True grit?
Clint Searl
Does sharpening stone grit equate to the grit of wet/dry silicon carbide paper? And how does grit translate to mesh size?
Clint
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
True grit?
Clint Searl
Does sharpening stone grit equate to the grit of wet/dry silicon carbide paper? And how does grit translate to mesh size?
Clint
Re: True grit?
Moses Yoder
No, and very carefully. I think the only way to make any personal decisions on the subject is to experiment.
Re: True grit?
In a word: Sorta
There are so many variables, of which grit size is one, that as Moses said you just have to experiment and see what works for you. If you Google "grit size comparison" or something similar, you will get about a million choices of grit size charts. Take them with a serious grain of salt (fine grit salt is O.K., but you might need to go to coarse) You also need to take into account the binder, the material of the grit, the amount of the grit, the shape of the grit and on and on.
Re: P.S.
Moses Yoder
If you are setting up a sharpening system, a simple and relatively inexpensive system is a 1000, 4000, and 8000 grit water stones. I honestly think this system is cheaper than using sandpaper for sharpening, (although the inital cost is higher), is not as fussy to set up, and is faster and more effective. Another thing I mean to look into is sharpening on cast iron plate with diamonds, but I may not actually get that done until my water stones are worn out. There is quite a bit of stuff in the hand tool archives on sharpening with diamond.
and in addition.....
Bill Tindall
the scratch depth and profile from each abrasive material is different even at the same particle size.
Re: and in addition.....
Jesse Cloud
and manufacturers vary on the variation in the grit. Every sheet of xx grit will have some particles smaller and some larger than xx.
Re: True grit?
Clint Searl
Well. Sorta, you came closest to answering the question. I'm quite satisfied with my collection of oil stones. About the only ones I use are a Norton India and fine Aluminum Oxide. Finishing on a waxed linen followed by a cordovan strop, the edge is sharp enough to shave with. The hard and soft Arkansas and ceramic stones just sit in the communal kerosene bath. I'll occassionally touch up a chisel edge on wet 600 silicon carbide paper.
Clint