Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

WB poly over Watco Danish oil

Posts

WB poly over Watco Danish oil

#1

WB poly over Watco Danish oil

Ken

Can I use water based poly over Danish oil? If so how long does the oil have to dry? I am building a bookshelf and finishing prior to final assembly. The Watco has been applied. I would like to use WB as my shop is in the basement and ventilation is minimal.

Thanks for any advice.

Ken

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

#2

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

Bill Tindall

For the 100 or more years before water based finishes were developed people used solvent based varnish indoors without concern or adverse effect. Professional painters used such finishes daily. With this record it doesn't seem necessary to avoid them today.

I have yet to see a water based finish that has the sparkle of a traditional finish.

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

#3

Clint Searl

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

Clint Searl

I'd give it at least a week, but you won't have a problem. If the Watco has no odor after a week, you're good to go. Rub the Watco down with a maroon scotchbrite and proceed with a couple coats. It'll sparkle :D

Clint

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

#4

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

FredD

On the Watco cans I have , it says wait 72 hours to apply a finish coat, water based , I couldn't say, never used it , never will.

FredD

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

#5

Clint Searl

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

Clint Searl

Fred, having no admitted experience with water borne poly, it seems a bit presumptuous to imply that it's somehow inferior to oils/lacquers. Have you never used it on a floor, where it's probably the most popular finish?

Clint

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

#6

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

Alex Grigoriev

"For the 100 or more years before water based finishes were developed people used solvent based varnish indoors without concern or adverse effect"

Yep, but if a guy died of brain cancer or something, it was not a big deal. Everybody dies, some do go in pain. Who would care to collect statistics then? And there was no X-ray or MRI, too.

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

#7

I have experience..... all disappointing

Bill Tindall

I finished an ash floor with the most expensive catalyzed material available from the flooring materials supplier. I went with water based material because I needed a non-yellowing finish over white ash. It is both softer than the best solvent urethane varnish and substantially less bright. Water based material is used on floors for one reason....speed. It dries quick so the finisher is done days sooner, or in my case because it is non-yellowing.

I finished an out door oak table with a water based "exterior" urethane from Target, again because I needed a non-yellowing finish. Actually the table lived on a covered porch out of the weather. Finish was the typical dull luster I expect from water based finish. It molded and turned black in places; disintegrated where the sun hit it.....after 15 months. I have had adhesion issues with this stuff on other indoor projects.

If one thinks that using a water based product prevents exposure to chemical vapor you are not knowledgeable of how these materials are formulated. They all rely on a coalescencing solvent, 30% or so, to enable the latex to form a film after the water evaporates. The film cures (hardens) by evaporation of this solvent. The notion that these finishes are safer just because they smell different is unjustified. There is no reason to believe that mineral spirits is significantly different hazard than 2,2,4-Trimethyl-1,3-pentanediol monoisobutyrate coaleascing solvent.

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

#8

do you have data to support your claim?

Bill Tindall

See post below on solvents in water based finishes.

If you wish to avoid exposure to mineral spirits or similar hydrocarbons in traditional varnishes, and to be consistent wear a respirator while refueling, that is a person choice that I have no reservations accepting. But if you want to convince others of a hazard then back up the warning with data.

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

#9

Clint Searl

Re: I have experience..... all disappointing

Clint Searl

Bill, my experience with water borne poly, mostly Varathane and some Minwax to be specific, is limited to indoor furniture and trim, and in that setting it has performed in the brush-on application and service most acceptably. Nary a problem with adhesion or gloss over bare wood or or wood that has been oil stained or colored with latex/acrylic pigment paint. I can only speculate on your negative experience; maybe it's technique, wrist action...who knows.

Clint

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

#10

Re: do you have data to support your claim?

Alex Grigoriev

Back "100 or more years", before petroleum distillates were industrially produced, it was turpentine that was used as a solvent. Turpentine vapor inhalation causes respiratory and lung irritation and damage, and also central nervous system effects. Those days, there was no OSHA.

