Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

OT - Computer purchase

Posts

OT - Computer purchase

#1

JL

OT - Computer purchase

JL

The LOML and I have decided to "bite the bullet" and purchase a new desktop.

We will be getting a PC based system.

Some questions still linger though.

Quad core versus duo core. I understand that have four "processors" makes for faster computing than a single processor or two processors. Is there enough difference to warrant spending more?

Memory is a good thing to have (now where did I put that square...). Is having more than a certain amount that beneficial?

The "Deal" - a local computer store builds PCs to your spec. The guy is offering a second generation I-5 quad core processor with 3.1 GHz (or so) with 16 GB of RAM, the DVD burner and a 500 GB hard drive for $640. This is lower than the price for a "name brand" PC by ~$70 (heavily discounted by the maker) - and the "name brand" PC has only 8 GB of memory.

I am tempted - should I be? Or should I just go with a duo core processor and 6 GB of RAM for $240 less?

I would be running Microsoft Office Professional, a browser, an email program and be doing some CAD and picture stuff (minor). I don't really need a "high power" computer.

Thoughts?

Re: OT - Computer purchase

#2

Re: OT - Computer purchase

Chuck in Mtl.

It's hard to justify the extra money for a more powerful system if the applications don't use much computing power, like internet surfing, office programs and the like. A duo-core will work as well as a quad core in this case. Where i like to spend a bit extra is in the power supply. Cheap power supplies don't last and often "take out" the motherboard and cpu when they fail. the better ones last longer and don't fail as often.

Re: OT - Computer purchase

#3

Re: OT - Computer purchase

John McGaw

Opinion only: If you have no applications to run (and don't plan on having any) which are multithreaded then extra cores are not terribly useful. They don't hurt anything but the extra cores won't be adding much. Programs such as CAD, photo retouching, art are more likely to make use of extra cores either now or in the future. Memory is good but sometimes you can go overboard and if your computer is not being used for anything heavy-duty then 16gB is probably twice what you need. On the other hand, 500gB seems to be a tiny hard drive by modern standards, especially given that a 2tB drive can be had for < $75. As Chuck wrote, make sure that the power supply is top of the line. If you aren't getting a gaming system you don't need a really high-power supply but a quality unit (Seasonic is one of my favorites) is a necessity.

Personally, I don't build systems which are running much behind 'bleeding edge'. Never actually on the edge but pretty quickly after the really good stuff comes on the market the prices drop quickly. If a computer is to have a fairly long life then what is 'bleeding edge' now will after a few years seem 'barely usable' since programs and data grow to fill whatever is available. My current system build (now under way) has an i7-2600K overclockable processor, Intel's newest Z68 chipset, 8gB RAM, 60gB SSD cache drive, 2tB (maybe 3tB?) hard drive, double-wide video card, and it all fits into a case which is about the volume of a small shoe box. I definitely won't buy less than a quad-core CPU since I run a distributed processing application for scientific research 24X7 on all of my machines and more cores and more threads means more work gets done but my needs there aren't typical.

Re: OT - Computer purchase

#4

Re: OT - Computer purchase

JimG

You might want to consider a DVI/HDMI output for your TV. Check your TV first, but almost all newer ones have some kind of input for DVI/HDMI. DVI requires a separate audio feed or speakers hooked up to your computer. Also make sure your connection can handle it. I think I read on Netflix they suggest a 3MB connection minimum.

Then you can stream videos, Hulu, Netflix, shows from network web sites, etc to your TV. We dropped our cable a few months ago and haven't looked back. One thing to note, the streaming selection from Netflix is not as good as the DVD selection.

Course, with a nice size monitor, you can do it without the TV.

JimG

Re: OT - Computer purchase

#5

Clint Searl

Re: OT - Computer purchase

Clint Searl

Any of the el cheapo machines fron WalMart, Best Buy, or Costco will serve your needs for a long time. Do consider a good monitor, wireless keyboard and mouse, and an external drive.

Clint

Re: OT - Computer purchase

#6

not enough information

Bill Tindall

You didn't say what you were going to do with this new computer. The cost is twice what I could buy one for at Office Depot. The computer I have has but a small fraction of the capability of the one you described. It is an embarrassment to my children and their Geeky husbands.

