Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Wood dye light fastness

Posts

Wood dye light fastness

#1

Wood dye light fastness

Ed Pretty

I have been using Procion MX dye for some time now with excellent results. I started using Procion because it gave me better results than any aniline dyes that I had used. Recently the issue of light fastness has come up. I had read that aniline dyes were not that lightfast so was pleased to hear that dichlorotriazine dyes (Procion MX) were more lightfast. I have been doing quite a bit of research lately and have found that the opposite may be true: that aniline dyes are more lightfast than Procion MX.

Can someone tell me with certainty which of the two is more lightfast (prior to application of any UV protecting finishes). In addition, I would like to know how lightfast aniline is compared to acrylic paints.

Re: Wood dye light fastness

#2

JL

Re: Wood dye light fastness

JL

I hate to say it - but the answer is - it depends.

Any organic dye (aniline, dichlorotriazine or whatever) has a number of substituent groups on the molecule. These substituent groups give the particular color to the molecule. Along comes a high energy photon - it hits the dye molecule and sends it to a higher state. If the molecule "snaps back" to its previous state, all is well and good. You still have that particular color. If it doesn't "snap back" but rearranges instead - that is when you have problems.

Certain colors are going to be more labile than others. So the thing to do is test. There are a number of other variables in addition to the basic chemical structure. These include the vehicle, binder (if any) and substrate.

A metallic pigment is probably going to be more light fast than the organic dye.

Re: Wood dye light fastness

#3

now that is a complicated question

Bill Tindall

I did some testing of wood dyes but I did not test the dye you ask about. There are some general guidelines though.

As you may know dyes can be made from a large variety of chemicals. The label "aniline dye" is historical and of little utility in predicting light fastness or the actual structure of the dye molecule. It seems to be a label used to describe a wide range of chemicals dyes, of varying lightfastness. However, there is a class of dyes called "premetallized dyes" that in general are more light fast than any other class of dyes.

A way to tell if some product is a premetallized dye is to get the MSDS sheet for the dye in question. If under composition it says premetallized dye then the best guess will be that this dye is as good as it gets. The dyes I have checked from J. E. Moser's are labeled "aniline" and they are premetallized dyes according to the MSDS sheet. Dyes I have checked from some other manufacturers have not been premetallized dyes.

In general the mineral pigments (for example burnt umber) are permanent. Other pigments such as used in paint are in general quite light fast, but these too vary. In general reds are less light fast.

Re: Wood dye light fastness

#4

Re: now that is a complicated question *LINK*

John Lucas

Well I have also been playing with dyes and asking the same questions. I guy named Gary Sanders did a test by putting samples of a lot of dyes in the dashboard of his pickup in during a summer in texas. none of the dyes he tested except the metallic dyes held up for more than a week. Most colors completely dissappeared.

After checking with other wood turners who do a lot of dyeing and have asked the same question I decided to move to the Trans Tint dyes. I just placed an order with the place below a few days ago. They have excellent prices.


http://www.woodfinishersstore.com/

Re: Wood dye light fastness

#5

Re: Wood dye light fastness

Ed Pretty

Thank you Bill and John (JL?). This helps to clear up a lot of my confusion. I had heard that "aniline" had become somewhat of a "universal moniker", not to be relied upon as confirmation for a dye classification and was beginning to believe that as I read various descriptions. I had also heard that premetalized dyes were the most light fast , however had been led to believe that Procion MX (dichlorotriazine dye) was premetalized. It never occurred to me to check an MSDS. :(

I have never used trans tint dyes so will have to check them out. Thanks again.