Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Questions on Tried & True Finish

Posts

Questions on Tried & True Finish

#1

Questions on Tried & True Finish

Todd Nebel

Hello,

I'm building a tool chest from an article in a woodworking magazine and the author recommends using Tried and True Oil Varnish. The wood is curly cherry. First question is can I finish the inside of the chest with this? It looks like from the article's pictures that the author did. I typically would not use oil on the inside of a closed case since the smell lingers for a long while. Does the varnish allow you to? Next question is what to do between coats? The author says he sanded. The instructions say 0000 steel wool and burnish it. What's the recommendation here? Also, the instructions say to use a very thin coat. I found that hard to do on a test block. The product is relatively thick and requires a moist cloth to apply. Do they just mean wipe it well before moving on. That's my guess as the instruction says to come back in an hour and wipe it until there's no sign of product on the cloth.

Thanks,

Todd

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

#2

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

If it were me, I would not use oils. I would use shellac. But that's me. T.

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

#3

JL

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

JL

I've used this product. I "diluted" it with Tried & True Danish oil (1:1). It took a while to cure out, but it did cure eventually. I used another product for the inside of the drawers.

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

#4

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

Jim Dillon

Todd,

I use T&T varnish almost exclusively (along with shellac), and like it a lot. My experience on a china cabinet (doors opened infrequently) is that a slight smell will remain, but I don't find it objectable (in fact, I kinda like it), and I doubt your tools will mind :). On my kitchen cabinets, I notice no smell at all. Having said that, if you want, use a coat of blond shellac on the interior to avoid odor problems. Personally, for a tool chest, I would not bother with shellac.

I apply the T&T with a white, non-abrasive "sanding" pad. I just dip a small portion of the pad in the T&T, then apply. I don't worry too much about starting with a puddle of the stuff, but do make an effort to wipe it out to a thin coat. After an hour (or less), I wipe it off and allow to dry for a couple of days. Then I lightly sand with a gray sanding pad. After that, I just apply multiple coats with the white pad and do not bother to sand with the gray pad again. I sometimes apply a coat of wax to finish things off. I just love the feel of the silky smooth wax finish (and smell) on cherry wood.

Speaking of which, with cherry, I first apply a 1# cut of blond shellac, allow it to dry, then lightly sand with a gray pad. Following that, I apply the T&T as usual. This approach might, hopefully, minimize any blotching of the wood, and it seems to work.

When I use tinted T&T (using TransTint dye), I only allow the first coat of T&T to set for 15 minutes or so, but maybe an hour would be OK to, only the tint would likely be darker.

There are reports of T&T not drying. I have only seen this with red oak paneling. Otherwise, it seems to dry just fine in a few days. You can also warm the T&T up a bit to allow it to spread more easily, but since most of my finishing is done in the summer when it is 98 degrees in the shop :( , this isn't a real problem for me. Hope this helps

Jim

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

#5

First coat...

Todd Nebel

Thanks Jim, that was super helpful. I will have to get some white and gray pads. I think I'll go with shellac on the inside. I have sliding trays and boxes to make for the inside and shellac will just be faster. The case will have time for several coats and time to cure while I work on the rest. But once they're done I'll want to get using it. So, shellac is the choice here. I included a photo of the first T&T coat on the outside of the lid and case. I'm really pleased with the silky smooth look already.


Todd

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

#6

Wax?

Todd Nebel

Hi Jim, what brand wax would you use on curly cherry? I'm about out and need to buy some anyway. I like Antiquax (Beeswax and Carnauba).

Thanks,

Todd

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

#7

Re: Wax?

