Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

How to attach/opp grain

Posts

How to attach/opp grain

#1

How to attach/opp grain

Greg Muller


I am making a library stand. The picture shows the under side of the top. My question is how to attache the angled pieces to the under side. I have made a dado for the angle piece to sit in. Can i glue it or will movement crack it. If I can't glue it do I screw it from the top and then plug the holes.

Re: How to attach/opp grain

#2

Yes, movement will probably crack the top *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Too late now, but a sliding dovetail, glued at one end only, might have been a better joinery solution. At this point, screws are probably your best bet, but even screws from the top could create a problem - the cleats will not change their length much, the top will change its width. What you want to avoid is attaching the cleats in a way that will prevent the top from changing width with the seasons.

Traditionally, the maker chooses one edge that will hold still, and fastens the rest of the width (of the top, in this case) in a way that allows movement. Screw fasteners are usually put in slotted holes, longer as you get farther away from the fixed point.

Will these cleats be, in turn, fastened to a framework of some sort? If so, you might be able to use buttons (wooden) or clips (metal). If not, I suppose you could fasten cleats to the side of the existing cleats, and make your screw holes into the top in those...but that starts to look like one of those mistake correcting moves.

You could, I suppose, counterbore holes from the bottom of the cleats, then drill screw holes into the top - depending on how much thickness you've got left in your top in those dadoes. But you'd have to sort out how to "slot" your holes at the moving end. Some folks will ream out the hole in the direction of movement in a funnel shape, leaving enough meat at the top to engage the screwhead and using flathead screws; the idea is that the screw then flexes to the wood movement. I've never tried it, and it always seemed like a recipe for disaster down the road, as the screw either wallowed out the wood into which it was driven or broke.

Someone will no doubt be along in a minute with a good solution, as opposed to this rambling.


FWW on the subject

Re: How to attach/opp grain

#3

Re: How to attach/opp grain

John Pappas

How about attaching some cleats, or even a strip of wood, to the angled piece and drill some slotted holes in the cleats (or strip). Also might want to use some washers to help things move easily.

Re: How to attach/opp grain

#4

Re: How to attach/opp grain

Bill Tindall

One end can be glued. If you glue the front ends then over time that joint will stay in alignment and the comings and goings will be at the back side.

You could angle some screws in from the bottom side. Or cut a narrow dado in the feet and attach top with "table top fasteners", either bought or home made.

Re: How to attach/opp grain

#5

Re: How to attach/opp grain

Greg Muller

If I were to start with a new top what would be the prefered method. The angles will be dadoed into feet and attached to a bottom shelf. The top has to be able to hold approx 45 pounds at an angle. A large piece of wood will be displayed on it. I like both suggestions so far but I am open to anything that works and will look professional. This piece will be on display at the Village Hall of the municipality that I work for.

Re: How to attach/opp grain

#6

Re: How to attach/opp grain

Greg Muller

Bill,

Do you think I could pocket screw the front and table top fastern the rear. As I said there will be a lot of weight on it and it needs to be at an angle for display. I am very concerned about keeping the top fasterned to the angled part.

Re: How to attach/opp grain

#7

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: How to attach/opp grain

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Too bad you've already cut the dados. This would've been a great place to use a sliding dovetail.

That said, what about gluing the front 1½~2 inches, and using brads at the back, driven at a nearly horizontal angle across the leg and into the top on the other side of the dado? One nail driven thru each way (from either side) near the back will hold the legs firmly and still allow for seasonal movement.

Re: How to attach/opp grain

#8

Jim/New Top

Greg Muller

Jim,

Making a new top is not a problem. I have never done a sliding dovetail but am willing to give a try. Can you point me to a good resource on how to do it.

Re: How to attach/opp grain

#9

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Jim/New Top *LINK*

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Derek Cohen, a regular here, has a really nice tutorial on his website. He cuts the tails with a dovetail plane, but they could be done easily at the router table, too.


Derek Cohen's website

Re: How to attach/opp grain

#10

As is is fine

Bill Tindall

I don't see anything wrong with what you have. Glue the first 2-3" and table top fasten the back. If you are concerned about sideways stiffness then bridge across the back of the feet with a 3/4 x 2-3" piece set on edge (perpendicular to the surface it will set on).

A shoulder would have made the assembly more stable to sideways forces. I would have used a smaller dado and rabbited the "feet" such that the sticky out part of the feet rabbit would snugly fit into the dado in the top. The rabbit's shoulder would stiff against sideways forces.

Re: How to attach/opp grain

#11

Re: As is is fine

Greg Muller

Bill,

Reading through your message gave me an idea. How about two cleats attached to the top and bottom of the under side of the shelf runnung horizontal with the grain. dado them into the feet useing a full 3/4 dado slot. the cleat can be glued to the dado and the top should still be able to move. 3/4 x 2 glued on the face or glued on the 3/4 side? I understand what you mean about stiffness but the piece of wood that will be displayed is a round slice that is about 28 inches across. I am more worried about the downward pushing force then the shelf bowing. What do you think.