Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

Posts

Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

#1

Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

John McGaw

I'm in the process of prepping the shop for closing up the ceiling. This means fixing a lot of wiring among other things. My existing 240V outlets are kludged with, of all things, the honkin' big outlets used for stoves, dryers, etc. Clearly a case of overkill. On top of that they are temporarily hooked through a junction box buried inside a finished ceiling box fed from what used to be heated-ceiling wiring in the basement of the house. This is a no-no and was meant to be temporary 13 years ago but I've gone straight and have pulled three 10-3 Romex straight from the main panel to feed the shop after the changeover.

Now for the question: what is the correct connector for hooking up 240V shop machines, primarily a big Robland which has three 3HP motors but only runs one at a time, an LT-14 2.5HP bandsaw, and my DC which is now 120V but which I want to change over to 240V. I'm sure that most everybody uses some sort of twist-lock connector but looking at electrical catalogs there seems to be a bunch of different variations on this theme and I only want to do this one time.

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

#2

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

FredD

I use four prong , 20 amp ,250 VAC rated twist lock outlets and connectors.

The connectors are White Nylon and tough and do not fall out or become loose .

They will pass any Inspection , but the down side is they are bit pricey but well worth the peace of mind.

These are the type used in Saw cord Construction extension cords, but made for inside use.

FredD

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

#3

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Different configurations of prongs signal different voltage/amperage combinations, and are standardized in the U.S.

See linky below.


One chart on this subject

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

#4

I don't see any locking plugs or receptacles

Henry Higginbotham

Useful chart, otherwise.

Google for NEMA L6-30

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

#5

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

Rick Christopherson

I wouldn't mention this except you mentioned overkill in your description of the original wiring. None of your circuits needed the 10-3 romex, and could have been served sufficiently with 12-2. Your 3 hp motors can be operated from 20 amp circuits with #12 wire. The only time you need to step up to #10 and a 30 amp circuit is for 5 hp motors. None of your tools should require the neutral, and that is why you didn't need the 3-conductors (plus ground) of the 10-3 romex.

A lot of people advocate pulling the #10 wire "just in case", but then it goes unneeded because most workshops aren't large enough to support having a lot of 5 hp tools. It's not a big deal, but it is also not any fun working with #10 wire in a small box--not to mention that you will have an unused neutral that needs to get tucked in too.

As for the receptacles, for 20 amp circuits you need the NEMA 6-20 straight blade, or the L6-20 twist lock. On the off chance that one of the tools required the neutral, then you would use the L14-20. (or change the last numbers to a 30 if you are going to put these on 30 amp circuits.)

As for your dust collector, if you are wiring in a new circuit, then there is no reason to convert it over to 240 volt operation. Just run a 20 amp, 120 volt circuit for the dust collector and be done with it. If it has the common NEMA 5-15 plug on it, then it cannot exceed 12 amps (a little higher if it doesn't have a UL sticker on it). There is nothing wrong with converting the motor, just that there is no gain in doing so. But there is a risk in doing it of you make a mistake. There is also the added cost of having to put a new plug on it.

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

#6

JL

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

JL

I am a fan of L6-20 receptacles and plugs.

I used L6-30s on my cabinet saw - but it is 5 hp.

Locking receptacles give you that extra "security" - you aren't going to accidentally pull one out.

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

#7

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

John McGaw

Yeah, I understand that I could have used smaller/fewer conductors. The biggest motivation for the size was the length of the run involved -- basically the entire length of the house before it gets to the shop and I wanted to minimize voltage drop. The extra conductor was a 'just in case' for the possibility that I might want to split one of the 240V lines into two 120V. Since the wiring was soon to be buried in finished ceilings in the spare room and the 'library' I decided to pay the extra price and wrestle with the extra stiffness.

