Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Need a better air filtration unit.

Posts

Need a better air filtration unit.

#1

JL

Need a better air filtration unit.

JL

I have a small "portable" that is not really enough for my shop. The dust collection system does well enough for the power tools, but I don't really have enough for sanding.

My shop is 18' x 25' x 8'+ = 3600 cu. ft. for the main part with a 7' x 7' x 8'+ (392 cu. ft.) "extension". Call it 4000 cu. ft.

I'm looking at the Jet AFS-400 - $225 at Rockler.

I'm also looking at the Jet AFS-1000B and the Dust Right 1200 (~$330 and $300 at Rockler).

Re: Need a better air filtration unit.

#2

Re: Need a better air filtration unit.

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I currently have a JDS-750 installed. Very convenient with the three speeds, timer and remote. Cost me $275 on a special sale. I got it after I installed our old kitchen cabinetry in the shop which mandated removal of my original air cleaners, those being a pair of 20" box fans fit with two layers of high performance furnace filters. I made frame holders for the fans and filters and hung them from the basement shop ceiling joists. You can see one of them in this photo, top edge, right of center, just above the drill press.

I had the fans set up on timers so they'd run for an hour or so after I left the shop.

The JDS does a good job (JETs are basically the same), although cleaning the filters can be something of a pain, but to be very honest, the old box fans were better and much quieter as well.

Re: Need a better air filtration unit.

#3

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

and at $30 each [box fan plus filters] the fancy units can't begin to compete on price/value.

Ideally, place two units on opposite sides of your space, facing in opposite directions, so you get a continuous circulation of the air.

Re: Need a better air filtration unit.

#4

Re: Need a better air filtration unit.

Pat Evans

Mark's box fan filters are your best bet, but I would use them as portable fans. I have the same fan/filter but with a base so it can stand on any surface. I can position mine directly behind any sanding, routing, or sawing operation to pull dust away from me and into the filter. Without mine, I could only work for short periods then wait for the dust to settle. With mine, I can work all day.

Re: Need a better air filtration unit.

#5

Re: Need a better air filtration unit.

Stuart Johnson

I had the fans set up on timers so they'd run for an hour or so after I left the shop.

Mark has made a good point. How many of us have very dutifully used our air filtration or dust mask while sanding and then turned or taken them off just as soon as we finish the sanding? The dangerous dust is going to still be hanging around just waiting to get sucked into our lungs.

Re: Need a better air filtration unit.

#6

PPS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

The filters were set up with an outside spun-glass version (cheap) and the inner one with the high performance HEPA-rating. The outside filter got a very light spray of PAM to make it stickier. That got replaced about once a month. The inner filter would then last between 2 and 3 months between changings. SWMBO once remarked that the shop was cleaner than the rest of the house as there was little or no dust settling on things.

BTW, every sander used in my shop is only run when hooked to a shopvac with a HEPA filter. I would not depend on any air cleaner, other than a true sanding table with blower and filters, to control the bulk of sanding dust.

Re: Need a better air filtration unit.

#7

Cleaning inner filter

Hoa in Alameda

"....cleaning the filters can be something of a pain."

Hopefully this will ease the pain a bit.

Find a vacuum cleaner attachment that looks like the one at the bottom right in this photo. The longer and bigger, the better ;)

With a 1" (or larger) Forstner bit, drill several holes on each side of the "flat" part of the attachment. Offset the holes on either side so you don't have any "through" hole.

There, use it to vacuum the inner filter.


img

Re: Need a better air filtration unit.

#8

Thanks Hoa

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I vacuum the outside surface of the JDS pre-filter regularly. I clean the filters by removing them, taking them outside, reversing the pockets, and then blasting the things with high pressure air until they don't release more dust. Naturally I'm wearing my respirator when doing so. Filters come out pretty clean, but the neighbors aren't real thrilled if the wind changes direction.