Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

[AD] Tablesaw Survey *LINK*

Posts

[AD] Tablesaw Survey *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

[AD] Tablesaw Survey *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

An old friend, Joe Johns, has asked us to publicize a survey that he is involved in, regarding tablesaw use and accidents. Follow the link if you would like to participate in the survey.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Hey y'all,

I first want to let you know this survey is hugely directed at the safe usage of a table saw.

Although there are two questions hovering around it, the survey has absolutely nothing to do with the sale of the SawStop technology - nor does it have anything to do with us making a single dime on the outcome of the responses.

What we're trying to do with this survey is to gather a more broad response and was prompted by a recent discussion on another woodworking list I've been running since 1996. The responses there were quite interesting.

By "we" I mean myself and Graham McColluch of the Shortcuts column hailing out of Nova Scotia, Canada

The link to the survey is...

http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/WJKL6YC

Joe Johns,

Twisted Knot Woodshop, "There's never been a classier joint"

http://www.twistedknotwoodshop.com



Tablesaw Survey

Re: [AD] Tablesaw Survey *LINK*

#2

Re: [AD] Tablesaw Survey

Joe Johns

First, I want to thank Ellis for agreeing to do this.

Now, I want everyone to know that this survey has nothing whatsoever to do with promoting or propagating SawStop. Further, I want you to know that it is not my intent to cause any heated debate(s) on whether it is or isn't the magic pill to assuage someone getting injured using a table saw.

So, I'm going to tell you exactly what I told Ellis when he emailed me privately asking about the survey.

"Graham McCulloch (he runs the ShortCuts column up in Canada? I'm sure

you've heard of him) and myself are running this survey.

http://www.shortcuts.ns.ca/column/column732/

It all started when someone posted a note on our Sawdusters ww'ing email

list about the SawStop. Well, the discussion got some pretty interesting

returns - mostly dealing with the disgust at the attempt to make the thing

mandatory on future table saws. Graham and me wanted to broaden - quite

literally, broaden, the discussion to find out just how many people are

getting hurt using the machine. We realized, as everyone already knows,

that the saw is blameless but we wanted to ask real woodworkers other

questions.

"and what they plan to do with the results."

As far as I know, I nor Graham have zero to gain from this other than

knowledge. We're not selling it to anyone and SawStop has nothing to do

with it. I will say that it MAY - heavy on the MAY - at some point end up

in an article in some ww'ing magazine.

As for what we'll do with the results? I will say the following for a fact:

It will definitely be posted on my web site

It will definitely be in one of Graham's future columns

Beyond that, Ellis, this is a hands-down honest thing."

Now, before you pick on the writing of the survey and how some of the questions seem to be poorly structured, I posted the following explanation on WoodNet.net...

"Despite some of you saying the survey was poorly written, I am not a bad writer.

At the time I discovered "Survey Monkey" I signed up for the free account. In their brilliant maneuver of hiding the fine print I found out that their statement of "unlimited questions" really meant ten questions and if I wanted to ask more then I'd have to upgrade.

Well, that pissed me off so I went back to my ten questions and restructured some of them so that they would be questions within a question therefore including some of the questions we really wanted to ask.

After we launched the survey we found out that our "unlimited responses" was true but, again, The MONKEY would not let us look at any of them past one hundred - anything beyond that we had to upgrade.

By this time (because we're running the survey on several other venues) lots of people had already taken it and we thought it was unfair to change the question structure(s).

So, either take the survey or not - I really don't care, but, please, don't call me a poor writer."

Thanks to all for taking the survey and especially Ellis.

Joe Johns,

Twisted Knot Woodshop, "There's never been a classier joint"

Visit the shop: http://www.twistedknotwoodshop.com

Re: [AD] Tablesaw Survey *LINK*

#3

Are we going to get the results here

Dustmaker Mike

as well? Or will there be a link to them when it is over, so we can see them?

Thanks

Mike

Re: [AD] Tablesaw Survey *LINK*

#4

Re: Are we going to get the results here

Joe Johns

Hey Mike,

I'm glad you asked that question.

Per our agreement, I will send the results directly to Ellis.

It will then be his decision on how he chooses to convey the information.

Joe Johns,

Twisted Knot Woodshop, "There's never been a classier joint"

Visit the shop: http://www.twistedknotwoodshop.com

Re: [AD] Tablesaw Survey *LINK*

#5

Like to see them also.

steve mackay

Re: [AD] Tablesaw Survey *LINK*

#6

Re: [AD] Tablesaw Survey

Robert R. Clough

Joe, Graham McCulloch had this survey on his Short Cuts. I answered it there.

Re: [AD] Tablesaw Survey *LINK*

#7

Re: [AD] Tablesaw Survey

Neal in San Jose

There's a problem with the survey. Question #2 will not accept just (other) as an answer, but forced me to check one of the brands listed.

Re: [AD] Tablesaw Survey *LINK*

#8

Re: [AD] Tablesaw Survey

Stuart Johnson

Neal, I took the survey when it first came out on Joe's site and when I checked other I had to type in the brand.