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

#8

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

Barry Irby

I think your No. 10 wire is plenty, but the exception might be for the 5hp saw and the DC. In a one man shop you seldom run more than one major tool at a time so the loads don't accumulate or add up, except for the DC and perhaps an Air compressor. My Air compressor is on the same circuit as my DC and its leaks a bit and runs occasionally at random. The shop is in the basement under my bedroom so I turn the circuit off when I leave just so I don't hear the thing in the night. (It annoys my frugal gene more than anything else). So, if I turn on the the DC and nothing happens, I flip the switch and both the DC and Compressor come on at the same time and the start up load is sometimes too high for the breaker. And then there are rare times I do run two tools at the same time along with the DC. So, If you still can I would suggest another home run circuit so you can split things up a bit.

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

#9

Clint Searl

L6-30 for me


Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

#10

Re: Tend to disagree

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I am a firm believer in over-sizing the wiring. Installation of the wiring is usually quite easy when first installing, with easy access to everything. The cost difference is pretty minimal. If you look at what it will cost you in time and / or wall, ceiling damage to replace even one circuit after the shop is complete it would probably pay for all the oversize wiring 5 to 10 times over. When I built my shop I installed all my 220 outlets using #10 wire and 30 amp breakers. At that time I didn't need over 20 amp for any machines. Since then I have replaced my planer with a 20" stationary with a 5 hp motor. I have replaced my small band saw with an MM-16 (4.8 hp), and it is quite possible my air compressor will in the future require a 30 amp circuit and a larger joiner or a shaper may be installed by my son after he takes over the shop. I used standard 30 amp receptacles - It is quite easy to change these if wanted in the future. I have never had any problem "pulling" any plugs out so wouldn't install expensive twistlocks.

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

#11

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

John McGaw

I can confidently say that I will never be getting any 5HP equipment. I find that I use my 3HP stuff far less than I should. Given that this is a one-man shop in a walled-off half of a two car garage I know that I could actually get away with a single 30A 240V circuit since my two power hungry machines will never be used simultaneously and I could almost certainly run my rather small DC off the same circuit at the same time. Having the second 240V circuit is just something that may be done in due course because it is there. I could then use the remaining 10-3 to feed a sub-breaker panel for additional 120V outlets and replace the wiring to the eight 8-foot fluorescents and run it from the sub breaker. That would be an easy fix I guess.

One thing for sure is that any way I attack it there will be a lot of work to be done before I can consider putting up the drywall on the ceiling. Right now I need to go back down there and start rerouting wiring that the builder cleverly ran below the joists to save three inches of Romex or to avoid drilling a hole. It does get interesting in the places where the insulation crew oversprayed and coated the wire to be moved with rock-hard foam. Maybe I'll just replace those runs completely and give up on reusing. I'm getting too old for this...

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

#12

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

You may or may not have needed the extra size, depending on how long the run is. For future reference, there are voltage drop calculators online (Google "voltage drop calculator" for lots of choices). If in doubt, though, you're right: it's always better to go up in gauge than down.

I've started using 4x4 boxes* for every fixture box with more than one cable running into it, mounted 1/16" back from the stud (this is done automatically if you use the nail-on bracket), with a mud ring on top to flush to the face of the sheetrock. It makes stuffing the wires back into the box when installing the fixture (for instance, outlet) ever so much easier, and I know I'm not over-stuffing the box. I do still do the box fill calculation if there are more than two cables entering the box.

*I also use metal boxes, a conservative approach, but one that reduces the chance that someone in future will have to remove the box because the threads strip out of a plastic box.

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

#13

It all depends on knowing your habits...

John in NM

I don't bother oversizing wiring, except the one time I had leftover 10-3 to use rather than buy more 12-2. There's always conduit if you need to upgrade and most never do.

Most of my equipment is older than I am, will never wear out, and will not be upgraded. Usually I spend more on wood than equipment, just my habit. In many cases, I think that people over-wire and then never need the heavier capacity. If they wish to do so, that's their business, not mine - but I'd rather spend the savings on materials than "insurance". I've found there's a balance to be struck between planning for the future and attempting to anticipate every possible future need - and I realize I tend to be in the minority on this.

