Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Varnish Chemistry and Swedish Wooden ware

Posts

Varnish Chemistry and Swedish Wooden ware

#1

Varnish Chemistry and Swedish Wooden ware

Bill Tindall

We had Drew Langsner, Country Woodshops for out Sept. club meeting. (BTW, the workshops there got rave reviews from our members) We all carved a wooden spreading knife, expect me. I carved a stir fry stirrer. (always one in the crowd) There was only one minor wound observed. The topic of finishing wooden ware came up. Drew finishes with cooking grade raw linseed oil. There followed a discussion of how linseed oil worked. To clarify the misinformation I volunteered to write up how these finishes work. On the chance that someone else may be interested in clarifying this chemistry I have copied it below:

Glycerin has three reactive parts of the molecule that can react (combine with) with organic acids such as acetic acid, stearic acid, etc.

All animal and plant "fats and oils" are mainly glycerin combined with three acids. The composition and size of these acids determines the properties of the fat or oil- whether it is a solid or liquid at room temperature, its smoke point for frying, whether it will readily go rancid or not, and most important for woodworkers whether it will "dry" (cure) to a durable film.

These acids can contain between zero and three reactive parts. These reactive parts can combine with oxygen to make a peroxide. Peroxides are unstable and they spontaneously decompose to various things including "radicals", an extremely reactive material. The most important reaction to us is the ability of radicals to react with themselves which will result in the joining together of what ever the radical is part of , in our case the fat or oil molecules.

For our purposes the acid of interest is "linolenic acid". It contains 3 reactive groups, each capable of reacting with oxygen and generating a radical capable of joining its oil molecule to another.

Some oils have none of this highly reactive acid, for example olive oil. The "drying oils" (linseed and Tung) have lots of this acid. Lots of these reactive parts means exposure to oxygen makes millions of radicals which will link thousands of the oil molecules together to make a polymer/plastic. (not every radical results in a link, see below) The more molecules that are linked the tougher and harder the resulting film will become. Bottom line: to get a tough durable film the oil must contain lots of linolenic acid. Linseed oil does and corn oil doesn't.

Cooking: Many foods and all cooking oils are composed of glycerin with acids with zero, one or even two reactive groups. While these oils won't make a wood finish they will do another annoying reaction.

Another thing the peroxide/radical can do is split the acid into two pieces. One of these pieces will be a smaller acid- acetic, propionic, butyric, caproic(named for goat stink). These small acids all stink. When an oil goes rancid (or a material with lots of oil(butter, whole wheat flour, nuts, etc.) goes rancid it means the acids in these oils have some reactive groups that have combined with oxygen and made a peroxide which has decomposed and split off a stinky smaller acid.

More cooking: The part of the oil that is left after it has reacted some with oxygen and split off smaller acids is a surfactant. Used deep frying oil will contain sufficient amounts of the stuff to cause it to foam.

More cooking: Oil made from acids that have fewer reactive groups is slower to react with oxygen. It will have a higher "smoke point", which is to say these oils are more chemically resistant to reaction with oxygen and they therefor are more stable when used for deep frying.

Moral of story: any food with fat or oil will react with oxygen and go "stale/rancid". Freezing greatly slows the reaction. Refrigerate butter, freeze whole wheat flour and steel cut oats and any kind of nuts out of the shell.

Personal Hygiene: Soap is made by splitting the acids off the glycerin. Any of these large acids (stearic for example) makes a soap when it is split from the fat or oil with caustic/lye. The property of the soap (solid, liquid, reacts with hard water or not) will depend on what acids are in it, which in turn depends on what fat or oil it was made from.

Re: Varnish Chemistry and Swedish Wooden ware

#2

Re: Varnish Chemistry and Swedish Wooden ware

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Thanks for the explanation of the chemistry involved.

Re: Varnish Chemistry and Swedish Wooden ware

#3

JL

Re: Varnish Chemistry and Swedish Wooden ware

JL

More appropriately glycerol rather than glycerin.

The reactive parts of glycerol are the -OH (alcohol) groups on the glycerol molecule.

The alcohol group reacts with the carboxylic acid group of the organic acid to form an ester linkage.

One, two or three of the alcohol groups may react. Thus you can have a monoacyl glycerol, a diacyl glycerol or a triacyl glycerol (monoglyceride, diglyceride and triglyceride)

Many of the plants and animals "fats and oils" - not all.

As an example, you have phospholipids such as phosphatidyl choline where you have a choline molecule joined to the glycerol molecule via a phosphate linkage. You can also have phosphatidyl inositol and phosphatidyl ethanolamine.

You may also have a glycolipid such as a ceramide, cerbroside or ganglioside.

Triglycerides make up a large component - but it depends on the source of the fat or oil as to how much.

I'd steer away from "reactive parts". I'd go more for double bonds or points of unsaturation - but that is your call. The ester linkage is also somewhat reactive.

Tung oil has alpha-eleostearic acid rather than alpha-linolenic acid - slightly different isomers. I would agree with "polymer", but I would shy away from using the term "plastic".

Re: Varnish Chemistry and Swedish Wooden ware

#4

Question... *LINK*

John in NM

I recently read an article that made the claim that turpentine made raw linseed oil "dry" faster than mineral spirits. Given the article's general wording and rather sloppy use of almost scientific language, my skepticism flag went up. But I do wonder if you've ever heard anything similar or can speculate as to the possible validity of the claim.

I'll link the article if you would like to read it. The site is a bit on the "ancient mystery of alchemist hocus pocus" side, but not the worst I've seen :D Doncha love marketing?


http://www.violinvarnish.com/turpentine.htm

Re: Varnish Chemistry and Swedish Wooden ware

#5

hocus pocus indeed

Bill Tindall

Well there is certainly plenty of hocus pocus in the claims. One the one hand they say terpentine makes the oil dry faster while on the other hand it causes the film to be less hard.

Speculation......The reactive sites on the linseed oil molecules are similar to reactive sites on the constituents of turpentine, so one could speculate that once the curing reaction gets going the remaining turpentine would be participating, for better or worse. I could believe there would be differences between mineral spirits and turpentine.

My varnish works adequately with mineral spirits so considering the price difference I will be happy with mineral spirits.