Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

Posts

How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

#1

How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

Nathan

I'm restoring an old pine couch. We sent it to the dip tank to have the paint removed. We've had good results with this drastic measure before - the paint comes right off in the strong lye solution. It only works with soft woods.

Anyway, this time, one of the boards in the piece came back severely deformed. The board is part of a panel that is "captured" in a dado that goes all the way around.

To replace the board, I'm planning to chisel out one side of the dado (on the bottom, facing inward, where it won't be visible), insert a new board, and then glue in a piece of wood to replace the material chiseled out. However, the board will just "float" - it won't be glued to either side, so it could warp.

How would you go about replacing the board?

For pictures, click on the following link, which will take you to the page of my blog containing a play-by-play of what I've done on this project so far:


Bed repair project (blog page)

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

#2

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel

Barry Irby

Why not use a chisel to make the dado/slot at the top deeper, maybe close to twice its current depth and then make the replacement piece with a longer "tenon" on the top end. Then you could raise it into the dado/slot and drop it into the bottom one. This would be the same way you install sliding doors. You could put a small pin through the tenon at each end to keep it from coming out.

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

#3

Ellis Walentine

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel

Ellis Walentine

Interesting problem, Nathan. One aspect of this repair to consider is the amount of effort relative to the payback-- in other words, consider the danger that your replacement will warp and the need for it to be housed in grooves all around, in light of the work involved in housing it. There is no one answer.

If it were a valuable antique, you might be justified in routing out all the surrounding pieces and then patching them all after installing the replacement slat. I don't think that makes sense here.

Another option would be to rout out the stile as well as one end, then you could make a piece with tongues on two ends and one long side, and you could drop it in and glue it to the adjacent panel piece. Then you'd have only two rabbets to repair.

Let's see if anyone else can come up with a solution that preserves the integrity and appearance at a reasonable cost in time.

Ellis

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

#4

some thoughts on the problem

Bill Tindall

First, I presume we are talking about something equivalent to a frame and panel door with a warped panel.

Pine has little strength so it will take not much support to keep a pine panel flat. For whatever reasons the extraordinary assault from the stripper bath caused a failure that I would not expect to be repeated in normal usage with a new board even in a less robust panel construction. Hence, the solution proposed by Nathan seems reasonable.

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

#5

Re: some thoughts on the problem

Nathan

I presume we are talking about something equivalent to a frame and panel door with a warped panel.

Yes, except it's just one board that warped. Not the entire panel, which consists of three boards. There was too much end-grain exposed on the face of the board, so the stripper solution wicked in deep and caused major cupping - total destruction, basically. Although the board remained securely in the dados, it turned into a long, rectangular, shallow bowl.

I'm inclined to agree with Bill that the replacement board, given the thickness (1/2"), will not warp. And Barry's idea of deepening one of the dados is a better solution than mine. Also my thanks to Ellis for his thoughts. Routing out rabbets had not occurred to me, and that would be a good way to connect the replacement board to the surrounding pieces, but probably overkill for this couch, where slight warping certainly won't make any difference and might even add character.

Sorry if my description was inadequate - even though I'm a professional translator, I still struggle with words. That's why I included the link to photos of the project - because "a picture is worth a thousand words".

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

#6

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel

FredD

Since the back side doesn't show , why make your work harder.

Using a new board the width of the opening and the exact same height. on one long side form a tongue and the other long side a half lap groove.

install a backer board that bridges the opening from the back using say a 1/4" piece of plywood and glue it in place.

When it's dry tap in the new board with glue on the back and it should serve you well.

About dip stripping , you can depend on it ruining glue joints.

FredD

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

#7

Clarification

Nathan

The repair I'm doing is part of an old-style wooden couch which has five components - two wooden sides (frame and panel), a wooden back (frame and panel), a stretcher (just a long board) in the front, and a steel frame with a spring "sheet" stretched on it that holds the cushion and firms up the whole thing structurally.

