Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Veedddy interesting *LINK*

Posts

Veedddy interesting *LINK*

#1

Veedddy interesting *LINK*

john lucas

Some of you may have heard about Gibson guitar being raided by the feds for having east indian rosewood. I think you'll find this interesting.


http://landmarkreport.com/andrew/2011/08/ceo-of-gibson-guitar-a-republican-donor/

Re: Veedddy interesting *LINK*

#2

Sorry, didn't see Craig's post below


Re: Veedddy interesting *LINK*

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: Veedddy interesting

Moses Yoder

I personally am not offended at your post, I just thought it was against the rules to discuss politics on the board.

Re: Veedddy interesting *LINK*

#5

Re: Veedddy interesting

FredD

me too

FredD

Re: Veedddy interesting *LINK*

#6

Agree, and... *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

The writer of the article took a clip from the entire story (which I easily found by googling elsewhere) and "spun" it to imply that politics is involved. I don't object to the story or the discussion of it, as it very much applies to woodworking. I do object to the far flung conspiracy therories of the writer.

The real story as it applies to our collective interest is that Gibson is thought by some to be in violation of law in ANOTHER COUNTRY. While on the surface this seems Un-American, the act is one of the only ways our law enforcement people can help stop trade in endangered plants and animals. Apparently the "Lacey Act" is what Gibson is thought to have violated in this matter. We aren't given enough information in the article to decide for ourselves objectively, and will have to leave it up to the courts.

If you do research on that act, you will find that this is the US law that makes it a crime to import plants and animals that are illegal to harvest in other countries. I think most of us have have come around to agreeing that it is best to prosecute those who import illegal ivory, for example. Again, I am not saying Gibson did anything wrong here at all. Indeed it appears that they haven't, but we don't have all of the facts, nor are we in a position to make a fair determination.

I think it best we focus on what the law means to our hobby/livelyhood and move on with making beautiful things from wood, while minimizing the impact of our activities on the planet.

I have linked to a brief about the Lacey Act act for your reading pleasure below.


Lacey Act FAQ

Re: Veedddy interesting *LINK*

#7

Interesting post Grant...

John in NM

The grey area here seems to come from whether this aspect of the Lacey Act is intended to prevent importation of illegally harvested materials, or to prevent circumventing protectionist global trade laws of another country. The trouble is it's likely going to come down to judgement at the enforcement level, and which side that judgement falls on seems to change with the political winds.

Re: Veedddy interesting *LINK*

#8

Re: Political post

Nelson

Yes it is and every person on this board should write,call their Senator/Congressman and tell them what an injustice this is to not only Gibson but any company.Gibson has not been charged yet but their competiors using the same wood have not had their plants invaded.