Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Shop air cleaner/ dust collector advice needed.

Posts

Shop air cleaner/ dust collector advice needed.

#1

Shop air cleaner/ dust collector advice needed.

Ray Carson, Lawrenceville, NJ

Hello,

My wood working area is in my basement so the dust and fumes have a tendency to travel into our home. I have a main dust collector and I dilegently try to use my Shop-Vac when using my portable sanders and such. However, my problem lies mostly when finishing. Sometimes I will finish items in the garage so that the fumes can escape but on really humid days it's just not realistic. All finishes go milky white and never turn out right. (I'm a poet and didn't know it) So, I'm forced to finish them in the basement. The fumes get really bad sometimes and I'm looking for a solution.

I've been considering some sort exhaust system and I would probably have to utilize a basement window. I do not however want to lose the light and I don't want the fan and exhaust port permanently exposed to the elements. Also, I don't bugs and such entering thru a vent especially and grade level. I could very easily rig a temporary type system so that a fan could swing in and out of the window.

First question - Will a "box type" suspended air cleaner do the trick? I know these are made to be hung at the ceiling and remove dust from the air BUT without it going to the outside what are some other options to remove fumes.

Second question - Regardless of the fumes I may buy a suspended air cleaner anyway just to aid in dust control. I've been looking at Penn State Industries, Grizzly and US Body Products.

Do any of you have a preference? Which one do you own if you have one and what are pros and cons?

Thank you for reading.

Ray

Re: Shop air cleaner/ dust collector advice needed.

#2

JL

Re: Shop air cleaner/ dust collector advice needed

JL

I have a box fan that I put in my basement window when I finish things. It is a three speed and works well at medium or high. It exhausts enough air such that I don't have to worry about fumes stinking up the house.

I am currently installing a Jet AFS 1000B. It will move enough air to control the dust (hopefully). As people have been quick to warn me - it should not be used to control vapors and fumes as it doesn't have enough capacity. It should be able to minimize lingering odors though.

Re: Shop air cleaner/ dust collector advice needed.

#3

Re: Shop air cleaner/ dust collector advice needed

Phil Joines

Unless you have activated charcoal filters I wouldn't think an air cleaner would do much about solvent fumes.

Re: Shop air cleaner/ dust collector advice needed.

#4

Re: Shop air cleaner/ dust collector advice needed

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Morning Ray,

I have a Bridgewood 1 1/2 hp DC servicing my shop, as well as a JTS 750 air cleaner. My shop is still dusty, so I Shop Vac frequently. When weather permits, I use a window exhaust fan and it is very effective. There will always be dust in my shop since it is used every day for several hours. I do finishing either outside on my screened in back porch, or within the shop after the air cleaner has run for several hours.

Fumes???Only when my SWMBO needs an outing/to go shopping/or is mad at me. ;)

George

Re: Shop air cleaner/ dust collector advice needed.

#5

Re: Shop air cleaner/ dust collector advice needed

Barry Irby

I have a 1 1/2hp DC that is outside the shop in an exterior closet. I recently started using my spray gun again after it sat on the shelf for thirty years because I don't have a spray booth. My shop is small ( 14 by 22) and is in the walkout part of my basement. I have an undersized window air conditioner that is a blessing on these hot days. Does not really cool the shop, but it helps and it lowers the humidity enough to be bearable.

So, when I started spraying, if I could not open the overhead garage door, I ran the DC with about four gates open. Basically used it as an exhaust fan. Probably not the best idea in the world, but it worked. It was interesting. On the gates that were not open, I discovered a pattern of white in each of the gates that indicated air was leaking into them and depositing the white residue of the clear lacquer I was spraying. Again, not the best idea in the world, but it worked and I made do with what I had.

Re: Shop air cleaner/ dust collector advice needed.

#6

Re: Shop air cleaner/ dust collector advice needed

Ron Jones

JDS does have a charcoal filter available for the 750. I have no knowledge of other manufactures filters.

Re: Shop air cleaner/ dust collector advice needed.

#7

Shop air cleaner

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

JL, thanks for pointing out that you've already been warned about fume removal. That's good to know.

Ray

Re: Shop air cleaner/ dust collector advice needed.

#8

Seems unaminous

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Hello Colonel 'G',

It appears the masses have spoken and although an air cleaner will be a nice addition to the shop it's not the answer for a good ole' exhaust fan or something similar. I agree the "fumes" of SWMBO are sometimes worse than the lacquer.

Thanks,

Ray