straightforward explanation
Bill Tindall
1. Walnut is not a common species so there isn't a lot of it.
2. Walnut has gotten popular again (the fashion for light wood-dark wood cycles and we are in a walnut peak cycle)
3. Veneer plants have learned to get get acceptable yield from logs as small as 12". Veneer mills will pay more for logs than saw mills. So veneer mills buy the best logs leaving small logs or knotty logs for the saw mills. (a veneer mill gets 32 "boards per inch)
4. The large buyers of walnut don't care if the wood is sap or not. Hence, the grading rules don't consider sapwood a defect. Walnut has special grading rules allowing some of what would otherwise be #1 common lumber to be graded as FAS.
Leading to the bottom line of poor quality , relative to other species, lumber being all that is available when the species gets popular. I have recently seen 8" logs on log yards. The log pile looked like firewood!
My advice on cherry and walnut is to buy it any time you see some desirable stuff. It will be the one of the best investments you can make.
If thousand canker disease spreads as it as is feared walnut will be extinct in a few decades. Then a stash of this wood will be worth a fortune.