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

#11

Re:Again Alex - Do you have Data

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I am 70 years old - smoke, used turpentine, Triclorethelene 111, Acetone, mineral spirits, Toulene, Naptha, Carbon tetracloride (fire extinguishers) and a lot of asbestos etc. for several years. I used these chemicals a lot as a result of my Engineering and contracting professions. When I worked in a large electrical motor / control repair shop, we washed our hands in a bucket of used transformer oil, laden with pcbs. As of this date I have had no effects. I am quite sure that something will kill me in the next few years. I am not being factious, but do feel that OSHA and the EPA blow many things way out of proportion. I probably wouldn't do some of the things I have done in the past due to all the warnings, but if the warnings were even close to accurate I would be buried years ago. I am sure that some of the chemicals used did harm some people - but how many and how much is in my mind still to be determined. As a young lad I did know several old men that were professional painters - (in their late 60's and 70's). This was in the 1950's and face masks, ventilation were not used or even considered. I feel sure that if they died early it was more from Alcohol (the drinking kind) rather than from any exposure to other chemicals.

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

#12

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

FredD

Let's try one more time Clint .

I never said I didn't any experience with Water borne finishes, quite the contrary, I have watched many a contractor get in trouble with it and then comes the phone call, can you help us?

What I did say was "I have never used it and never will" based on my observations of what happens when a Amateur gets in the mix and unhappy clients of other Contractors.

The Last major interior trim Job I did was in BlackHawk ,Ca. in a 2 -1/2 millon dollar house built specially for the clients wife who had purchased all of Emily Post's One and one-half million dollars worth of antiques to be on display as her furniture and accouterments.

The Oak flooring laid though out the house which was a duplicate of the one in "Gone with the Wind" was laid by guys who got paid by the foot . not the hour and when the finish crew showed up they applied Water Borne Poly with a wide rubber bladed , long handled tool after the guy walking ahead of it poured the Poly on the floor and the Squeegee guy spread it.

Needless to say , as Bill surely knows , the next morning when the East Sun came though those ten foot high windows, every pass with the Squeegee left a lap mark , you could see from a long ways away.

After the client who was a Investment Banker explained to the flooring company what his Lawyer would do to them, the crew was fired , the floor was stripped and a company I recommended applied a Solvent based Swedish finish called Glitza which is as good as there is in floor finishes and one your probably not familiar with Clint.

The Lawsuit was avoided and the Flooring contractor ate that job because he was not competent and not familiar with Water Borne floor finish.

In my career as a General Contractor , I rapidly learned it was prudent and cost efficient to avoid others mistakes. I guess you could say that is my experience.

FredD

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

#13

Clint Searl

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

Clint Searl

So what you're still saying, Fred, is that you, yourself, don't have experience using a water borne poly. You simply witnessed an instance of poor workmanship having nothing to do with the finish, per se. If there's a moral to your story, it might be to follow application instructions and guidlines faithfully.

Clint

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

#14

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

BilWil

I have used water based poly, a number of brands, over Watco, Waterlox, and oil based stains. I ALWAYS wait two weeks before I put on water base over oil base. I know, overkill, but haven't had porblems yet, and that is what I judge by. If you really want to be absolutely sure put on a coat of 1 pound wax free shellac and then put on the water based poly.

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

#15

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

FredD

I gotta ask you Clint , did you have to grab something hot to get the idea?

I only related the one instance , since the telling the whole of a contracting career would take a book.

Like I said , I learn from other people's mistakes.

FredD

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

#16

Clint Searl

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

Clint Searl

But you're missing half the fun, Fred. ;)

Clint

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

#17

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

Ken

Thanks all for your input. I will be using the water based poly after 2 weeks of drying time for the Danish oil.

Health concerns are not an issue for me. As a previous poster I have worked with many materials over the years, including asbestos, lead, PCB's and radiation. I am 72 and healthy as a horse! Many of the so called hazards defined today are way over blown. It is comical to me when a drop of PCB occurs in a building there is an army of people all over it. I used to dive into high voltage transformer housings with my arms up past my elbows making adjustments and repairs. We even used it to clean grease from our hands.

In my current situation it is not the health hazard but the annoyance of the fumes from the other, non water based, coatings.

Thanks again,

Ken

Re: WB poly over Watco Danish oil

#18

To Answer the Question.....

Howard Acheson

.... yes, you can over coat Watco with a waterborne clear acrylic finish. However, acrylic is more imperious to air than oil based so you need to allow a longer period for the Watco to fully dry. 5 - 7 days would be adequate.