We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
With two young kids at home I'm trying to do as little work as possible on this project. I'm installing a built-in closet. I've sprayed the doors with Sealcoat and they look pretty good. I was going to topcoat with some Target lacquer, but if I can get away without doing it...why not?
But will the shellac stand up over time? I will also use the same finish for the drawer fronts.
Here's the doors hung...I will build in drawers underneath.
As part of the doing as little as possible part of this project, I bought the doors unfinished from Multiwood - here's a shot of their shop. Amazing place...almost any type of door in any type of wood customized to your dimensions (including custom rail widths, etc.), ready for pickup in 3 days. Cost was about $140/door (18" wide x 50" tall).
Re: Is shellac tough enough finish for closet doors?
They are going to get abused and worn if you have little ones in the same space. After raising ten of them, I can attest to the effects of exhuberent and innocent rough housing. I would use poly.
George
Re: Is shellac tough enough finish for closet doors?
Re: Is shellac tough enough finish for closet door
Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana
I would think so. My son & I made all the woodwork for his house from rough White oak (planed, molded and sanded) - Baseboard, cove, window and door trim. We stained them, then applied 2 or three coast of amber shellac. This was 3 or 4 years ago and it still is looking good. It is so easy to refinish / repair any scratches or dings you can certainly try it and if you aren't satisfied you can later clean it with DNA and top coat with any finish you like.
Re: Is shellac tough enough finish for closet doors?
Re: Is shellac tough enough finish for closet door
Stephen Shepherd
Go with shellac, it will work a lot better than modern finishes that can't be repaired easily. Shellac can be touched up, it's natural, no petroleum distillates and it isn't hard plastic that doesn't move with wood movement. Shellac is an excellent choice.
Stephen
Re: Is shellac tough enough finish for closet doors?
While shellac itself isn't derived from petroleum, an irrelevant factor to most, its processing and formulation certainly involves petroleum. While some ethanol is derived from corn that could otherwise be used for food, ethanol, as well as the other solvents to be found in a product like Zinnser are. The most common, and least expensive, route to ethanol begins with ethane, a by-product of natural gas production.
Shellac isn't a "hard plastic" but it is certainly hard and brittle as anyone that has dissolved flakes can see. However, any finish properly formulated will "move with the wood".
Re: Is shellac tough enough finish for closet doors?
While shellac might not be completely petroleum-free, it's about as close as a non-water-based finish is likely to get.
Shellac has been (and still is) used as a finish for hardwood flooring, and it holds up very well in that regard, plus it's very easy to repair if/when damage does occur. Its only real enemy is moisture - like adjacent to an entry door that might see rain blowing in.
Used on a door, it should last nearly forever if it's maintained with a littl wax occasionally. The garnet shellac on my interior doors is about seven years old now, and they still look like new. The wife even uses (gasp!) Pledge on them once in a while.
Re: Is shellac tough enough finish for closet doors?
.... when fully dried no matter what type of alcohol is used to dissolve it.
Yes, it is a quite hard and can be inflexible in thicker films. But film when apply in normal film thickness is more than flexible enough to withstand normal activities--even from children. I made a toy box 20 years ago and it still looks good.
Re: Is shellac tough enough finish for closet doors?
I have never seen any credible data to suggest that any finish is toxic except lead pigmented paint. In any case the original question was about toughness.
Re: Is shellac tough enough finish for closet doors?
We have a hung parliament or congress or whatever your local form of governance is. Half are for shellac, half are against shellac and everyone likes to argue :-)
Thanks for your input. Now I have to decide. It's not too much work to put two coats of WB lacquer on as long as I don't screw it up and have to sand it off and do it again.
Re: Is shellac tough enough finish for closet doors?
Not to put to fine a point on the discussion Steve, but what do you think a couple of WB coats of Lacquer will do for your doors , that a coat or two of 2 Lb cut Shellac won't, it has to be the most nearly fool proof film coating out there with easily the longest history of use and performance.
WB Lacquers are a recent, relatively speaking, end run around VOC requirements that has put Solvent Lacquer nearly out of business in some States , like California and don't have the depth or the warmth associated with solvent Lacquer.
But since you asked , there you go.
FredD
Re: Is shellac tough enough finish for closet doors?
My experience with shellac has not been very good. I have French polished two side tables. I've refinished one top because it imprinted very easily by objects such as lamps, or even just fabric coasters left sitting on the surface. The other tabletop which I gave to my Grandmother needs refinishing, mostly due to imprinting and numerous watermarks.
The bases and drawers on both tables are fine, but the finish on the tops was ruined within months with very gentle use. I also sprayed shellac on a special vase. The shellac was quite soft to the point that business cards left sitting in the vase left deep impressions in the shellac. All this was with flakes freshly dissolved in alcohol.
So my experience has been that shellac is not very durable at all. I've always had trouble with shellac and tried a couple different batches of flakes to ensure that I didn't have bad flakes, but always ended up with with what I thought were soft finishes whether applied by pad or when sprayed. The shellacked surfaces were also very difficult to sand without gumming up.
I've also noted that dye (Transtint) impairs the sandability of shellac and SealCoat.
On the other hand, I've finished a coffee table, a similar vase, and refinished the one side-table top with Target WB lacquer. I agree the stuff is kind of plasticy looking especially if applied too thick, but so far it has been indestructable to the point that I don't really mind when my daughter runs her toy truck up and down the surface of the coffee table.
I recently sourced some SealCoat, which has to be special ordered here because it is not normaly stocked by any stores. These cabinet doors are my first time using SealCoat. It appears to dry much faster and harder than my home-dissolved-flakes and it also sands much better than any of my home-dissolved-flakes, so am willing to give the SealCoat a try, but I really hate to waste any more time giving shellac a third or fourth chance.
Thus the question I posted...I'm hoping that the SealCoat shellac is much better than my experiences with home-dissolved-flakes and wanted to hear what people thought about shellac in this service.
Re: Is shellac tough enough finish for closet doors?
I usually stay out of these arguments but here is my 2 cents. Use what you are most comfortable with it will easier and you will get the best results. Sounds like if you have had problems with shellac in the past it might not be the best finish for your doors.
Tom
Re: Is shellac tough enough finish for closet doors?
The shellac is on there and looks good. Why not just leave it alone and see how it holds up for your application? If it doesn't then you can always recoat with something else like varnish.
Re: Is shellac tough enough finish for closet doors?
I agree with Bill on this. I read the whole thread. I have never bought the flakes and tried them, but I have used Sealcoat with good results. I am impressed that such ancient technology holds up so well against modern chemistry. Sorry you had poor luck with the mixed version, but if I already had Seal Coat on, I would go with that.
Re: Is shellac tough enough finish for closet doors?
The only harm is time. Right now it would cost me 1 hour to spray two coats of WB lacquer.
If I have to refinish the doors later it might cost me 8 hours to dismount the doors, sand down, get the spray equipment out, refinish, and remount the doors.