Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

veneering a drawer question

Posts

veneering a drawer question

#1

veneering a drawer question

Bill Tindall

Bottom line: would like to veneer a drawer front and not cock bead the drawer. Will it be successful long term?

More details: I am building a chest of drawers and the style is not compatible with cock beading the drawers. I have read that cock beading was invented to protect the edge of veneered drawers, to keep the veneer edge from damage. This claim strikes me as dubious. In any case, if I veneer the drawers with home made veneer (1/16" thick or more) can I expect the veneer edge to hold up with years of use as well as an edge not veneered?

I am hoping someone has done it and has years of experience with the result, or, someone has observed the fate of a veneered drawer without cock beading. It doesn't seem to me that a well glued thick veneer edge will be any more prone to damage than a solid edge.

Re: veneering a drawer question

#2

Stephen Shepherd

Re: veneering a drawer question

Stephen Shepherd

Bill,

I have restored a number of cabinets with one or the other treatments. Most of them were hand sawn veneers, applied thick and scraped thinner. The cock beading on the sides of the drawers get the most damage from the drawer front shrinking, requiring re-mitering the corners of the cock bead.

On the other hand the solid veneered drawer fronts will have damage, chips, cracks, and missing veneer usually at the edges.

Not all styles call for cock-beading. I don't know if this helps, but it is what I have observed.

Stephen

Re: veneering a drawer question

#3

Ellis Walentine

Been there

Ellis Walentine

As a product manager and production engineer for a contract furniture company back in the '80s, I presided over lots of different ways to construct veneered, edgebanded and solid-wood-edged furniture, including desk tops, cabinets, doors and drawers, you name it -- millions of dollars worth of it. We routinely veneered parts over the edge, but the higher-quality work was edgebanded with solid wood strips. Sometimes the solid wood edgebanding was applied to the substrate then sanded flush in a giant flat-belt sander prior to veneering, but more often applied in a big two-ended edgebander with typical industrial hot-melt, occasionally but rarely, RF-cured PVA. There is not a doubt in my mind that solid wood edgebanding, over the veneer, not under it, and at least 1/8" thick -- maybe thicker if soft -- is my preferred method for all but things like modesty panels that are being butted to another piece of the furniture and not subjected to wear and tear.

Actually, it is the denting forces that bugger veneer edges the worst, and depending on what kind of use the piece will get, almost any veneered edge or veneer-to-edge part will be subjected to these forces at some point. I say almost, because your customer may be different. And if you're using 1/16" veneer and edgebanding with same, I'd feel fairly comfortable with it. It's a hard/soft continuum, too. Soft woods will dent more than harder ones; harder ones will hold up to denting better but may be brittle. All of them need close attention to surface contact and correct gluing practices, because the tiniest air bubble or holiday in the glue line becomes a potential failure point. Exposed edges are also vulnerable in that someone's sweater or nylons could brush against the edge and pull up wood fibers, whether or not it actually lifts the veneer.

My own preference, which I employed regularly in my custom work, was to veneer the substrate first and then trim it perfectly to size and then edgeband with solid wood edging of around 1/10" to 1/8" thickness, occasionally thicker if the design could stand it. Usually we chamfered or rounded the strip to minimize the appearance. With your 1/16 banding, you could probably handle it either way, but banding after veneering is easier, IMO.

My 2¢,

Ellis

Re: veneering a drawer question

#4

Re: veneering a drawer question

Sgian Dubh

I've seen many drawers veneered as you describe Bill. Older ones usually show some sort of damage, particularly at the long grain ends of the veneer where they intersect the edges, whether horizontal (veneered vertically) or on vertical edges at either end of the drawer (when the veneer grain runs horizontally. Where the long grain of the veneer intersects the edge there's nearly always less damage in my experience.

Instead of a cockbead you could veneer your ground and put a lipping around all the edges after veneering. In essence the lipping is much the same as a cockbead, but it doesn't sit proud of the front face of the drawer. This (I think) generally works best on man-made board drawer fronts that are planted onto a separately made drawer box, but I suspect you're not doing this kind of construction. Slainte.

Re: veneering a drawer question

#5

correct, and more information

Bill Tindall

The proposal would be to apply a thick cherry veneer to a solid hardwood drawer front, either cherry or poplar. The drawers will be flush style, slightly inset into a bull nosed case edge. Hence, the drawer edge will only be vulnerable when the drawer is open/opened.

The case is otherwise plain as dirt so I would like to use a somewhat figured piece of cherry to cut the drawer front veneer from and have the pattern repeat on each drawer.

Re: veneering a drawer question

#6

Re: veneering a drawer question

Phil Smith

I have commercial bedroom suite with applied veneer (oak). Veneer is over solid core wood. Veneer is appox. 3/32" and edges of drawers are still good after 30 years of daily use. In fact they have a fake bead (small grove routed into face of drawer fronts to give appearance of approx. 1/4" bead) which should make them more vulnerable.