Goncalo Alves
John Veerkamp
Is tiger wood (Goncalo Alves) safe for food use? I have leftover/scrap from building deck railings. I 'm thinking of some rolling pins and spoons. Any experience with this wood?
Thanks,
John
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Goncalo Alves
John Veerkamp
Is tiger wood (Goncalo Alves) safe for food use? I have leftover/scrap from building deck railings. I 'm thinking of some rolling pins and spoons. Any experience with this wood?
Thanks,
John
Re: Goncalo Alves
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
Wood is not especially toxic but it does act as a sensitizer, most often by contact with the dust. Not sure I'd use it for unfinished treenware, but a platter that is lacquered should be fine. Personally, I would not use it for a cutting board or where dust and chips may be generated and ingested.
Remember, its similar to Cocobolo and there a two clases of people when it comes to that wood; those who are and those who will be sensitive to it.
Re: Goncalo Alves
Ellis Walentine
As Mark says, Goncalo Alves is a sensitizer, although not a particularly potent one. I have built furniture of it and never had any reaction that I was aware of, but then, I still work cocobolo regularly without incident. Personally, I wouldn't worry about using it for a cutting board, but I don't know if you or your likely guests are hypersensitive to whatever's in it.
Ellis
Re: Goncalo Alves
paul in AZ
This question comes up regularly, only the name of the wood changes. At the risk of being a curmudgeon I would like to know if there are documented cases of allergic reaction to foods prepared on cutting boards or with rolling pins made of woods known to be allergenic.
allergic reaction to sawdust or splinters is one thing but how much wood can be ingested from a rolling pin unless one gnaws on the wood?
anyone with any hard data on this?
Re: Goncalo Alves
JMOHNIKE
I have not worked with the wood, but it seems that there is no set opinion. If you are not sure and that there is a chance that it might make someone sick, don't use it. Stay with the safe woods, you can always use the wood for something else, like a hand plane.
Joe
Unlikely
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
You'll find hard data, Paul. But the issue is, given the wood's established sensitizing nature and the range of human physiology, why run the risk? We know the risk, but we can't control exposure to the item by someone who may be unusually sensitive. Like Ellis, I've worked Cocobolo, rosewoods, Lignum, and Goncalo without incident over the years, and wouldn't have an issue making stuff for my own use. Putting it "out there" for the general public is very different, however.
Re: Smokers
Moses Yoder
The risk of getting lung cancer from smoking is much, much higher than any danger of toxicity from wood. Yet how many people do you see smoking every day? And we are worried about a cocobolo rolling pin or cutting board possibly causing a reaction. What gives?
Re: Unlikely
paul in AZ
Mark, on a purely intuitive level you could be quite right to err on the side of safety.
My question is can you show me a case study of such an event actually happening? I don't want to get into a philosophical or personal injury lawyer type discussion but wonder if there is documentation of such allergic reaction actually occurring. I've made cutting boards from a variety of woods that are otherwise scraps and am curious.
And
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
After all, how many people do you see smokin' wood, right? 
First
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
I'm not a P.I. lawyer. I stay about as far away from that stuff as I can; had more than my share as a puppy-lawyer working in my Old Man's office.
That said, I am, as all lawyers are, a trained pessimist when it comes to proposed behavior. That risk-adverse attitude has stood me very well over a long period of time, and I can comfortably say that, while there are some who may debate how much "good" I've done, I'm pretty sure I've done no harm.
Re: Goncalo Alves
Clint Searl
There's a case of a man in Nebraska who died of an allergic reaction of sorts when his angry wife hit him over the head with a cutting board of Goncalvo Alves.
Clint
Re: And
paul in AZ
I'm grinning.
I smoked some mahogany yesterday by absent mindedly trying to run it through the shaper with the cutter spinning in the wrong direction. BIG blue smoke. Not very smart but nothing bad happened.
Logical error
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
There are lots of people who drink to excess, shoot each other, etc., too; but that doesn't mean you should let your children set the couch on fire.
I think making a decision about what wood to use for a cutting board based on whether or not the wood is a likely allergen makes perfect sense. But, then, I have a wife and two sons who are sensitive to, of all things, wheat; so I may myself be hypersensitive on the subject of sensitizers in the environment.
That's Funny
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
I heard the same story except it was a rolling pain made out of "cocobongo"
That's wood from a dual-purpose tree
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
You get coconuts from it, and the wood's good for making bongo drums.