Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Oil poly over milk paint?

Posts

Oil poly over milk paint?

#1

Oil poly over milk paint?

AZ in Colorado Springs

I'm starting a new project. I'm building a kitchen island for a friend whose current island is getting wobbly, and they have seven or eight kids in the house. Needless to say, the kitchen gets a lot of use, and they need ssomething sturdy.

I'm using the plan in Woodsmith from Feb/Mar 2011. Instead of cherry, I'll use poplar and maple for the top.

The finish needs to be durable, so I'm thinking milk paint, finished with 10-12 coats of satin oil-based wiping poly. I've used wiping poly over oil-based stain and like it a lot.

Thanks

AZ

Re: Oil poly over milk paint?

#2

Clint Searl

Re: Oil poly over milk paint?

Clint Searl

I've been playing with milk paint of late for a library wall project, and have coated it with raw tung oil to see the effect. The most prominent effect is a strong darkening of the finish, but otherwise they're compatible. Probably OK for oil or water poly and lacquer, too. In fact, the manufacturer, realmilkpaint.com, promotes mixing raw tung oil with the milk paint emulsion to make a weather resistant exterior finish.

Clint

Re: Oil poly over milk paint?

#3

Re: Oil poly over milk paint?

John Veerkamp

I've done several pieces with milk paint covered with satin oil poly. As was said the most prominent effwct was darkening of darker colors of the milk paint. Navy and red especially. The cream/yellow didn't darken as much. On all of them it gave a much deeper, rich look.Two coats of the poly and they are almost bullet proof.

Re: Oil poly over milk paint?

#4

Try This

David Yoho

Applying the oil-based poly over the milk paint should work fine. I'm sure you realize, since you stated you'd apply 10 - 12 coats, that it takes more coats when wiping than brushing to build a surface film.

One method I like to employ when going for a satin finish with a satin poly or varnish that makes the final look of the wood grain clearer is to begin with a clear gloss and apply it for all but the final two coats. Even when wiping, this technique works better than using satin all the way through. If you've never tried it before, this would be a good opportunity to see the difference.

Re: Oil poly over milk paint?

#5

Re: Oil poly over milk paint?

AZ in Colorado Springs

Clint -- I've never used tung oil, but weatherproof probably equals kid proof, so that's valuable to know.

John -- bulletproof -- yeah!

David -- I've brushed poly before, but always had to deal with runs and sags. I read something by Bob Flexner a few years back and tried wiping poly and liked that it cured faster and I've had no problems with runs or sags. (Had some poly drip off the rag once and that had to be leveled, but that's a separate issue.) I understood that you needed 2x the number of coats when wiping, and that was OK (three brushing = six wiping). But on a toy box I made earlier this year for my grandson I went for more coats, and after number eight or nine it really started to glow. So, for that reason, and to increase durability, I figure 10-12 coats wiped on.

I've never combined gloss and satin layers (I think you've posted about that in the past) but I think I will try that on this project.

Thanks for all the suggestions so far.

AZ

Re: Oil poly over milk paint?

#6

Re: Poly sprays very well too

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

If you have a spray outfit, I have sprayed Minwax poly - last time I sprayed the best I can remember I think I thinned about 50% as it was a pretty hot day & I was spraying outside. You can thin it with MS, Turpentine, Naphtha, Acetone, toulene etc. depending on how fast you want it to dry. Too fast & it won't flow well, to slow runs on vertical surfaces and tends to pick up dust etc. I was very satisfied with the results I obtained.

Re: Oil poly over milk paint?

#7

Clint Searl

Re: Oil poly over milk paint?

Clint Searl

Further experimentation with top coating milk paint indicates that the least color darkening results from using a water borne poly. That's what I'm going to use. A couple brushed on coats will provide plenty of protection against a house full of critters.

Clint

Re: Oil poly over milk paint?

#8

Re: Oil poly over milk paint?

AZ in Colorado Springs

I do not have spray equipment, so that's not an option for me. I've used water based poly and it does dry quite clear. But I really like the "control" offered by wiping poly, even if it builds in thin layers.

So, it'll be either water or oil based poly.

Thanks for all the suggestions. As has been said by others, there is a wealth of knowledge and experience posted here every day!