Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Style question

Posts

Style question

#1

Style question

Mike Donaldson

I Am building a jewelry box for my wife as a 10th anniversary gift, the front and back will be quilted maple, the sides will be bloodwood, joined with a box joint. The top will be a bloodwood border with a raised panel of basswood in to which I will carve her initials. The box will be about 4 inches deep, and the lid will be an additional inch on top of that. I was thinking of using a spline joint for the top, with maple splines in the bloodwood. Would it look bad to mix a box joint on the body with a splined mitre joint on the top?

Re: Style question

#2

Not in my opinion, no

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Miter/mitre* joints in tops are fairy common, and the lines pointing toward the center are a nice detail. If you make the splines open on the edge, that will repeat, or at least reference, the horizontal joint detail you have in the sides.

When in doubt with something like this, it's always nice to knock together a mockup. You could just do a quick and dirty box from pine, maybe mitering the corners (miters don't have to be perfect; best if they're closed on the outside), and take magic markers or paint and paint on your details.

High-contrast woods used in juxtaposition like that can look great or garish. People talk about rules for that, but I'm not always sure the rules are universally so; I've seen pieces that violate rules I've read and look great. Small pieces can usually get away with it more than big ones.

Bill, no expert on the subject

PS Anniversary presents like this get MAJOR husband points - but you no doubt already know that.

Re: Style question

#3

more fundamental question

Bill Tindall

There are people on this Forum that build stunning pieces from mixed wood like you are suggesting. And, I have seen some mixed wood things that just didn't work. Hope one of these people that have a good eye for mixing woods offers a considered opinion.

The whole affair of mixing 3 woods and two joints sounds risky to me. If you are risk adverse, or in the absence of some talented designer's affirmation you might consider the figured maple ever where but the top of plain maple, and traditional splined miters for the joinery everywhere.

Re: Style question

#4

Re: more fundamental question

Barry Irby

I tend to agree with Bill. There are people here that post pictures of their work and they blow me over. I am impressed and taken aback by the designs and the contrast in the wood. When I do it I often look at what I have done and think, "Whoa, not so good, I could have done better." Not sure that to have tried and couldn't is not worse than not trying.

I wondered about the box joints. With two different woods what are the chances the joint will fail or the wood will split? Four inches is not a great width and it might work well if the two woods have similar expansion and shrinkage characteristics.

Re: Style question

#5

Dale Lenz

Seems different to me...

Dale Lenz

but I say go for it, could be very interesting. Please show some pics when completed.

Good luck

Re: Style question

#6

Clint Searl

Your wife will love it...

Clint Searl

If not, there's always Plan B.

Clint

Re: Style question

#7

Re: Style question

Dave Paine

Mike,

I am not able to advise on box joint for the sides vs splined mitre for the top based on experience, but your wife may just appreciate the custom work. I would not worry.

I do have experience in combining several species of wood for contrast.

The attached picture is a custom frame I built for a retirement gift to my supervisor.

Bloodwood, wenge, lacewood and hickory. I liked the contrasts, so did the recipient .

Re: Style question

#8

Re: Style question

Mike Donaldson

Wow. That frame is amazing. I made a simple box out of scrap wood tonight just to cut my teeth on my new box joint jig. It actually turned out pretty good (by that I mean the joints all fit together perfectly, and the box is square). Now I just need to build a jig for the miter spline joint and start this box. Thanks for the input, I will post pics when I'm done.

Re: Style question

#9

One simple way to do a splined miter *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

One simple way to do a splined miter is to use what the British call "feathers." The article linked below shows the principle. A simple jig that holds the assembled box lid against the tablesaw fence with the corner down and the edges rising at 45 degrees each way will let you make the cut. Full thickness tablesaw blades are about 1/8", thin-kerf a little thinner. Cut appropriate stock to the right thickness (plane or sand it to fit), glue in place leaving a little sticking out, plane or sand smooth.

I've used this approach several times, and it is very strong. You want to select a tablesaw blade that will give you as close as possible to a square-bottomed cut.


Article on the subject

Re: Style question

#10

Re: Style question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I highly recommend the method that Bill suggests, having used that many times for picture frames of a variety of widths. I can't imagine what kind of force it would take to pull that apart.

However, you'll find it a lot easier to cut if you use a jig to hold your workpiece steady as you feed it against the fence. I'd show a pic, but I'm at work. A jig will register against the fence and hold the piece at the necessary angle, and do it consistently for all your joints.