Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Shutter/wood expansion question

Posts

Shutter/wood expansion question

#1

Shutter/wood expansion question

Pat Evans

BIL's shutters rotted and I am making new. They are just 3 vertical 1x6 held together by two horizontal 1x6. Given the cross grain condition, is slotting the holes for the outboard screws necessary to allow for expansion? Or is that overkill?

Re: Shutter/wood expansion question

#2

Re: Shutter/wood expansion question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

It depends a little bit on the wood you're using, the screw size, and where you live.

If you're using countersunk screws, I'd do three things:

1. Don't use hardened screws, which are usually a little more brittle.

2. Use a lightish screw size, say #6.

3. Drill the body holes (the holes that the screws pass through on the way to screwing into the other piece of wood) larger than they need to be.

This will give the screws room to flex a little, while the countersinks maintain the alignment.

Around here, Victorian/Edwardian house lap siding up to 10" wide is installed with two nails at top and bottom (about 8" apart), with, generally, little wood failure. I use box rather than common nails to install it on my house, figuring the nails will flex; so far, it's worked.

Re: Shutter/wood expansion question

#3

overkill.  Here's why

Grant in Iowa

So long as you fasten on the diagonal, you are golden. An example:

If you drive a screw an inch from each edge along a 45 degree angle, and assuming expansion and contraction occurs more or less evenly on each part, the assembly will move to compensate without undue stress. You can even add a screw to the center of the space between the two screws on the same diagonal and not have issues.

Lets say you have a part six inches wide at 6 percent moisture content. You drill two holes on a 45 degree angle an inch in from each edge. Do the same only mirror image on a second piece. Now subject the two pieces to any weather you choose to your satisfaction. No matter what you do, the two holes will be more or less the same distance apart. Therefore, no stress will occur.

You will be fine with your design so long as you don't put screws or fasteners in other than on the diagonal.

Think it over and I invite other thoughts on the subject.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa