Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

I may never buy stain again!

Posts

I may never buy stain again!

#1

I may never buy stain again!

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

First, to be clear, I hate adding color to wood. But...the customer is always right.

I am doing what I hope is the last of a bunch of built-in floor to ceiling bookshelves. For some reason, I could not get the right shade and I was running out of time. Turns out I have a great lacquer supplier - a good color man. I took my sample boards to him and asked for a quick solution. He mixed a toned shellac that fixed everything. Sprayed on nicely, dry in ten minutes, though I will wait until tomorrow to spray lacquer. Looks great and oh so much easier than applying multiple coats of stain!

Now I need a paint shaker so I can brew my own!

Re: I may never buy stain again!

#2

Careful

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Carol,

I've been coloring shellac coats for a bunch of years, mostly to blend different parts on the same piece as in cherry and walnut. The problem comes in when you try to apply too much leading to blotches, lap marks, etc. BTW, I always spray so that I can back way off on the material knob and lay on a very fine mist to push the color to build the tone.

I mix my own using a pale shade of dewaxed shellac and then add Transtint alcohol-based dyes. Wouldn't be surprised if your color man does the same thing.

Other thing you need to worry about is too much shellac under another finish, especially the new waterborne finishes. Since you mentioned lacquer, I'll anticipate that you're going with NC solvent product. That's fine, But I strongly suggest, even in your AZ location, to give the shellac a bit more time to get rid of its solvent. I routinely wait 3-4 days on shellac so that I'm comfortable that there's no more VOC (alcohol) present to mess with the topcoat's chemistry.

Re: I may never buy stain again!

#3

Re: Careful

Jesse Cloud

+1 on Mark's advice about letting the shellac cure. Even here in New Mexico ('monsoon' season but 5 per cent humidity), I get some bleed thru between shellac and 'alcohol based' dyes. I suspect the formulations involve many more solvents than alcohol to provide longer shelf life and other 'benefits'. One good reason to mix your own shellac.

Re: I may never buy stain again!

#4

Re: Careful

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

It is monsooning as I type. Messing up my schedule, too!

I sprayed early this afternoon. I won't shoot lacquer until Friday.

I used my Apollo HVLP gun and it went slicker than wax. Great clarity for the grain. And so easy to do. I have lots of experience with my gun, so I was confident I could make it work. It did. I'm happy,

My color guy used his regular tints as for paint and his paint shaker. I want to try Transtint for the next job which is a custom color.

Gonna have to find a quart sized paint shaker. :)

Re: I may never buy stain again!

#5

Leave The Shakin'

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

to the quakes. Transtints and shellac form solution without any shaking. You do, however, want to let them sit 5-6 hours or so to let the dye fully disperse. For added clarity, mix your shellac then run it through a coffee filter before adding the dye. You'll always have a few spoonfuls of liquid that won't move through the filter; just pitch it. You'll notice a marked difference in the clarity of the shellac.

The attached are three mini urns I did this summer for a dear friend's widow and sons. The burl (maple) was dyed with transtint, then sanded, bleached, dyed again and sealed with blue tinted shellac, and lastly lacquered. The chatoyence and depth were incredible. (Silver inlaid after the shellac)

Re: I may never buy stain again!

#6

Re: Leave The Shakin'

Woodie49

Mark, any more details on how you did that finish?

Thanks

Re: I may never buy stain again!

#7

Re: Leave The Shakin'

paul in AZ

I too don't like changing the natural color of wood but a while back tried some dyes with painful results. Stains and dyes must work for some people. Not me. Its a good thing I don't like them very much.

From that I went to shellac tinted with a German universal colorant. Forget the brand. I added a few drops at a time to get pretty much the shade I wanted. That mostly worked OK. In doing so I made all the mistakes Mark mentions. The worst was a blotchy job from putting in too much color and not getting it dispersed well enough. I still like tinting shellac enough to do it again if the need arises.

Re: I may never buy stain again!

#8

Finish

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Hi Woodie. Hope you're not in a hurry ;)

Step 1: Sand to 180.

Step 2: Immerse in dye [10 drops Transtint to 3/4 cup DNA]

Step 3: Remove and dry, resand lightly w/180.

Step 4: Two applications of "A/B" wood bleach. This primarily whitens the winter grain. 2 applications requires neutralizing with white vinegar.

Step 5: Sponge on dye.

Step 6: Pad on shellac - Dewaxed Ultra pale tinted with same Transtint. This deepens the color and evens out the burl's porosity.

Step 7: Metal inlay and touch up with more shellac and sand to 320

Let sit for 2 full days to fully evaporate the alcohol.

Step 8: Apply and build NC lacquer finish. Mini HVLP gun shooting Parks lacquer. Two coats applied, then lightly sanded with 600 to level, wipe off and repeat for 6 coats.

Let sit for 2 more days for lacquer to evaporate and tighten down.

Final: Rub out with 0000 wool followed by Meguire's #3 and #9 compounds.

All in all, these little items (about 5"x2-1/2") took a week to finish which was about 100 times longer than they took to turn. :D Worth it, though, as the family was really excited about them.

Re: I may never buy stain again!

#9

Re: I may never buy stain again!

JMOHNIKE

I remember reading, several years ago, in an old, old woodworking book the in the past they considered staining and dyeing as two different processes. Staining was like fumed oak, or a chemical reaction which caused the wood to react and change color. Dyeing was the application of an artificial color to the wood. Both processes then followed by a clear coat of choice. Question, what do you call it when the color is in the varnish, laquer etc. I feel that it is nothing more than a translucent paint. What's your opinion.

Re: I may never buy stain again!

#10

Two Terms Apply

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

"Toning" and "Glazing" although glazing is most often used to relate to wiping on (then wiping off) a darker colored finish/stain to highlight shadow lines of moldings, corners, and the nooks and crannies of less than dead flat-sanded wood.