Mine runs Win 7, and has Office Professional loaded on it. I use it for modest Excell, Power point and MS Word application, using internet and email. In other words, a very modest computer($300) does all these basic applications as good as a computer costing twice more.

I prefer buying a computer at Walmart. If it doesn't work out of the box I can take it back and get one that does. No risk of spending hours on the phone with a Dell technician like my friend did.

Economy of scale makes it unlikely that a local shop can build a computer for what a large company can, even including the greater overhead. But local company would be there to fix it should that be necessary.

Re: OT - Computer purchase

#7

Re: OT - Computer purchase

Dave Paine

Good advise in the other replies. Your needs to not seem to require even 6GB of RAM, but these days this would be considered on the low side.

I am running XP at work and at home which can "only" map approx 3.5GB of RAM. I run some intensive java programs at work and wish I had more RAM, but at home I am normally browsing.

500GB hard drive is also considered low these days. I expect it will take a long time to fill.

Another reply stated about quality of power supply. Very good advise. I have had a power supply failure which took out the CPU and motherboard. This is an item to pay a few extra dollars for better quality.

I personally look for video to have two ports so I can run two monitors, but at work and home.

If you are getting new monitors, check the types of connections. The old "VGA" style are going away. Now more likely to see DVI or HDMI etc. Just ensure the system and monitors have the same connections.

Consider how you will back-up the hard drive. I have personally "experienced" more hard drive failures on my home PC's than I ever wanted. Having a good back-up to e.g., external hard drive can minimize the grief of getting a replacement hard drive up and running.

Re: OT - Computer purchase

#8

Re: OT - Computer purchase

Bill Howatt

I run 32 bit Windows 7 or XP which means my 4GB machine can only use about 3.5GB RAM and my other machines all have under 3 GB in them. My use is similar to yours other than a music editing program and RAM availability is not a problem. The people who typically need huge amounts of RAM are gamers and Photoshop users who are manipulating large images. However, RAM is very cheap these days so they can load a machine up for little extra cost. You will need the 64 bit version of Windows to access all the RAM being offered in either case. This can be a problem if you want to use some older hardware because there may not be a 64-bit driver.

Right now my best machine is a first generation 2 Core-duo machine which is inferior to even your cheapest option and its performance is more than adequate with W7 and running your applications listed.

The video "card" being offered is likely on-board video which is not the fastest and performance can be upgraded with a better quality separate card. This card will have its own, often faster, memory and will not poach system memory. A better video card add on could bump the price by about $100 though - some real barn-burner video cards can cost as much as the rest of the PC but these are for the high-power gamers. As mentioned, consider if you want to hook it to a TV etc and make sure it has the required connectors and capability.

500GB is a bit small now days but unless you plan on storing videos or thousands of RAW format images it is quite adequate. The way I prefer to do things would be 2 drives so I can use the second one for quick backup and imaging. Not as secure as an external drive but a lot more convenient. Nowdays having USB3 on the motherboard instead of USB2 can make using an external drive (needs to be USB3) a lot faster for large data transfers.

Power supplies, yes, buying a better than the low-end supplies is a good idea but I've never had more problems with a cheapie than I've had with a brand name. Maybe just lucky.

The use of multi-core processors is better these days but I still think universal usage of all the available cores is not a given.

Do you plan to run this machine until it is virtually useless? If so you might add more weighting to the more expensive option.

If you are strictly a user and not a bit of a computer nut then the WalMart or other big box might give you bigger bang for the buck but they are often loaded with annoying crapware and some name brand computers can have proprietary parts that cannot be replaced with generics if they fail.

My preference is to select the motherboard and processor and take it from there. My preference is Asus followed by Gigabyte. However this requires you have a bit of understanding what it's all about. I also prefer to deal with a small computer store like you are doing.

The real place to start with a new computer purchase is to make a list of what you want to do and might want to do as best as your crystal ball works. It is likely the future use that is the problem. I have bought cheap and regretted it and I have bought the more expensive and regretted it! I used to work for a guy who said, if in doubt, buy the next one up.

