Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Bosch vs. Dewalt SCMS

Posts

Bosch vs. Dewalt SCMS

#1

Bosch vs. Dewalt SCMS

Mike Caldwell

Hi all, been a long time since I've been here. Health and work has kept me away. If I may, I'd like to ask for your help. I need a 12" SCMS. I have done a lot of research and have narrowed my list down to two. I like what I've read about the Bosch 5312 with the B4T stand, and the Dewalt 718 with the 723 stand. Because both of these are expensive, I need to be pretty sure about what I'm doing. If you own either of these units, or have experience with them, I would appreciate your recommendations and advice.

Thank you so much,

Mike

Re: Bosch vs. Dewalt SCMS

#2

JL

Re: Bosch vs. Dewalt SCMS

JL

I don't think you would be unhappy with either saw. I'd see what sort of deal that you could get. If you really want the "Top of the Line" - go for a Festool - but sit down before you look at the price.

Re: Bosch vs. Dewalt SCMS

#3

Re: Bosch vs. Dewalt SCMS

Mike Caldwell

Festool is too rich for my blood. I have to have something that can stand up to job site treatment

Thank you,

Mike

Re: Bosch vs. Dewalt SCMS

#4

12" Saws

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Mike, since you don't mention why you need a 12" machine, keep in mind that the cut quality of the 12" saws with their thin-kerf blades, are less than the 10" machines, and quite a bit less than the 8" blade saws. I bought a 12" Makita and was havng servious issues with wobbly cut lines until I put a full-kerf blade on the saw. I originally bought it to build decks and needed the depth-of-cut to do 4x stock in a single pass. When I put it in the shop to make furniture, I found it unsuitable; a friend with an 8" Hitachi was making far superior cuts.

Re: Bosch vs. Dewalt SCMS

#5

Re: 12" Saws

Mike Caldwell

Good point... My plan was to have a saw that I could take to job sites for deck and outbuilding construction. But to also use it in the furniture shop.

Now I have an old Dewalt single bevel miter saw, 12". It has a standard 80 tooth blade. I havent used it too much in furniture building. So maybe I can get away with a 12" standard thickness blade.!? What'd you think?

Re: Bosch vs. Dewalt SCMS

#6

Personally

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I have a Makita LS 12-11 with a full width Jesada 90-tooth blade. Were I buying a new slider, I wouldn't go for more than a 10" saw, especially if you're planning on doing precision cuts for furniture. You get mostly the same motor [15amp], the same cross-cut capacity, but use a 10" blade that will blow through framing and deck lumber with ease. For 4-6" thick stock, just make two cuts.

12" saws are fine for trim, especially if you're doing heavy crown molding, but then you don't need a slider.

I have several close friends who do pro remodeling and additions. They run Hitachi (8 and 10"), Makita, and Bosch saws; pretty much in that order.

m

Re: Bosch vs. Dewalt SCMS

#7

Re: Bosch vs. Dewalt SCMS

Dave Paine

I replaced my Bosch 10 in SCMS with the latest 12in GCM10SD "slider".

I love the new saw, much improved dust collection, bevels to left or right and the glider mechanism means less rear space requirement.

You mentioned SCMS, so this may be more money than you want to spend.

If you are close to Eastern PA, I have a 10in Bosch SCMS gathering dust. javascript:insertTags(":D");

Re: Bosch vs. Dewalt SCMS

#8

Re: Bosch vs. Dewalt SCMS

John Lucas

Mike I just went through that. I looked at all the 12" machines and finally decided on 10" . I went with that for 2 or 3 reasons. It's less expensive, The blades are less expensive, it weighs less, and according to all the reading I did, the 10" saws are more accurate. I decided I could do with a little less cutting capacity.

I bought the Makita 1016L. For what I do the laser is really not very useful but since I've never had one I decided I'd give it a try. I can see for some cuts that don't need to be as accurate it would really speed things up.

So far I've only done a little work with it but it's pretty accurate. I'm super picky and there are minor cut accuracies. I think it's the thin kerf blade but I found that if my feed rate is consistent and not forced it cuts pretty darn near dead on. When your cutting 16 segments it has to be much more accurate than your standard cabinet work.

I looked very hard at the Festool but the saw I got will do probably 99% of all the things I want out of it and it cost 1/3 of what the Festool cost.

Re: Bosch vs. Dewalt SCMS

#9

Re: Bosch vs. Dewalt SCMS

Mike Caldwell

Thank you all. You've really given me a lot to think about. Now I'll start looking at 10" SCMS. I see you points and they all make very good sense.

Thank you for helping me work through this. I feel like i just got a bunch more friends. I'll let you know how this progresses.

Again, many thanks to all,

Mike

Re: Bosch vs. Dewalt SCMS

#10

Re: Bosch vs. Dewalt SCMS

Michael Caldwell

Below are the results of my search. Based on function and price, I'm going with the DEWALT DW717.

I havent decided on a stand yet. Ive used the DEWALT and liked it. But I really like the Bosch with the folding leg stands and wheels.

So, anyway, there you have it. If I can help anyone in the future with researching tools, please let me know. I'll be happy to help.

Thanks, again, for all you alls help,

Mike

Bosch Bosch DEWALT Hitachi

4310 4410 DW717 C10FSB

10-Inch 10-Inch 10-Inch 10-Inch

Dual Bevel Dual Bevel Dual Bevel Dual Bevel

Slider Slider Slider Slider

Amazon 526.99 546.50 447.42 529.99

5 stars (9) 4 Stars (50) 4 1/2 stars (15) 4 1/2 stars (38)

Weight 55 lbs 55 lbs 51 lbs 43 lbs

Motor 15 amp 4800 15 amp 4800 15 amp 4000 12 amp 3800 Arbor 5/8 5/8 5/8 5/8

Laser extra Yes

Cut Length 12 in 10 1/2 in 14 in 12 in

Cut Height 3 5/8 in 4 1/4 in 6 in

Bevel Range 47 degrees Rt& Lt 47 degrees Rt & Lt 48 degrees Rt & Lt 45 degrees Rt & Lt

Miter Range 52 degrees Rt, 60 Lt 52 degrees Rt, 60 Lt 57 degrees Rt, 45 Lt

Bevel Detents

Miter Detents 10 detents 10 detents 11 detents 0, 15, 22.5, 31.6, 45 (L & R)

Extensions 37 1/4 in 37 1/4 in

Money-back 90 days

Warranty 1 yr 1 yr 3 yr

Includes saw, blade, dust bag, clamp saw, blade, wrench, dust bag, clamp saw, blade, wrench, dust bag, clamp saw, blade, wrench, dust bag

Stand 299.99 299.99 169