Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Drawer pull placement

Posts

Drawer pull placement

#1

Drawer pull placement

Bill Tindall


The pulls are paper cut out copies from a catalog. The question is spacing. Books that have pictures of 3:2:1:1:1:1 drawer pattern center the pulls on the top two rows of drawers and then locate the single drawer pulls in line with the double drawers. It looks a bit odd to me but acceptable.

Can anyone think of any different arrangement to try.

The bow front acts as a lens and I have yet to get a good reflection-free picture of this piece.

Re: Drawer pull placement

#2

Re: Drawer pull placement

del schisler

that is the way i would do it add 3 at the top than 2 than two single line's down for the other drawer's look's good

Re: Drawer pull placement

#3

Re: Drawer pull placement

Ron Jones

I agree with Del.

Re: Drawer pull placement

#4

Clint Searl

Re: Drawer pull placement

Clint Searl

On two-pull drawers, I like them centered between 1/6 and 1/5 in from each side, regardless of the single pull drawers. I think more than rules, the pulls need to be visually balanced with the drawer sides, neither spaced too close to the sides nor too centered.

Clint

Re: Drawer pull placement

#5

Re: Drawer pull placement

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Keying on the 1-pull second-tier drawers is fine, but those pulls must be centered on their respective drawers. In the photo you've posted the pull in the second tier drawer is not centered on that drawer. That placement will not do as it needs to move toward the outside.

Re: Drawer pull placement

#6

Re: Drawer pull placement

FredD

Works for me , not a lot of choices that won't detract from the design and that is the way I would go.

With the amount of time and effort you have expended so far , why not try your hand at some you design and make.

FredD

Re: Drawer pull placement

#7

Moses Yoder

Re: Drawer pull placement

Moses Yoder

I don't know if it is just an optical illusion, but the 2nd drawer from the top looks like the pull is spaced to the left. If it is centered, I think your spacing is correct.

Re: Drawer pull placement

#8

Re: Drawer pull placement

Dave Paine

The chest of drawers I have at home uses two pulls on the large drawers. I tihnk originally purchased from Ethan Allan by my mother-in-law. More than 20 years old, but I would consider "modern".

Mine has two rows of two half size drawer and 3 sets of full size drawers.

I like the look of two pulls on the large drawers.

If a single pull were used, it feels the pull may be too small to easily pull without causing some sideway deflection and friction.

My chest has the wooden rail in the center. Not how I would do this today.

Re: Drawer pull placement

#9

Re: Drawer pull placement

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Hello Bill,

I'm not sure who I agree with the least. Surely I do agree your proposed placement will work. Visually, I am not so sure that the pulls in the third bank need be aligned with the pulls on the single drawers. When I used the curser to "place" imaginary pulls on the left of the chest, they appeared to be too close together on those full drawers. I'd move both left and right pulls on the third through bottom drawers closer to the chest sides. Alternatively, I'd also consider another pull design befitting the period and design. Of course, that would be another mock-up. However, it would be time well spent. BTW, I've followed your progress, and its first class.

George

Re: Drawer pull placement

#10

Re: Drawer pull placement

Rob Sandow

One suggestion is that you have centered holes for the posts on the pulls top to bottom on each drawer. The way I have seen it done is if the holes are drilled slightly higher than the center. Since the pulls are not symmetrical top to bottom, mounting them a bit higher than the center of the drawer is more visually appealing. I discovered this when I made a set of bedroom furniture and I centered the pulls on the 2 night stands but they didn't look right. On the larger dresser, I elevated them about 1/2 inch higher than centered and they look much better.

To your specific question, I believe the pulls look better on the full width drawers if they are farther apart. I don't think it is extremely important to align them with the pulls for the half width drawers.

Re: Drawer pull placement

#11

More information

Bill Tindall

Thanks to all for the thoughtful comments. George, the pulls are period authentic. And, what ever pulls go on I have the same problem of what to align with what.

An examination of many 3:2:1:1:1:1 drawer configurations in auction catalogs revealed that every possibility has been used. The arrangement that looked worst to my eye was with the pulls on the single drawers aligned with the pulls on the three top drawers. It made the bottom drawer pulls too far apart. By far the most common arrangement was to have the single drawer pulls aligned with the pulls on the double drawers.

To my surprise there was one piece that aligned the single drawer pulls between the the 3 and 2 drawer rows and it look good. I think I will install the top two rows and have another look at what to do about the single drawers.

many commented on the vertical alignment. I have measured this factor on several dozen period chests. What looks worst is centering the posts on the drawer. Locating the posts for the pulls between 3:2 and 3:4 on the drawer height was most common and looked best.

Re: Drawer pull placement

#12

STRESS is.....

Bill Tindall

drilling the pull holes in drawers. I am holding the drawers in the vice to drill them and I nearly got one backwards where I would have been measuring from the drawer bottom rather than the top.

I found a cherry chest of drawers in the Connecticut Valley Furniture book very similar to my piece. My best guess on vertical pull location matched what was in the book exactly. The pins holes will be proportioned 3:4, top to bottom on the drawer. Many drawers in this book with back plates had pull pin hole ratios of top to bottom of between .5 (pull in the middle of drawer and it looked strange) to 0.85 (pull way to the top of the drawer).

Re: Drawer pull placement

#13

Re: STRESS is.....

Barry Irby

I am somewhat dis-lexic or dis-graphic or maybe just a little bass-ackwards. Doing repetitive things that involves lefts and rights and ups and downs drives me crazy. I have to be very careful and stay focused. The phone always rings. I find myself doing little mantra's. GSU-FTL (good side up, from the left) The other side might be GSD-FTR. OHMMM!