Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

wood deck issues

Posts

wood deck issues

#1

wood deck issues

avalon

back in 2007, I asked my dad to help build a 2100 sq ft deck for a wedding place we were building. He said he would take care of it and i went on taking care of other things. When the wood came in, the main deck boards were treated 1x6's... I told him to send them back cause i had told him i wanted 2x4s or 2x6s... he said he knew what he was doing and so i figured it wouldnt be that big a deal...

half the deck is covered, but the part that isnt is warping badly, like i knew it would.. some are warping into potholes that are dips in the deck, some are spliting, and some are pulling up on the edges, actually pulling the nails out.. (i said to use screws, but he wanted to use the nail gun we got him for Christmas..)

so about 2 years ago we put thompsons water seal on it and it seemed to keep it waterproof..

but im having to replace a couple of boards every month or so..

other than rebuilding the deck, would thompsons water seal slow down the warping or is there something else?nd as long as the deck holds togther, we dont want to spend the $ to replace the whole thing, since we'll be redoing it completely anyways.... just need it to last a year or more..

lesson learned.. if someone volunteers, make sure it aint your dad..

we are planning on building a bigger facility in 2 years, a

Re: wood deck issues

#2

Re: wood deck issues

avalon

and yes... i probably should treat it yearly... but u know how it goes...

the paint lady at lowes said tws wasnt what i needed and pointed to something made by black flag.. i told her that it was termite repelant, but she said it would keep the wood from warping.. but it also looks like id need about 20 bottles of the stuff tocover half the open deck... it would probably be cheaper just to replace the boards.

Re: wood deck issues

#3

Re: wood deck issues

FredD

"it would probably be cheaper just to replace the boards."

Truer words.....

The Lady from Lowes probably had the same skills's the Irishman who interviewed for a Job. See above.

As good as Thompson's WaterSeal is , it will not make a 1x6 perform like a 2x6 or increase the lumber grade.

If you start a Deck with crap , you pretty much have unintentionally lowered your expectations.

FredD

Re: wood deck issues

#4

Re: wood deck issues

Barry Irby

Many years ago I had a discussion with someone in TX who was supposed to be an expert on wood decay on a national level. One of the top two experts in the country. He thought nothing Thompsons Water Seal. To avoid controversy I was calling it "that stuff that makes the water bead up". He came right out and named it. His explanation was that it was little more than paraffin dissolved in thinner. The thinner evaporates and leaves a film of wax behind. His opinion was that it did nothing to preserve the wood. Not only is the film not durable, there is no way for you to coat he wood on all four sides. No one ever soak the bottom side. So the water runs off the top and then clings to the bottom and soaks in. The waxy film then retards drying out of the top side. This has a tendency to cause the boards to curl up ward along the edges and cup, forming little troughs that tend to hold water. As I recall he thought there was very little you could do in the field that would actually improve the performance of treated wood.

I have built many decks and used "two by" material for the floor and was more pleased with them than thinner material. Recently built on for my son and used 5/4 deck board from Lowe's that were the premium grade. Just finished one on rental house and used the 5/4 stuff that was the lower grade. The premium stuff is much nicer, nearly free of knots. and coated all the way around with a waxy coating. The utility stuff is full of knots and not coated. My son's floor has been in place for months with no complaints other than I turn the grade stamps on one board up to show the better side the board. A few more weeks should tell us something about the rental house' deck. The premium grade is certainly prettier, but it doubled the cost of the floor.

I think 1x6's offer little chance of success. A neighbor had them, left them in place for a year or two and tore them out.

Re: wood deck issues

#5

Re: wood deck issues

Pete in Holland

My deck is now 17 years old and going strong. 5/4 x 6 on the floor. Floor joists at 12-14". Yup, it has some splits and checking going on due to the harsh seasons SW Michigan sees, Only had one board that did a small swoop over the years. Deck was nailed down with twisted galvanized 3" nails. Have to pound in a couple once in a while.

Part of the key to the success on my deck, I think, is tighter joists.

Have hand many converstations in the past on wood decks. If you want a perfect deck that won't warp, crack or twist, pour a slab. Wood is dynamic, and eventually, mother nature will reclaim it, regardless of the wood and treatments.

Re: wood deck issues

#6

5/4 x 6 deck boards here too - 21 years.

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

I built my deck in 1990. Used 5/4 x 6 treated deck boards over 2x8 joists at 16" centers. Each deck board got two screws at each joist crossing. I use Wolman RainCoat (cedar tinted) every three years on the decking and maybe every 8 years on the vertical stuff, brushed on heavily by hand. I have replaced one rail cap treated 2x6 that twisted. Not one deck board has needed replacing and they are all still nice and flat after 21 years. Maybe I'm just lucky.

Re: wood deck issues

#7

Re: wood deck issues

John E in SC

I have decided that the key to making a deck last is some type of stain. Case in point - I built the deck on the back of my house using treated 1x6's, and shortly after it dried well, have treated it yearly or every other year with a semi-opaque stain. It is now 8 years old, and still looks pretty good. I occasionally have to hammer back down a few nails, but there really hasn't been any warping.

In contrast, we have an above ground pool, and I built a similar deck around it, using the same lumber and construction methods. Only thing, I haven't sealed or stained it at all. It is only about 4 years old, and is now so warped, split, etc, that I'm pretty much going to have to tear it down and start over if it's going to last any longer. (Hope I can just get rid of the pool, but that's another story!) These are separated by only about 20 feet. The pool deck gets more sun, but the difference is extreme between the 2. I would definitely recommend a good stain, the more opaque, the better.

Re: wood deck issues

#8

Re: wood deck issues

FredD

Treat wood is treated to specifically resist bug and mold invasion.

ThompsonWaterSeal in it's original flavor makes the wood water resistant for varying lengths for time assuming it is applied correctly and that is all it does and very well.

FredD