Is 60 t-8s (4') 9' over 732 sqft too much?
Ron
Subject line says it all. Need to know quite soon. Seems about right to me.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Is 60 t-8s (4') 9' over 732 sqft too much?
Ron
Subject line says it all. Need to know quite soon. Seems about right to me.
Re: Is 60 t-8s (4') 9' over 732 sqft too much?
Phil
I'm using 24 T8 bulbs (32 watt if I recall correctly) in a roughly 400sf shop and you almost need sunglasses: 60 32 watt bulbs is approaching 2000 watts of fluorescent light: might be a bit too much?
complex question, inadequate data
Bill Tindall
The question is more complex than you are considering. Too much for what purpose? What is the color of the floor, walls, work surface. How high is work surface or tool from the floor, ages of persons working in the area, nature work performed, etc. etc.
A large lighting store will have software to calculate lighting needs for defined tasks in defined space.
But, here aresome data to begin. A shady out door spot will be illuminated about 500 foot candles. 200 FC is considered minimum for detailed task work. I have 200 FC at my bench surface , the brightly illuminated area is 5 x 9" and there are 14- 4 foot lamps at 4.5' above the bench. To get to 200 FC with these lamps I needed to paint walls near white and have a near white work surface. Floor is grey, not optimum. Lighting of about 50 FC is adequate peripheral to the task area.
Seems like a lot to me...
John in NM
By the seat of the pants, I would have guessed maybe half to 3/4 that amount.
Smart thing though is to work it out along the lines Bill suggests.
Re: I have 36 in 832 ft�
Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio
and there are times when I'd like to have another eight or ten...
no need to be bright everywhere
Bill Tindall
It would be an unusual shop that needed that level of lighting everywhere. While the "task" areas benefit from high illumination the surrounding areas only need to be lit about 1/10 as much to maintain effective illumination for a task area . For some tasks it makes more sense to provide spot lighting of the limited task area. The whole work bench could be lit to 200 CP but it makes better sense to just provide localized light at say a drill press or grinder.
Consider multiple switches
Henry Higginbotham
My shop is about the same size as yours, and I have eight fixtures, each with four 48" tubes. There are three light switches. The first controls all the tubes in the the two fixtures nearest the overhead doors (where I least often need a lot of light). The second controls the outside tubes of the remaining six fixtures, and the third controls the inside tubes. Not that much more trouble to wire, and it provides great flexibility.
And, to your actual question: I feel I have plenty of overall light with all tubes on. But I also agree with Bill Tindall's suggestion of task lighting, and with that, sixty tubes is, I think, overkill. Unless you've found some nice, used fixtures for next to nothing like somebody I know--then go for it!
I have 26 T8 7500 degree K in 576sq/ft
Phil Joines
The walls and ceiling are painted gloss white. It's kind of like a tanning booth 
Re: Is 60 t-8s (4') 9' over 732 sqft too much?
JL
I would consider about 1/2 (or less) the lamps for overall illumination.
I would probably use maybe another 1/4 of the lamps (fixtures) for task lighting in the areas where you need it.
I don't know what tools you have in your shop. I would recommend more light in the following areas (if you have them).
Table saw
Workbench
Router table
Drill press
Mortiser
Lathe
Planer
Not so fast. Whadayawanto do
Gary Smyth
I�m sure that you know that there are published engineering �standards� for almost everything if you know where to look. Try �Time Saver Standards for Architectural Design Data�. It�s over 1000 pages and expensive (about $100 at Amazon-- but find a used earlier version for a lot less as most lighting "standards" don't change) but many libraries will be able to get you to a copy. Engineering schools should have the latest edition. As Bill pointed out there are factors. Color temperature, reflectance, and foot candles near and on the task area being of the more important. There is also the Illuminating Engineering Society Lighting Handbook. The web may be able to get you there.
In footcandles here are some standards.
reading 30, note taking 70, drafting/inspection 150 to 200, dental light at mouth 1000, operating table 2500, work tables 100, records management 150. There are literally hundreds of other recommended specs. Indirect (reflected) light will help reduce shadows. Light is measured in degrees Kelvin (K). Color temperature is measured on the Kelvin scale where the "cooler" the light, the higher the temperature (just the opposite of the Fahrenheit scale). Warm lights are below 3,100 K (yellowish) and cool lights are over 4,000 K (blueish); 3,500 K is considered neutral. You need not bother with why, but remember, outdoor daylight standard is 5500 degrees Kelvin. Incandescent bulbs in home lamps are typically 3200 degree. A good old fashioned photo light meter will get you footcandles and you can read it directly. If not available perhaps the web can help�it�s been a while since I did that kind of work.
Time Saver Standards for Architectural Design Data *LINK*
Stuart Johnson
Buy it here for less than $4.00 including shipping
Time Saver Standards for Architectural Design Data
No harm, no foul but
Gary Smyth
you may have mixed terms. Rather than being the amount of light that falls on an object (which is measured in foot-candles), candlepower (CP) measures the amount of light produced by the source, measured at the light source. This measurement is more commonly known as "candela," and the terms candela and candlepower are interchangeable. Foot-candles and candlepower are not.
Re: Thats about what I used
Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana
BUT, I do have multiple switches so that "strings" of lights can be turned on individually. As I aged (70 now), I found I need a lot more light to see the same things I used to be able to see with a candle. If the lighting is switchable, I think you are on the right track. As has been stated above, other issues come into play such as wall / ceiling / floor and other items color and reflectivity. I sure don't regret putting the "extra" lighting in my shop. Still hard to seen real fine lines for me sometimes. My 40 YO youngest son says it is lit up like a sunny day but doesn't seem to bother him. I have 3 switches that control my florescent lights and 1 that turns on five 100 watt halogen bulb fixtures (seems to give truer color). Another thing I found is that the "sunlight" bulbs seem to give a lot more visible/sharper light at least to my old eyes. I have changed most of my bulbs to the sunlight or other High temperature style bulbs.
you are of course correct
Bill Tindall
My brother-in-law, the lighting engineer(GE), has smacked my knuckles for reversing these terms enough times that one would think I would get it straight by now. Maybe I need more CP, or is it FC?
OK, 44 it is
Ron
My situation is white walls and ceiling. Dark floor. Yes, not all on one switch.
I've looked over the many notes about your sqft, # tubes, and opinions about whether your light is adequate or not. Computations re FC and such, not so much, but I appreciate everyone's willingness to share.
Ramped back to 44 tubes in 11 fixtures for my 732 ft2. It's getting wired this next week.
Thanks all!!
Ron
Re: I have 26 T8 7500 degree K in 576sq/ft
Keith Weber
I also have 576 sq. ft (12' x 48'). I have 24 4-foot T8s and find the shop to be nice and bright. That's the equivalent to about 31 bulbs in 732 square feet. I think 60 bulbs is overkill by a large margin.