For those with long runs, like the OP, the Pocket Ref book has both a chart for voltage drop over length of run for various wire sizes, or all the information you need to calculate it in your specific circumstance.

When using heavier wire, I do find that pigtailing the outlet connections makes life a lot easier. But then I do that on 15 amp circuits too.

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

#14

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

Rick Christopherson

Well John, now you've hit the full trifecta. These are the three most common pieces of misinformation that woodworkers will advise other woodworkers to deal with: Everything at 240 needs 10 gauge, motors should be rewired to 240, and finally voltage drop.

The voltage drop comments can be the worst, because I have seen people even bring this up even when the load center is in the same room as the shop. No one ever seems to look into it or think critically about it. It just keeps getting repeated. The simple answer is that as long as you don't live in a McMansion, you don't have to worry about voltage drop.

Voltage drop is simple ohms law. What frequently gets missed is that it is based solely on the actual amperage flowing, not the ampacity of the circuit. You could string a wire from here to the moon, and it will still read 120 volts without a load. The second part of it is that no one thinks critically about what a voltage drop even represents. It was just this weekend on another forum where someone brought up voltage drop concerns, and the calculated voltage drop amounted to 0.96 volts.

The resistivity of #12 copper wire is 0.0015 ohms per foot, and for #10 copper is 0.0010 ohms per foot (a difference of 0.0005 ohms per foot). For a fully loaded #12 wire spanning the length of a typical house, the voltage drop will be about 2-3 volts. Your utility voltage will fluctuate more than this throughout a single day. But what's more interesting is that upsizing to #10 wire will reduce this by only 0.5-1.0 volt.

Your wiring is already installed, so I am not trying to be critical of you. I am just trying to educate the other woodworkers that may be reading this in preparation for their own work.

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

#15

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

FredD

If you get the feeling your beating a dead horse Rick , I wouldn't be surprised. ;-))

One thing that hasn't been addressed is the sensitivity of some Motors to minute voltage drops .

I had a Trim Carpenter on a interior Trim crew whose Pancake compressor would not run unless it was plugged directly into a outlet in the house, not a extension cord, even a ten foot one.

The only time I ran across that , but I have since read , some motors and appliances, cheaply made will run badly or not at all with a even a slight Voltage drop.

FredD

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

#16

Re: Wiring for 240V Shop Equipment

John McGaw

"Well John, now you've hit the full trifecta. These are the three most common pieces of misinformation that woodworkers will advise other woodworkers to deal with: Everything at 240 needs 10 gauge, motors should be rewired to 240, and finally voltage drop."

Well, I don't know if I hit anything. I understand good ol' Ohm's Law pretty well and know about voltage drops and realize that motors don't need to be 240V. I put in 10-3 because I didn't know what I was going to be doing some years down the road. Fact is that I'm doing it right now and I still don't know which way I might finish the job but the fact that a box of 10-3 was enough to give me three runs from the house's outside breaker box to the closest wall of my shop was as much reason as I needed at the moment. It was preordained.

As for needing 10-gauge, the steady state current draw of even an inefficient induction motor would allow for something less than 12A draw and could be run on 14-gauge. Of course the high surge current at startup, different for every motor and every application I've seen, might mean a momentary draw of twice that much and having power wiring big enough to cover that momentary pulse without choking the flow certainly can't hurt anything.

I can think of one really good reason for converting my DC to 240V that nobody touched on and I failed to mention: all of the remote start units for DCs that I've seen allow for 1.5HP under 120V while the 240V version, presumably using the same relay or contactor, will support 2 or 3HP with no problem. I want to use a wired remote switched by each of my air gates so the simple virtually free switch to 240V seems reasonable. Why stress the contacts in a 120V unit and possibly shorten its life considerably?

At the rate I'm progressing with this I might be able to go through a half dozen different 'correct' methods before I get done. :b