Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

walnut rant

Posts

walnut rant

#1

walnut rant

Ryan in Vancouver

What gives with the quality of black walnut these days? The last couple of lots of black walnut I bought are certainly the dregs from the forest. Even the guys at the hardwood warehouse agree. Lots of sapwood, almost no heartwood or colour and yet they are still charging premium dollar - even though I got a break because I complained.

Is any one else finding this a problem, especially those of you back east? Or are they keeping the best for the local market and exporting the junk?

There. Now I feel better.

Re: walnut rant

#2

Re: walnut rant

McKay Sleight

We have three large hardwood dealers in the Salt Lake area that would deliver wood to the school when I taught there. Most of the walnut was ok, but local walnut was much better colored. I have a former student that goes back east about two times a year and he picked up some cherry, walnut and quartered white oak. I had no idea that there was such nice wood available. It confirms that, at least the schools, were getting the picked through material.

Re: walnut rant

#3

Re: walnut rant

john lucas

We have the same problem here. Our wood is harvested locally and they just can't find large trees. There is a lot of sapwood and wide boards just don't happen.

Re: walnut rant

#4

Re: walnut rant

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

Maybe shipping is being banned in order to combat the walnut canker fungus. My last batch was purchased in the spring. The quality was quite good although the price made cherry look like a bargain.

Re: walnut rant

#5

Re: walnut rant

Jim Hoeller

I would urge anyone looking for a decent selection of locally grown hardwoods to find and get to know the owners of custom sawmills. Especially those in urban areas. They work with developers and municipal/county arborists to make use of trees that need to be cut. Some have logging trucks that will pick up logs you may come across at a relative's or on a neighbor's property. I was pleasantly surprised at the quantity of good hardwoods cut locally.

Woodmizer at one time offered the names and phone numbers of their customers that wanted to attract business. This was about 25 or 30 years ago.

Good luck

Re: walnut rant

#6

Re: walnut rant

Yonak

The last time I checked, Wood-Mizer South in Newnan, Georgia keeps an active index of Wood-Mizer owners, most of whom can be contacted for sawing services. Some of them carry inventories and some offer drying. Also, locally, there are some sawyers who specialize in urban wood harvesting.

Re: walnut rant

#7

straightforward explanation

Bill Tindall

1. Walnut is not a common species so there isn't a lot of it.

2. Walnut has gotten popular again (the fashion for light wood-dark wood cycles and we are in a walnut peak cycle)

3. Veneer plants have learned to get get acceptable yield from logs as small as 12". Veneer mills will pay more for logs than saw mills. So veneer mills buy the best logs leaving small logs or knotty logs for the saw mills. (a veneer mill gets 32 "boards per inch)

4. The large buyers of walnut don't care if the wood is sap or not. Hence, the grading rules don't consider sapwood a defect. Walnut has special grading rules allowing some of what would otherwise be #1 common lumber to be graded as FAS.

Leading to the bottom line of poor quality , relative to other species, lumber being all that is available when the species gets popular. I have recently seen 8" logs on log yards. The log pile looked like firewood!

My advice on cherry and walnut is to buy it any time you see some desirable stuff. It will be the one of the best investments you can make.

If thousand canker disease spreads as it as is feared walnut will be extinct in a few decades. Then a stash of this wood will be worth a fortune.

Re: walnut rant

#8

Re: straightforward explanation

John McGaw

Probably five years back when I was actively working on my sawmill list I ran into two mills in this area, one just over the NC border and one up north toward the VA border, who had huge amounts of walnut in their yards and available on contract in the woods and their complaint was that they couldn't give the stuff away -- nobody wanted it. Things were tough enough on the walnut front that they offered me a kickback if I could steer anybody to them to buy walnut. Guess that the turnaround came as a pleasant surprise to them, assuming that they didn't convert all of their walnut into firewood for sale.

Re: walnut rant

#9

Re: walnut rant

BilWil

Here in MI I phone LL Johnson and tell them what I'm looking for and so long as I am ordering 100bf+ they tell me when it will be ready. Yes, I do pay more than I would like, however, the same thing is happening to cherry.

Re: walnut rant

#10

Walnut Quarantine

Howard Acheson

Google "Walnut Quarantine" and you will see what it having a big effect on the supply and price of walnut. A number of states including Pennsylvania, Virginia and Ohio have quarantines in effect.