Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

Posts

keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

#1

keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

kellyanderson72

Hey, I have a question for everyone.

I have one of the original JET SuperSaws with the short legs. It has been and still is a great saw for me. The original fence quit locking during a cut on some plywood shortly after I got it but the distributer replaced it with an Exacta II fence and it is great. Every thing is good.

I have found a Unisaw on Craigs list locally. It looks like an older model, 50's or 60's probably. I have sent an email but have not heard back from the seller yet so I do not have much information. They are asking 550.00

My question is would this be a trade up? I know it would depend on the condition of the Unisaw but all things being in good shape what would you think?

I appricate your opinions. Thanks

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

#2

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

Jesse Cloud

I have a unisaw, and its a good saw, but if you are happy with your current saw, what would the unisaw do better??

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

#3

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

kellyanderson72

Well I guess that is the question. Would an old Unisaw be worth buying to have over my current saw? My shop is not big enough for two saws so I would have to sell the Supersaw.

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

#4

Steve Strickland

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

Steve Strickland

I would be skeptical of a $550 Unisaw. I seriously doubt that "good condition" would apply.

But let's assume it's a good saw, the main casting isn't cracked, the trunnion isn't worn out, the arbor bearings aren't flopping round, the centrifugal thingy in the motor isn't frozen up, the top isn't rusted out and it's a single phase (not a 3 phase). Heck, it might even have the doors and panels still on it. Rarest of rarities is an original blade guard/splitter!

The Unisaw is a superb machine. Even the old ones are great. It's hard for me to imagine a better table saw. It is a heavy beast. You cannot move it by yourself without taking it apart, unless it's on a mobile base.

Old worn out ones can be rebuilt by you at home and Delta has a very good video series on rebuilding a late 1940's model with a reference to an antique woodworking machines restoration website. With a $550 price you should expect problems but there's almost nothing that can't be fixed by the home amateur with access to the right information.

If you like your current saw why bother unless you just like fixing up old saws. I doubt the Unisaw will do anything the Jet can't do.

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

#5

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

Randy Johnson

"I would be skeptical of a $550 Unisaw. I seriously doubt that "good condition" would apply."

But you never know.

I know a guy who was doing some work for someone that let it be known they would like to sell �dad�s old saw�. He asked the price and they said 200 bucks. The man had a Grizzly cabinet saw he was happy with, but he figured for 200 bucks he might as well see what kind of saw �dad� had.

That�s how he wound up with two cabinet saws. The original Grizzly, and the Powermatic 66 that he got for 200 bucks.

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

#6

JL

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

JL

You have a saw. You are happy with the saw. Let's look at the differences.

Big one - weight - the SS weighs maybe 380 and the US weighs maybe 550 lbs. The extra weight does mean some extra stability - but is it really that much of a difference? Chances are you can't shift your SS without a great deal of effort - and certainly not during use.

Big one - power - the SS requires a dedicated 110 V 20 amp circuit. The US requires a 220 V circuit. Do you have 220 V? if not, that's an extra expense. What does the extra power do for you? You've got a 1.75 hp machine in the SS. You'd be getting another 1.25 hp with the US. Are you ripping that much thick hardwood for it to really matter? If you have a good sharp blade, your SS can rip everything that the US can rip - except not as fast.

The Exacta fence is a good fence. The older Unisaw might have an Unifence - which is also good.

If you were stepping up from a contractors saw, I would probably go for it. As you are stepping up from a hybrid Supersaw, I'm not sure. I just don't see enough of a difference in capability to warrant a change. If you want to do it and get enjoyment out of restoring old machines - then consider it.

My $0.02.

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

#7

550 is not low, but high

McKay Sleight

At least in this area, because of the unfounded desire to be "safer", many UniSaws have been replaced in schools etc. This has placed many unisaws in the market. I have owned a unisaw for many years and I would question any saw that was priced higher than 450.

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

#8

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

Dave Paine

You do not state what feature differences between the Supersaw and Unisaw. Mostly max cut width and motor HP.

I used to have a Craftsman 22144 hybrid, made my Orion, now using Bridge City Toolworks name. This had a Bies. "pro" fence.

The saw was accurate enough, but the 1 3/4 HP motor was not big enough for thick cuts in dense woods like maple. I had to go slow and got some burning even using thin kerf top quality blade.

I eventually bit the bullet and got the new Unisaw with 3 Hp motor and 36 max cut width vs 31in. Passed on the Craftsman to a friend. This was a step up from contractor saw for the friend.

Older Unisaw's were built well and thick steel. Some came with only 1 1/2 HP motor.

If your potential Unisaw does not offer any feature benefits, I would stick with what you have and know.

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

#9

Ellis Walentine

My 2�

Ellis Walentine

I'd check the motor and fence first. Many of the old Unisaws (including my first Unisaw) had a 1 1/2-HP motor, and it just isn't enough to rip through 2" hardwood efficiently. Also, the fences on those saws were primitive and unreliable. If you're used to an Exacta fence, you will never be satisfied with the old Unisaw fence, so figure in the cost of retrofitting a modern Exacta/Biesemeyer-style fence.

Beyond those two primary factors, check the table for flatness, make sure you have room in your breaker box for a 220-v 20-amp breaker, and see how the switch is working. It's good to have a magnetic switch, and you may find that the old saw didn't have one, so that would be another upgrade item.

I also think $550 is a lot, unless it has the 3-HP motor.

Ellis

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

#10

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

Jesse Cloud

If it were me, I would keep the saw I'm already happy with and use the $$ to buy a tool I don't have yet... I think you would get more bang for the buck that way.

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

#11

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

kellyanderson72

Thanks everyone for your opions.

From the pictures it looks like it is in good, original condition with the original delta round rail fence. The top is covered in plastic in the pictures so I do not know what that looks like. It has the original light switch type switch and the description says that it is wired for 110 so I assume that it would be a 1.5 hp motor.

I emailed some questions and the owner responded with a phone # and asked to call him. I will try this afternoon to get ahold of him to ask some questions. I was going to offer 350.00 would that be out of hand?

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

#12

JL

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

JL

No. Not in my opinion.

But why? You have an excellent saw. If you aren't stepping up to a 3 hp motor, why spend the money.

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

#13

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

kellyanderson72

To be honest with you it is probably the "idea" of a Unisaw more than anything. A true cabinet saw. And I really like look of the old Unisaws, I know looks aren't everything.

I haven't talked to the seller yet so I do not know anything specific and he may be insulted by my offer and tell me to take a hike.

As far as power goes, everything that I have heard before sounded like the older motors that may be rated for a lower hp are usually stronger than todays motors that are usually rated for no load, going down hill with a strong wind behind them to seem like they have more power than they actually do.

Any way we'll see what happens this afternoon when I call, Thanks

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

#14

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

FredD

I have bought more table saws then most and my rule is ,never touch a offer unless I have inspected it first, for any power tool.

In this case you not getting anything better then what you have and you could be out 555.00 bucks if the saw is not in good condition and of course Delta upgraded the saw motor a long time ago to 3 H.P. for a reason.

If you really need a Cabinet saw, look around locally . not Craig's list or Ebay.

FredD

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

#15

Re: keep the Supersaw or get the Unisaw

kellyanderson72

Well I got to speak to the owner tonite and we figured out that it is a 1952 model from the serial #. He could not find the plate on the motor but said that it was wired for 110 so I am going to assume that it is 1 1/2 hp at most.

He said that he bought the saw and some other things from the previous owner of the land and that he paid 550.00 for the saw and did not want to come down too much in price because of that.

Oh well you can't win them all. Thanks for all of your advice everyone.