Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Phillips bit questions

Posts

Phillips bit questions

#1

Phillips bit questions

Barry Irby

I bought some deck screws that came with a Star or Torx driver. It was one of the little short ones about an inch long. I wanted to use my impact driver so I bought a pair of drivers made by the same company (Grip tite). Perhaps it would be more accurate to say it was sold under the Grip Tite label, I have no idea who made it or the screws, but they had a Gripe Tite label. All the drivers fit the screws so poorly I returned and bought one made by (for?) Bosch. It was better, but a bit loose. The others were so tight they would not fully seat in the screws.

So, after all that effort and expense I decided to try to go back to Phillips Screws. Bought two five pound boxes of the at the borg. Spotted what appeared to be some excellent driver bits made by Senco of their Duraspin Driver. Paid about $11.50 for two six inch bits. Today, I used one of them to install the pickets on a deck rail. I pre drilled the 2x2 pickets and drove 2 1/2" through them using a little Bosch impact driver. Wet treated wood. After about 200 screws one of the bits is showing significant wear and cams out of the screws easily.

Am I right to be disappointed in the driver bit? For $5.75 I expected it to last longer.

And a second question. Has anyone tried to grind one down past the wear?

Re: Phillips bit questions

#2

Re: Phillips bit questions

Galen Vetterick

I assume in both the Torx and Phillips you are using the correct size bit for the fastener.

The Phillips bits are doing just what they are designed for. The Phillips head is designed to cam out under high torque. The driver is to be damaged before the screw head. (although you can put enough force on them to strip the screw if you just keep trying) 200 screws in wet treated wood is not that bad.

Don't buy the long bits as you can have a tendancy to drive with the bit at an angle. Use the short stubby and you can buy a lot more for the money. They are considered disposable!

Torx were developed to overcome the cam out action of the Phillips.

Re: Phillips bit questions

#3

Re: Phillips bit questions

Howard Norman

I only use square drive screws anymore 95% of the time. Usually buy them from McFeeleys.

Re: Phillips bit questions

#4

JL

Definitely Square Drive

JL

I switched to using square drive for the theatre sets. I bought a bunch more than a year ago. The bits and the screws have survived an entire year w/o any real problems. This is with continuing construction and deconstruction of sets.

I would typically run through Philips head drywall screws like "potato" chips. I'd also run through the bits.

Re: Phillips bit questions

#5

I'm sure you are correct, but....

Barry Irby

It would make more sense to me if the drivers were permanent and the screws disposable. In most cases you will drive a screw once and use the driver many times. Somehow, making the driver softer than the screws does not make sense.

Re: Phillips bit questions

#6

Jim Rahbe, Bedford Texas

It's you, not the Torx..

Jim Rahbe, Bedford Texas

Barry,

Something is not right with your set up. The star headed deck screws are the only ones I use now. Square heads are much better than Phillips, but the torx (star) bits are the best, at least for me. I�ve installed several hundred and have yet to wear a bit out. I have lost several, but have never had to throw one away because it no longer fit.

There are more than one size, but the bits I use are all # T25 (Dewalt) that I get at the big box stores. Using an impact driver, you can drive a screw right through a 2 x 4 if you want, without the bit slipping. For the short bits, that come with the screws, I use an adapter that fits the impact driver.

I can't believe that the screws and bits we have here in Texas are any different than the ones you are using.. Except ours are currently about 105 degrees, in the shade.

Jim R.

Re: Phillips bit questions

#7

I got irritated...

Barry Irby

At the variety of screw configurations. I don't need four or five different kinds, I need one good one. I was astounded to find that the torx screws at 2 1/2" required a No. 20 driver and at 3" require a No. 25. I switch back and forth on screw sizes as I change jobs building a deck Its stupid to have to change bits. The fit of the torx bit in the screws was so bad it was dangerous. The bit would only engage if you put excess pressure on the screw as you started it and that made it flip the screw over and you tend to stab yourself in the finger. This was after I bought a set of brand matched bits and a different brand bit. If I had not been so far from the store and needed the screws to move on, I would have returned them. We cursed our way through five pounds.

Re: Phillips bit questions

#8

Make sure you're leaning hard enough on the driver

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

In my experience, what wears bits out more than anything is not leaning hard enough on the driver; I know this because it's one of my weaknesses.

Re: Phillips bit questions

#9

Re: It's you, not the Torx..

Barry Irby

I thought so too. I bought the five pound box of torx screws on purpose because I was sure they were better than Phillips. There is something wrong with this box of screws. Its as if they have paint in the heads and the bits won't engage. They look OK, but the bits simply does not want to fit into the socket. And I have used both the bit that came with them and the two bits I bought that were the same name brand and specifically labeled as being the correct size. As I mentioned above, I would have returned them except that once we go to the job we struggled with them to get on with the job and I hated to take four pounds of screws back and bitc..er complain, so I bought new drivers. Then went back and bought another new driver. These are hateful, whatever there problem is. The Grip Tite driver seems to be over sized and the Bosch Driver is undersized even though they are labeled as being the same size. The Grip Tite driver is clearly tapered and the Bosch driver appears to be straight. This is not my first trip to the Rodeo, I have used hundreds of pounds of screws in similar projects. The last porch I built required thirty pounds of screws just to screw down the floor.

