Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Fundamentals of hand plane dulling

Posts

Fundamentals of hand plane dulling

#1

Fundamentals of hand plane dulling

Bill Tindall

For most of my life I never had a rewarding experience with a hand plan in my hand, in spite of how handy this device is for fitting stuff in furniture construction. Turns out that success with a hand plane results from success at the sharpening station. But, once sharp, the blade dulls in use more or less quickly and problems reappear.

For some time I have been thinking about dulling, and Steve Elliot ( your must check his awesome web site) and others have been studying dulling. I want to make clear that Steve has done the hard work and I just write about it. If you are not into fundamentals just skip to the conclusions at the end.


Shown in the figure is the edge profile of a plane blade after it has planed various lengths of wood with a hand plane. The point to note is that in the beginning there is clearance between the tip of the blade and the wood beneath it. This clearance is essential for the tip to easily "pick up" a shaving. This clearance is essential to any cutting operation, be it a drill bit or lathe tool, metal or wood.

As the blade is used abrasion removes metal from the plane blade tip. The tip rounds over and most importantly a flat spot forms on the bottom of the blade, which destroys clearance (also called relief).



This figure is from a scientific paper. It shows the profile of two plane blades used to plane wood in a planing machine that functions similar to a hand plane. The plane blade highlighted in yellow is a blade similar to what Steve used to generate the data in the first figure. Two profiles are superimposed, the original profile and the profile after 500 meters of planing (the numbers on the figure are kilometers). Note the wear patter is like what Steve found, the tip rounds over and there is loss of clearance.

The figure shows a second plane blade that has been coated with a 3 micron thick very abrasion resistant material on the bottom, much like the titanium nitride work I described earlier. In this case this coating prevents wear and loss of clearance on the blade's bottom, yet the tip wears as in the case of the uncoated blade.



This graph shows the cutting forces acting on the blade while planing. The top set of curves shows the force in the direction the plane is pushed(force resisting pushing)and the bottom set of curves is the force perpendicular to the wood surface. A negative value indicates the blade is being pushed into the wood by the cutting action, while a positive value means the blade is being lifted off the wood. The yellow highlighted curve is for the uncoated blade, and the other curve is for the blade with the abrasion resistant coating on it bottom.

I always thought a blade got "dull", (or at least was judged dull by the fact it quit cutting or was too hard to push) because the tip got blunt from wear. The point to note from the data in the figures is that planing performance deteriorates as soon as the clearance has been destroyed by abrasion to the bottom of the blade, even if the tip is still fairly sharp . The force to push the plane rockets up and the blade wants to lift off the wood surface.

Clearly coating the plane blade's bottom with something highly abrasion resistant increases the useful life of the blade. But of great practical importance to the use of uncoated blades is that when sharpening, the most important thing to accomplish is to remove the flat spot on the blade bottom. Also, it is a very bad idea to drag the plane back across the wood surface at the end of the forward planing stroke. Such dragging increases the wear that results in loss of clearance.

Re: Fundamentals of hand plane dulling

#2

Ellis Walentine

Couple things

Ellis Walentine

I always thought a blade got "dull"...because the tip got blunt from wear.

Blunt might not be the best word for it, but whatever you want to call that rounding on the bevel, it adds up to dull.

Thanks for summarizing this research for us. I was most amazed that the coated blade could plane two kilometers of red alder before it stopped biting.

Ellis

Re: Fundamentals of hand plane dulling

#3

Subtle point

Bill Tindall

It may not be the tip rounding over per say that causes the sensation of dulling. We think it is the loss of clearance that produces the dulling experience. If the "dulled" blade was raised to gain clearance it would likely still cut adequately. A hand held lathe tool will cut literally miles of wood and still give a good finish......I think because one can adjust the tool angle to compensate for loss of clearance.

So, what we need is a variable angle plane bed....just kidding or course. But the work does suggest that a TiN coating on the back of a bevel up plane blade might just be dandy. Vanadium carbide coating was used in the literature work reported. Which is why high vanadium tool (3V and M4)steels wear so well...vanadium carbide is the ultimate of carbide abrasion resistance.

Re: Fundamentals of hand plane dulling

#4

Clint Searl

Re: Couple things

Clint Searl

A hollow grind would appear to be the intuitive answer to improving mileage, said by someone who's never put a kilometer on all his planes combined.

Clint

Re: Fundamentals of hand plane dulling

#5

likely not

Bill Tindall

In the machine generated data the blade cut so long as there was clearance and the "ramp" the shaving climbed up was not a 90 degree wall. The shaving only experiences the first few tens of microns of the plane blade.

Re: Fundamentals of hand plane dulling

#6

Re: Fundamentals of hand plane dulling

john lucas

I was thinking the same thing as Clint. Of course for this to work you need the hollow grind to be down not up as in some plane irons. Since I am a turner I found this most interesting. If the vanadium coating were put on the inside of the flute then in theory it would hold an edge longer, especially as you said, you could rotate the tool to obtain optimum cutting.