Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Learning to French Polish - long

Posts

Learning to French Polish - long

#1

Learning to French Polish - long

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hello.

I've been trying to teach myself how to French Polish with Shellac. Progress is kinda slow, but I think I'm making progress based on some earlier advice given here and reading some books along with a Jeff Jewitt video I have.

I went to the fabric store and bought some linen and some muslin for making the rubber. I wanted to try both. I had been trying to use some old t-shirts and other material but I was having problems. I wondered if the problems I was having were related to that material, and that is why I bought the fabric I did; the video and other things I read said to use either of these materials, so I thought I should. I think it made a difference. So far, I think the linen works a little better because it has a much smoother texture than the muslin I bought.

I am trying to french polish a couple small boxes I made from (very) curly maple. Maybe not the best material to try learning with. Even though I prepared the surface well (I think), it is a little wavy from the curl. So its not super flat if that makes a difference. On one of the boxes, I applied some trans-tint early american maple waterbased dye. On both, I applied a little BLO. I really like the color of both and the grain looks really nice.

After applying the BLO and dye, I sanded as a final prep. Then I started the build up stage.

For my rubber I used the mentioned linen. For the interior material I used old t-shirt. I know Mr. Stephen Shepherd mentioned in an earlier post about using cotton balls but I am using t-shirt. I squirt equal amounts of DNA and shellac onto the interior material that has been balled up. I am using zinser sealcoat. I haven't tried mixing my own yet. I try to ball up the interior material so there are no high spots on the outside of the rubber.

Getting the correct amount of DNA and shellac into the rubber seems to be a challenge. I never know how wet is wet enough. I read, and the Jeff Jewitt video says as wet as a dogs' nose, but not too sure really what that means. I have two Golden Retrievers right now and their noses are always really wet or bone dry, so I'm not sure which to go by... :)

So, once I have the rubber ready, I start to apply. Oh, one more thing, I apply a few drops (give or take) of baby oil to the surface of the rubber too. Applying the shellac seems to go well as long as I have enough oil on the rubber. I've tried not using oil and the rubber starts to stick quickly.

There seems to be a fine line between having the proper amounts of shellac, DNA, and oil on/in the rubber to get it to apply nicely. That is, to put down a nice layer of shellac and glide nicely across the surface. In the video, and numerous YouTube videos I've watched, the rubber seems to be gliding across the surface laying down a nice thin wet layer of shellac effortlessly.

I've done this 'build up' stage a number of times now. The oil seems to migrate to the surface just like I read it will. I am able to remove the oil using a rag that has just a tiny about of DNA on it.

Between build-up stages I've had to wet sand very lightly sometimes. This is due to nibs, dust, or just plain screw-ups (smudges or whatnot). More often than not, I see little swirls where the shellac didn't seem to lay down properly or melt into the previous coat - that is one of my biggest issues so far. How do I not get these little swirls?

I've done about 5 or so of these build ups now. Last night I did what I thought would be the last one. This morning though I see some of these little swirls. So I guess I will have to sand again and try another 'one last coat'.

I suppose I could try some polishing compound or auto polish and some wax and it would probably be fine in regards to removing the little swirls and be done with it. But I'd like to get a higher gloss. So I want to really polish it like in the books and video.

In the video, the last stage is done with just shellac and no DNA in the rubber. You start to apply and once the rubber (I think) dries out, you keep rubbing briskly to stretch out the shellac and bring up the shine - I guess it's actually burnishing. Does this sound reasonable?

I have to say that on one of the box tops, the one with the early american maple dye, somehow the it came out really nice. The gloss looks great as well as the figure. I haven't messed with it any further - don't want to ruin it. I'm not sure what I did different on this top but it looks great.

Once I get this technique figured out, I can see I think I'm going to like this whole shellac thing like some of you talk about here. :) I really hate finishing too.

I hope, for my next project, to make a Shaker style candle stand. I think I have enough of this curly maple left at least for the top. If I can get this shellac thing down, I think that's how the top will be finished...

That's my journey so far with French Polishing. Thanks for reading this long winded post. If you have any additional advice to pass along, I'm all ears.

P.S.

I went over to Jeff Jewitt's shop a few months and bought his finishing DVD. I've found it to be very helpful. You might also.

No affiliation. I just live close to his shop. :)

Re: Learning to French Polish - long

#2

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Learning to French Polish - long

Stephen Shepherd

Joe,

Anything like old tee shirts or old denim can be used inside the pad.

'In the video, the last stage is done with just shellac and no DNA in the rubber. You start to apply and once the rubber (I think) dries out, you keep rubbing briskly to stretch out the shellac and bring up the shine - I guess it's actually burnishing. Does this sound reasonable? '

I have not heard of that one before. I have however 'spirit up' a French polish finish, a traditional technique where only alcohol [no shellac] is added to the pad at the end and used to 'spirit up' or 'spirit out' the finish.

Stephen

Re: Learning to French Polish - long

#3

Re: Learning to French Polish - long

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Hi Joe,

I too have been slowly trying to learn to french polish. I've been using a piece of old bed-sheet which I dampen with 50-50 BLO/Turps, then for the inside I've been using cotton balls that I've dipped in 50-50 DNA-Zinsser dewaxed shellac. (as I had the dewaxed on hand). I'm applying it to a 9x12" cherry top on a monitor riser I made for someone.

I've only done a couple of passes at this point and am beginning to get a feel for the rubbing out phase of things. From what I've done so far it seems like I just need to work at it a little more in order to develop a feel for the whole process in order to get more consistent and predictable results. Time will tell.

Glad to know I'm not the only one who is dabbling with this process.

Bob in NJ.

Re: Learning to French Polish - long

#4

Re: Learning to French Polish - long

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Best of luck to you Bob. I've just about given up.

I don't get what the trick is. I keep getting swirls of shellac. It looks like the oil until it dries. Then I see it's shellac. Or, I leave it sit all night and the next day it looks perfect until I remove the oil and see there isn't any shellac.

Good luck.

Re: Learning to French Polish - long

#5

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Learning to French Polish - long

Stephen Shepherd

Joe,

Don't give up! I think I know what the problem is and how to solve it. I just helped a lady in Arizona out with a similar problem, she was using mineral oil on her pad and said that it looked good until the next day, when the oil went away.

I had her get a drying oil [linseed oil, walnut oil, poppyseed oil or hemp seed oil] on her pad rather than mineral oil. She called me up and told me that that was the problem and the French polish on her violin now looks great.

Try using blo on your pad.

Stephen

Re: Learning to French Polish - long

#6

Re: Learning to French Polish - long

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks again Stephen.

I'll give blo a try this weekend when I work on it again.

Joe