Jim Dillon

Good morning Todd,

Beautiful looking cherry! I have never used figured cherry, but maybe someday... . Regarding wax, I would go with what you have had luck with in the past. FWIW, I use Mylands clear for lighter woods (like cherry), and Mylands antique mahogany for darker woods such as, well, mahogany. For several jewelry and music boxes, I like the smell of lavender and have used Town Talk. I keep a can of Renaissance wax on hand as well. While I have found it somewhat difficult to buff out if you don't catch the drying step just right, it is great for applying to wooden drawer runners because it is so hard. I applied it years ago to locust runners in my shop bench and am always amazed that the drawers still slide so easily. As an aside, I also use the Renaissance wax for protection of my TS top.

Although you have already started your finishing process, I have found that the initial application of the 1# blond shellac (dewaxed) to the wood will result in a slightly lighter overall appearance after the T&T is applied. I happen to like this, but YMMV.

Be sure to post a pic when your tool chest is finished!

Jim

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

#9

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

Stephen Shepherd

Todd,

If you don't like the smell, just put a handful of charcoal briquettes or lumps of hardwood charcoal inside and they will absorb the odor. Then you can dispose of them in the BBQ, the gas they absorb with be burnt out before the coals are ready for cooking.

Stephen

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

#10

Ellis Walentine

Nifty technique

Ellis Walentine

I've never done that, Stephen. Have you? I thought that varnishes and other finishes out-gas for a long time. How quickly do the briquettes work and does subsequent out-gassing stink up the cabinet again after you remove them?

Ellis

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

#11

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Nifty technique

Stephen Shepherd

Yes, I have done this. Also works on cigar and cigarette smoke odors in upholstered furniture, put it in a big garbage bag. I also removed the smell of varnish on a wardrobe and the smell from drawers as well. The varnish I use is either turpentine oil varnish, which has more odor, but put in a bit of gum Benjamin and the smell is sweet. Alcohol based spirit varnish odor goes away quickly, turpentine based spirit varnish has a lingering odor.

The charcoal sucks up the gas, leaving space for more gas which it also sucks up. Once the odors are removed they seldom return. If so repeat the treatment.

Stephen

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

#12

Good to know...

Jim Dillon

... since Rennaisance Wax is not inexpensive, although a little goes a long way.

Jim

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

#13

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

Howard Acheson

***** DELETED ****** DUPLICATION ******

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

#14

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

Howard Acheson

I would not recommend or use T&T on a tool cabinet. T&T is a soft, not very durable or protective treatment. I doubt that it would stand up to the abuse that tools being put in or taken out would provide.

Yes, the odor will remain almost forever. How bid a concern that is for a tool chest, only you can determine.

If you proceed with the T&T, I suggest you carefully follow the manufacturer's instructions. They want you to be successful with their product and have spent lots of time developing what they feel is the optimum application regimen.

Finally, lots of folks have problems with T&T. It requires a very, very thin film application and then vigorous complete wiping dry. Than let it dry which will take quite a while. Test it out on some scrap before you commit to your project.

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

#15

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

Todd Nebel

Jim, it's been like two weeks and the first cost hasn't dried. I waited a week and then rubbed the wood with 0000 steel wool. That only drew the oil out. I've been vigorously wiping it with a clean cotton cloth daily and it still feels soft. What are my options?

Thanks,

Todd

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

#16

Re: Questions on Tried & True Finish

Jim Dillon

Good evening Todd,

I'm surprised, especially with cherry. Other than the red oak I mentioned (which finally dried after a week or so), I've never had a problem with walnut, cherry (although I have no experience with figured cherry), hickory, mahogany, maple, spalted maple, ebony, QS sycamore, spalted sycamore, QS oak, jatoba, locust, QS fir, and various veneer plywoods, etc. Usually a couple of days were sufficient. Does your wiping cloth still pick up T&T residue? With open grain woods like oak, T&T behaves like other oil finishes and some "bleed" will occur over several days from the open pores of the wood. In those cases, I would just keep wiping the residue. After a day or so, everything would be fine. But with cherry, I have never had a problem. If you are not picking up residue on a clean rag, I would assume the T&T is reasonably dry and would add another coat if desired. Sorry I couldn't be more helpful. If I think of anything, I'll be back in touch.

Jim