Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

OT - maybe a stupid Q' about ceiling fans

Posts

OT - maybe a stupid Q' about ceiling fans

#1

OT - maybe a stupid Q' about ceiling  fans

Terry Alexander

Ok......because I just don't know.

I have several ceiling fans and I love running them.

Now for the stupid question:

Would a ceiling fan use more electricity at low speed than high speed?

TIA

Terry Alexander in West Texas

Re: OT - maybe a stupid Q' about ceiling fans

#2

Re: OT - maybe a stupid Q' about ceiling  fans

John McGaw

Well, physics tells me that moving a lot of air requires more expenditure than moving a little bit of air so I'll have to vote for high speed using more power. This discounts the possibility that the designer/maker used some weird method of slowing down the blades but I doubt even the worst Rube Golodberg-esqe design would make it to market to throw off my guess.

Surprisingly, if you take a vacuum cleaner and hold your hand over the intake you will hear the motor speed up. In this state it is probably using less power than before you blocked it since it is moving no (or only a little motor cooling) air thus requiring less power.

Re: OT - maybe a stupid Q' about ceiling fans

#3

Re: OT - maybe a stupid Q' about ceiling  fans

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Things in this thread are mostly true, HOWEVER they do not apply to all motors. Some speed controllers use resistors and such to eat up the unused power as heat. Therefore there is no power savings at lower speeds in those situations.

Re: OT - maybe a stupid Q' about ceiling fans

#4

OUCH ! Good one !


Re: OT - maybe a stupid Q' about ceiling fans

#5

Steve Strickland

Re: OT - maybe a stupid Q' about ceiling  fans

Steve Strickland

While a vacuum cleaner may not be moving air when the hose is blocked, it is lifting air against atmospheric pressure and is consuming maximum power in the attempt to do so.

Even the strongest vacuum can't lift mercury more than 32". There's a maximum height for lifting water by vacuum, too.

Re: OT - maybe a stupid Q' about ceiling fans

#6

Re: OT - maybe a stupid Q' about ceiling  fans

John McGaw

Would I lie? Well, maybe if there was a lot of money involved but my measuring instruments don't. Measured with a Brand Electronics power meter my Fein Turbo III draws ~1210W in full-flow mode with a relatively clean paper bag and HEPA filters and ~815W under blocked-hose (turbine screaming) conditions.

If it wasn't such a PITA I'd go ahead and hook up the meter to one of my ceiling fans and try to answer that question definitively but stuffing that wiring into the crowded boxes was bad enough the first time.

Re: OT - maybe a stupid Q' about ceiling fans

#7

Re: OT - maybe a stupid Q' about ceiling  fans

Jesse Cloud

In any case, I think the power consumption on most ceiling fans is very low...