Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Shop Vac Recommendation request

Posts

Shop Vac Recommendation request

#1

Shop Vac Recommendation request

Barry Irby

I bought one of the Door Buster special Shop Vacs at the blue Borg. I did not pay much for it (maybe $40???), but whatever I paid was way too much. To say it doesn't suck is to be too kind. In Spite of knowing it was a POS when I bought it, I am amazed that I was suckered into buying this POS. Did I mention I don't think I got a bargain?

I have/had a Craftsman vac that must be 35 years old. It has temporarily escape into the custody of a family member. Its loud, very loud, but it sucks about ten times as well as the POS above.

I want to buy another one and will trash the crappy one. How can I tell which is the most powerful. Seems they should be rated in air flow or inches HG or something. I don't want to spend the money for a Fien. What medium priced unit would you recommend? This is going to be used on construction sites and not so much in the shop.

Re: Shop Vac Recommendation request

#2

"C-word", 5 gal.


Re: Shop Vac Recommendation request

#3

Re: Shop Vac Recommendation request

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I've had a very loud ShopVac (tm) brand 5-gal. sucker for at least 25 years. It's done more than it was ever designed to do.

Re: Shop Vac Recommendation request

#4

Re: Shop Vac Recommendation request

paul in AZ

My Crapsman labeled "6 HP" -inflated HP??- may be noisy but has worked fine for 15 plus years. Still using the original filter, just blow and hose it out every now and then.

Re: Shop Vac Recommendation request

#5

A.J. Hamler

Fein

A.J. Hamler

Its suction is better than any vacuum I've every seen, and it's quieter than any I've ever heard.

Expensive and worth every penny. You'll never need to buy another one.

A.J.

Re: Shop Vac Recommendation request

#6

Nilfisk Attix (WAP) *LINK*

mdclor

I have the one listed at the link below. It isn't inexpensive, but if you are using it on job sites where lead may be present, I would strongly suggest looking at this family of vacs although you would need to upgrade to a HEPA filter model. When I was researching for my purchase, I felt that I was getting more bang for the buck than with either the Fein or Festool vacs because of the "extras" on the other units that are standard with the Nilfisk vacs. I also thought that Bob was a great person with which to do business. I would buy this unit from Bob again. FWIW


Nilfisk at Industrialvacs.com

Re: Shop Vac Recommendation request

#7

I will not buy another Fein

Hoa in Alameda

I had a Fein Turbo, and used it for a while in the shop without anyone noticing.

About a year ago, when redoing the floor, I brought it in. The lady of the house saw (and heard) it. She decided to confiscate it.

I'm back to the ear-piercing Craftsman >(

When I bought mine, the price was so good I bought my boss one too. It was also claimed by the lady of his house!

Re: Shop Vac Recommendation request

#8

Re: I will not buy another Fein

mdclor

IIRC, Fein is the quietest with the Nilfisk being a close second, maybe 5 db difference.

Re: Shop Vac Recommendation request

#9

Re: Shop Vac Recommendation request

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

Best 'sucker' I ever bought was Rigid. Inexpensive and moderately loud.

Re: Shop Vac Recommendation request

#10

I like mine

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

LOML hasn't confiscated mine because she has a central vac system with almost as much suction. I really like how quiet it is and the stability when rolling it around.

Lee

Re: Shop Vac Recommendation request

#11

Re: I like mine

Doug Ridley

I have a Craftsman which sucks (good). I guess it is noisy but since I can't hear much anyway it doesn't bother me.

Doug

Re: Shop Vac Recommendation request

#12

Re: Shop Vac Recommendation request

Larry U. Verhoff

As Paul says, I also have a Craftsman, more like 3 of them. They are noisy, but I wear ear muffs anyway. I`ve had them more than 15 years. I got them cheap when they go on sale, and again like Paul, still have the first filter or maybe a second on them. Good Luck Barry. Larry

Re: Shop Vac Recommendation request

#13

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Shop Vac Recommendation request

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Barry,

I end up getting a new ShopVac every 4-5 years or so. Mostly because there was always that one time I would leave it in the back of the truck and it would get rained on. Their days were always numbered after that (I now use a van).

I get the large one that's about $100 or so. I think they're reasonable quiet and have good suction, but that takes some due diligence on my part. For one, always use bags. Always. Drywall dust is a shop vac killer. It's fine enough to go through the typical filter where it will accelerate wear in the motor and its bearings. Second, you can get a HEPA filter. I had one that I really liked (it seems to have sprouted legs, though, can't find it)--it had a very slippery surface on the plaits, so dust didn't pack into it when I broke the first rule above.

I'm with you on the ratings, though. They should be labeled with BOTH air flow and static pressure. I've noticed that the high-end vacs like Festool and Fein seem to always have smaller hoses which keeps the static pressure low (good) and the airspeed high (also good), but the overall airflow is probably low (not as good).

The bottom line is that moving lots of air at speed makes noise.

Jason

Re: Shop Vac Recommendation request

#14

HAVE both Craftsman and Ridgid 5 ga

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Barry,

The Craftsman came first, and its still going strong, loudly proclaiming itself. Its about 10 years old, and is on the third hose. The Ridgid is now about 6 years old, and proclaims its valued status as loudly as the Craftsman. I have the two smaller 5 hp ones because I have two shop rooms, and its more convenient than hauling one between the shops. The Craftsman is about the only

Sears corded tool which has survived as long as my Sears boycott.

George

Re: Shop Vac Recommendation request

#15

If you shop at Grainger

John in NM

They actually list static pressures and cfm per orifice size on the dayton vacs (watch for typo's though :D)

They're stuff is usually inflated in price a bit, but browsing their site might give you a feel for the air flow specs vs peak HP and current draw that you could then use when shopping at the borg.