Bill

Re: OT - Computer purchase

#9

Re: OT - Computer purchase

Jesse Cloud

I gave up on a high resolution crystal ball years ago. Who knows how much RAM we will need in a few years. I still remember thinking anything more than 64K of RAM would be wasteful.

Seems like every day more content is video based or huge PDF files - these exercise both RAM and core.

I have little patience with slow computers, so I always spend until it hurts just a little. :D

Re: OT - Computer purchase

#10

JL

Re: OT - Computer purchase

JL

What you are basically saying is that a quad core (as the computer owner suggested) - is more likely to be "ahead of the curve" and less likely to be obsolete in the near future.

I'm leaning towards a quad core and more memory - at least 8 GB. I probably won't need 16 GB of RAM for a while.

My current thoughts are to get an external hard drive for back up purposes. I'll ask about the USB ports.

Thanks.

Re: OT - Computer purchase

#11

Re: OT - Computer purchase

walta

I had a computer built to my specs and it worked but its case was much larger than a similar factory built unit and it was so loud that found myself wearing hearing protection when using it not that it was 90 db but after a while that hum was all I could hear. It got so bad I replaced the fans with a water cooled system.

I find the best way to judge a system is the "Windows Experience Index" to find this number right click on "computer" select "properties" left click on "Windows Experience Index" for a list of this units strong and weak points. I have yet to see a system where the CPU is the weak link. Every system I look at its the graphics that are weak. Often floor models are locked but the salesman can show you the number. My last laptop is a 5.2 replacing a 2.1

I think a USB3 port is a must have feature in any new computer.

Walta

Re: OT - Computer purchase

#12

Re: OT - Computer purchase

Bill Howatt

I agree with your observations about the video and USB3. System/Data backups are becoming larger and larger and it would be a mistake to hobble a good backup mechanism with USB2. It also brings to light that for convenience the new computer case needs to have USB3 ports on the front panel. I'm running an add-in USB 3 PCI card and the ports are on the back which is a PITA.

I would like to know how the Windows Experience Index rates the video since I had a poor rating for an add-in ATI card that surprised me a little but the question is how the video score reflects the ability to run Office, CAD or even watching a video compared to running games. IMO, for the non-gaming tasks, almost any modern dedicated video card with its own processor and memory with any power at all is likely to be more than adequate. Even modern on-board is reasonable but you can easily do better.

Bill

Re: OT - Computer purchase

#13

Re: OT - Computer purchase

Bill Howatt

Yes, the quad gives you more growing room. For todays typical "office" tasks almost any machine today is adequate but a faster machine can make usage a nicer experience. I backup my C drive (OS and applications) with a disk imaging program and it is a lot nicer to do it on my faster machine than my old P4 3.2Ghz machines. Images of older versions of Windows that used to be under 10GB now are in the 20GB range and given the increased popularity of video files and uncompressed RAW digital camera files the amount of data to be stored and backed up is increasing.

Another thing about the USB3 which came to mind when I was replying to a later post, is to make sure the case has front mounted USB3 ports or at least one USB3 port. Fooling around with rear mounted ports is a pain. USB3 is new enough that not all the hardware has caught up with its implementation so there are lots of cases that are USB2 only.

Bill

Re: OT - Computer purchase

#14

Funny thing...

John in NM

I tend to buy reconditioned laptops from Tiger or similar, always under $300. Never had a problem running openoffice, firefox or gimp even on the windows side of the machine. Its gotten to the point where I don't even remember how fast or how much ram each has, they both seem to work just fine. What I have noticed is that the internet connection is a bit of a bottleneck, so if slow surfing is an irritant, that is one place to look.

I do remember that the newest one was dual core and the older was single. I gave the newer one to my wife when the older one's HD died and I had to replace it with a blank one (no windows :D). I use both machines for surfing (including streaming), minor image editing and office work, don't notice a difference at all, except when both are trying to stream through a single dsl connection - then they both slow down a little.

Re: OT - Computer purchase

#15

JL

Re: OT - Computer purchase

JL

Thanks for all the advice. I'm ordering the 16 GB I-5 Quad - with 1 TB of drive.