much weight are you trying to lift and how high?


Re: some engineerng help, please

#5

I'm no help but this is a beauty

GolfSteve in Calgary

I was at the Mall yesterday (SHOCK!). Went into Restoration House, an overpriced place with cool stuff.

http://www.restorationhardware.com/catalog/product/product.jsp?productId=prod690020&link=IndustrialScissorLift

This "Industrial Scissor Lift" caught my eye as being something cool. My daughters and wife may not agree with my definition of cool, but I would really love to have something like this if it did not cost $2000!

Time to get out the welding machine...

Re: some engineerng help, please

#6

Re: some engineerng help, please *LINK*

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

As noted when the scissor is at its lowest point the torque needed for lifting will be the greatest. Most scissor jacks use an acme thread as regular pointed threads will require greater torque and will wear more quickly.

You might be able to adapt camping trailer stabilizer jacks for your needs at a relatively low cost. Or go to your local junk yard and see if you can get a scissor jack from a car. I have an old Toyota one that has a dual screw drive that overcomes the low position torque problem with two different thread pitches.

Lee


Scissor Jack

Re: some engineerng help, please

#7

Re: some engineerng help, please

Joseph Mulherin

Carol, last November I bought the plans for the jackbench...constructed it and use it whenever I have the need to alternate the working surface from lower to higher. It also jacks up the entire table to move around the shop. www.jackbench.com Go there and just watch the videos. He uses car sissor jacks to elevate everything...and uses a hand drill to operate the jacks.

Re: some engineerng help, please

#8

Re: I'm no help but this is a beauty

Carol Reed

We have a winner here! That picture from the Restoration House was just what I needed! I had built it using the straight scissor action and had a very difficult time overcoming the initial lifting effort. Actually put a double bend in 1/4" 2 1/2" bolts! Introducing the parallelogram principle within the scissors was just the ticket. I now have a working model. And I have learned a bunch of things about this. What doesn't work and what might. Even some things that do! Pictures later. Still have some excess friction to deal with.

It's kinda cute, actually.