Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Finishing Advice

Posts

Finishing Advice

#1

Finishing Advice

Mike Donaldson

First off, I have spent a fair bit of time reading previous woodcentral articles and posts on finishing, and still don't feel confident to start.

I just finished making a jewelry box for my wife (Aug 17th is our 10th anniversary), and have spent a long time and a lot of money making it (I will post pics of it as soon as I can figure out how), and the only things left to do are the final sanding, finishing and putting on the hardware and liners.

The owner of my local Woodcraft sold me an aerosol shellac and an aerosol H. Behlen stringed instrument lacquer. My plan is to sand everything with a 220 grit paper, then wipe off the surfaces with a clean rag, then wipe off the surfaces with tack cloth, then wipe it down with naphtha. Next, I shoot it with the shellac, let it dry for 30 min, sand with 220 grit, shoot it again with shellac and repeat this process for 5-6 coats of shellac, then let it sit for 24 hours. Then I plan of hitting it with the lacquer, waiting an hour between coats with no sanding until I have 12 coats on it. Then I let it sit for a week.

Does this sound right? Anything I missed? Any thoughts on a different way to do it? Thanks in advance.

Re: Finishing Advice

#2

Dale Lenz

Re: Finishing Advice

Dale Lenz

The way I finish my flag cases are as follows: One coat of 1# shellac, wiped on, equivellent to one spray coat, more or less. Fill wood pours if I wish to have a smooth finish, sand with 320 and give one more shellac coat. Lightly sand with 400 grit. Shoot lacquer every 15-20 minutes or so. Put on about 3-4 coats, let dry overnight, sand with 400-600 grit, shoot more coats if need and wait for 3 days and sand up to 800 grit for a satin finish, higher 1000-1200 plus rubbing compound for high gloss sheen.

Any stubborn spot with a satin finish I might rub it with red then gray Scotch-Brite pads. Yep, the first time you start to finish, you are buying everything for the first time. After a few finish jobs you will have left overs and finish is not that costly until you have to buy 5 gallons of lacquer again, tears up $200!

Hope this helps~

Re: Finishing Advice

#3

Re: Finishing Advice

Dick Coers

That's a lot of coats of finish. My concerns; Rattle can shellac nozzles aren't very good at all. They really throw out some big particles, and you can get too thick of a coat really quickly. It'll work, but far from a good surface quality. 1/2 hour may be too soon for sanding the shellac, depending on coat thickness and weather conditions. 220 is way too course for sanding between coats. I prefer 320 or 400. 220 fresh paper will leave a really deep scratch. I don't remember if you told us the wood species. Are you trying to fill some pores with that much shellac? I prefer to use grain filler for that purpose.

Re: Finishing Advice

#4

I agree with everything in this post, and addition

Bill Tindall

Why are you finishing with shellac AND lacquer? While it may be acceptable to overcoat a thin layer of shellac with lacquer, though I don't know what one would want to do this, differences in expansion may cause a heavy coat of one kind of finish to crack when applied over a heavy coat of some other finish.

What ever you decide to so, practice on something first. The final project is not the place to be learning to finish. You will rue the day you don't follow this advice.

Personally, for this kind of object I would just use shellac. Thin some Zinser shellac 1:1 with ethanol and pad or brush it on. If you brush use a technique I learned from the furniture conservator at the Smithsonian. Use a small fine bristled brush. Dip, and brush like made- short rapid strokes. Pretend the brush is a windshield wiper on high speed. Once covered let it set till dry and repeat as many times as it takes to build up a nice depth. Lightly sand smooth with 360 or finer paper and rub out with 0000 wool and wax.

Or spray a coat of lacquer. Sand with 360 or finer paper. Recoat twice and you are done.

Re: Finishing Advice

#5

FFF

Mike Donaldson

The box is Made of quilted maple and bloodwood. I really have no idea what I am doing as far as finish goes, and inwas relying wholly on what the salesman at Woodcraft told me (in hindsight, that may not have been the best idea). All I know is that I want the box to have a high gloss finish that is at least partially kid-proof. that being said, what is the best way to get there?

My dad always said to use the three F's when it comes to finishing: "finish firewood first." I have a practice box joint of quilted maple and bloodwood that has been heavily used to test things on this project, it will be finished first, but I need this box done by the 17th, so I may have to bend that rule a bit.

Re: Finishing Advice

#6

Re: FFF

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Your dad's advice was and is terrific. Nice to know that his wisdom lives on.

Re: Finishing Advice

#7

sounds to me like it doesn't

Bill Tindall

A "bent"rule is a rule not followed. I have finished acres of stuff and every time I try a new finish product or technique without first practicing it I get screwed.

Editorial. I don't go to Woodcraft often but on occasion when I have been in a store I have heard a staff person offer advice that made me cringe, for example the time that the Woodcraft instructor was advising the person to rip the 12" wide board into strips and reglue it "for stability".


The piece in the picture is done with shellac. Shellac sands easy, it rubs out easy and it is easy to fix and restore. It is available in handy spray cans which you can hope to be fresh enough to be good, or in cans of Zinser available at Lowes, HD, paint stores and the like. And, it is moderately durable, probably as good as lacquer unless water is involved. If you were experienced you would be done with a shellac finish in two elapsed days and an hour or two of actual work. These attributes should be carefully considered before proceeding to a decision.

Re: Finishing Advice

#8

PS

Bill Tindall

the piece in the picture was oiled before staining and shellacing. Oiling may or may not improve the box in question. If you oil with boiled linseed oil let it sit several days to be sure it is dry.

Re: Finishing Advice

#9

Clint Searl

Lose the shellac

Clint Searl

It's unnecessary. The Behlen lacquer is nitrocellulose, which is as good as it gets without anything underneath. Shoot a coat and smooth back the nibs with maroon scotchbrite. Follow up with as many coats to get the desired build. After a couple days rub out with auto polishing compound. Try it on a scrap.

Clint

Re: Finishing Advice

#10

Re: Finishing Advice

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

The current edition of Fine Woodworking has an article about spray finishes from cans. Might be worth a look.

Joe

Re: Finishing Advice

#11

Agree with most....

Bill Tindall

While I agree with what you recommended and indeed this is exactly what I would do if I faced this task, shellac is easier to fix. I think there is a good chance that given Mike's experience he will be revisiting this project some time in the future when his skills are more developed, or even redoing part in the present if his spraying skills, or the can's performance, fails. I would rather strip shellac in this case. On the other hand, if practice results in confidence that the lacquer can be sprayed successfully, then that is the way I would go, as you recomend.

Re: Finishing Advice

#12

Re: Finishing Advice

Mike Donaldson

Well, I started finishing my scrap wood. I put shellac and lacquer on half and just lacquer on the other half. The shellac seems to really bring out the grain. We'll see how it looks tomorrow. Thanks for all the input. It was very helpful. If I can figure out how to pist pictures, I will post them when the box is done.

Re: Finishing Advice

#13

Re: Finishing Advice

FredD

I would suggest you run back to that font of experience at the Wood Craft store and get a spray can handle that snaps onto a spray can and has a trigger which will give you better control over the fan spray from the can.

Use it a couple of times to get used to it

It doesn't need all of the coating you talking about, Zinnser has a Gloss in Shellac.

Shellac has a tendency to gum and load the paper more then a regular sanding sealer , so let it dry hard between coats.

Shellac is more forgiving of mistakes then any finish worthy of the name , don't get in a hurry between coats of sanding and stop when you like it, wax it , buff it and your done.

FredD