We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
This is done all the time in industry, although .003" is pretty tight. I don't know about the surface quality, either. That sounds like a possible challenge.
Repeatability can be acheived using a CNC lathe. And you can likely get the finish required without sanding. But I think you will need some very hard wood to maintain .003 tols.
CNC would definitely be the way to go. I did some spindles using a duplicator and was able to hold a tolerance of +/- .010. A CNC would get you there if you used a wood that is stable like Mesquite. Still not sure about .003 however. The lenght would not be as much of a problem as the expansion and contraction over the width.
There has been research done on most woods of the world. It might take some digging but you can find data on how each species moves.
I would not expect too much problem IF (1) you can hold the 3/4" dim. to less than the required finish dim. This, in my opinion would be somewhat difficult as the material would tend to shrink more in one dimension with changes in humidity. A CNC lathe is more than capable of holding .0001" as far as machining. A good turret lathe probably would do the job and hold within .001". Remember any error (out of square/tolerance etc.) will be added to the machining tolerance. One issue I can envision being a problem is "chucking" the piece, as a normal metal chuck would probably have enough pressure to deform all but the hardest woods. The other issue I can see is that the "cone" would likely become oval shaped when humidity changes occur after machining. I would think the finish would not be a problem with very hard woods and proper tooling.
It is dimensionally more stable, takes finishes well, and can be cut quite accurately. I can't say if it will hold .003" tolerance but it's definitely more stable than solid wood.
The stability is certainly an issue on all my puzzles. The solution I have evolved over the years is to use a well insulated shop with heating and air conditioning. My target is typical indoor conditions. The wood is brought in and maintained constantly at the target conditions until the project is complete and the product shipped.
I use a 2 stage finish that greatly inhibits moisture migration - Velvit Oil plus Lemon Oil. Once that's cured the puzzles are shrink wrapped and stored in the shop so that they never experience any environmental change until it's shipped.
The technical data on wood is a free download on the Forest Products Laboratory website.
The sanding question relates to the fact that sanding degrades my geometry and precision. The less sanding the better. I've also noticed that it's cheaper to sharpen the sawblades than it is to pay for sanding labor.