Re: Phillips bit questions

#10

Re: Make sure you're leaning hard enough on the dr

Barry Irby

I absolutely agree. You are correct.

I have been thinking about the comment that short drivers are better than long ones. I have generally bought the ones that are about 2" long and the hex shank that snaps into the impact driver. I had one or two longer ones for just that occasion where a longer bit is necessary. My son can't resist the longer one. I explain that we only have one or two of the longer ones and many of the shorter ones and that eh shorter ones are cheaper. Somehow, he can always find the longer ones and never sees a shorter one. So, to cut down on strife I gave in and bought what appeared to be excellent longer bits that I assumed would last quite a while. I am seeing the Senco bits as being crap for what I did with them. But, my thinking is that it is easier to keep the driver fairly well aligned with a longer bits. With a short bits, a small movement changes the angle dramatically. With a longer bit changing the angle requires significantly more movement. I think????

Re: Phillips bit questions

#11

Re: Phillips bit questions

Pat Evans

I bought a pack of American Vermont phillips bits and they are the best I have ever used. Somehow they seem to wedge into the screw head and rarely slip out.

Re: Phillips bit questions

#12

Thanks

Barry Irby

Re: Phillips bit questions

#13

I buy the shorter bits

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

They're cheaper.

I do have a magnetic extension in my driver, which means the shorter bits are effectively longer bits; you may be right about the angle issue.

I have no idea what brand my local contractor's lumberyard sells, but they're very good bits.

And, as to the question of whether the bit or the screw should be the weak link: I can testify that it's easier to change a bit out of the driver than remove a screw on which the head stripped when the screw was almost but not quite home.

Re: Phillips bit questions

#14

Phillips bit answer

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

Get a lump of beeswax and drag the threads of the screw across the lump before driving the screws. You'll be amazed at the difference it will make on the amount of torque required to sully seat the screws and how much less wear you will see on the driver. Beeswax on the threads will reduce the torque to drive the screw by at least half.

Lee

Re: Phillips bit questions

#15

"better" than bee wax- machine shop wax

Bill Tindall

Machine shops have a stick of waxy stuff (a cylinder about 1 1/2" x 10" long) that is used to lubricate something, maybe band saw blades. This stuff is easier to transfer to screws than bee wax. It is more sticky and lubs as well. I got my first nub or a stick from a machine shop and then ordered a full stick from MSC or Enco or the like.

Re: Phillips bit questions

#16

Moses Yoder

Re:Operator skill / screws on decks

Moses Yoder

I remember when I started driving screws, I went through both square and phillips bits at a pretty good clip. As I became more experienced at driving screws, doing it every day for 8 hours, I learned how to drive a screw without making the bit slip. This is the key to long bit life. And I would have to say if I was building a deck I think the joists would be nailed, because nails are not hardened therefore won't break. The decking would be screwed down with square head bits.

Re: Phillips bit questions

#17

Impacts are tough on bits...

John in NM

Some manufacturers make the bits softer to keep them from shattering when used with impact drivers, leading to just the situation you describe. I prefer the shattering though, one's not tempted to keep using a worn bit :D

I've used about three sets of Dewalt bits through five years of building on and off. They have about a 3" holder and a box of assorted 1" inserts, and you can also buy a box of 25 phillips inserts. Last box of those I bought seemed just about right, they don't shatter after 20 screws (I've had that happen) but they seem to last a long time before breaking. May have just gotten lucky, I'm sure a spinning thing that breaks steel bits sends Dewalt's lawyers screaming into the night.

Re: Phillips bit questions

#18

Jesper, Denmark

Re: ...or the old boatbuilder's trick.....

Jesper, Denmark

When driving literally thousands of screws in hull planking, dipping the screw tip in linseed oil before driving.

Had the linseed oil in a small can with a hook to hang from the top of the planking.

Re: Phillips bit questions

#19

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

For Phillips bits, I like... *LINK*

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

the Phillips II ACR2 Platinum bits. I get them from the blue box store, near the Tapcons usually. I get the 2" version--I hate those short, little "disposable" bits. The ACR2 bits have a shiny, silver finish, and seem to be fairly hard. I'm far more likely to lose one or break one than to wear one out, and even breakages are rare, though that seems to be the failure mode. They also have little ribs on the wings of the tip that have enough grip that I can point it down and hold a screw with it, even without a magnet (you have to twist the screw onto it a little).

My take on Phillips bits is that if it cams out, you're not doing something right--either off-axis driving, not pre-drilling, etc.

Jason


http://www.amazon.com/3-80202-Phillips-ACR-Bit-6pk/dp/B002UZAXX2/ref=sr_1_23?ie=UTF8&qid=1312283480&sr=8-23

Re: Phillips bit questions

#20

Re: It's you, not the Torx..

Gary Bindel

You're not alone Barry. I have had the same experience where the bit didn't fit the head. Your description of paint in the head is right on. It is like the coating is too thick.