The piece I am repairing is one of the sides. The lower rail of the frame will not be visible on the side facing inward, since it is under the level of the steel frame. But the stiles are visible - at least over that portion of their length that lies above the level of the cushion. (Fred, if I understood correctly that means your suggestion won't work?)

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

#8

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Solid wood panels in frame and panel construction are, in fact, not glued in. The grain of the frame runs in the opposite direction from that of the panel at the ends, and wood expands/contracts across the grain. So, if you glue it in, the wood will be prone to splitting.

You might consider attaching your repair piece with nails or screws instead of glue, both to ensure that you don't inadvertently glue the panel in place and so that you can remove it if the repair fails.

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

#9

Re: Clarification

FredD

Probably not.

One can see after enough information is given which way is the best way..

That relates to what Bill said just earlier , then of course I am slow when it is this hot, it did cool down to 105 just now.

Fred

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

#10

Chisel one of the mortises deeper

Grant in Iowa

Nathan,

Given that the board insert isn't tenoned on the ends (from what I can tell), you could chisel the groove in one of the rails (top rail would be best) deep enough to allow the new piece to be put in without disassembling the panel. Sort of like how a sliding door in a cabinet is installed.

It would be an invisible fix, and help preserve the pieces value.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

#11

Done! *LINK*

Nathan

Based on your kind advice, I decided to chisel the upper dado deeper. Once I got the board in the upper dado the friction fit was a bit tight, so it was a challenge to move it down into the lower dado. But in the end it worked out well - thanks!


Here's the updated project page:


Nathan's blog - "Couch repair" project

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

#12

Finished piece

Nathan

Can you see the repair?


Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

#13

All's well that ends

Bill Tindall

My favorite saying. Looks good. What next?

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

#14

Re: All's well that ends

Nathan

Oh, I've got a honey-do list that's a mile long :(

We've been remodelling the downstairs bathroom, and in the process somehow a plastic pipe broke and as a result I have to completely replumb the sink.

I know, you meant "what woodworking project is next"? We'll see :-)

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

#15

If it's a piece broken off in a fitting...

gary camp Bend, Oregon

Nathan you didn't say what the problem was but are you aware of the Pasco Ram Bit? They allow you to drill a broken pipe out of a fitting. A wonderful tool for maintenace use, they have saved my b.. ah tail several times.

glc

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

#16

OK, you asked for it :-)

Nathan

Thanks, Gary, for the recommendation. Not sure if the ram bit you mentioned would help in my case. Here's a picture of the repair:


If anyone is interested in the explanation, read on:

Here in Europe houses are very different. The wall this particular pipe (the drain pipe you can see in the picture, not the smaller potable water pipe) is in, was built 10 years ago out of "aerated concrete" blocks. Not sure if you have these in the U.S. - even if you do, I suspect they aren't very common. Around here they're a common material of choice for interior partitions, because they are pretty light, but of course not as light as stick walls.

The pipe I used back then for sanitation was a type of PVC. To connect two pipes, you heat the end of one until it becomes pliable and then you use the other pipe to widen the mouth. Once the two pipes go together the way you want, you then you use a special glue to make the connection permanent and move on to the next section of pipe (or the next fitting).

This system has since been replaced by a different type of plastic pipe, which has built-in rubber gaskets. Much easier to install - just rub vaseline on the gasket and connect the two pipes together for a "permanent" seal.

In the picture, you can see the old section of pipe and the new gasketed kind that I installed onto the old. (Yes, backwards - see below.)

Anyway, when I first plumbed the sink I had zero experience with home improvement and didn't know what I was doing, so I used a "flexible" drain trap, which also happens to be made of PVC. That would have been OK, but I made the mistake of gluing it into the fitting that protrudes from the wall. Now, fast forward 10 years - big bathroom remodel. Took the sink off but the flexible drain trap was hanging off the wall, because the glue had cured to the point where it had fused with the fitting in the wall - the "two had become one". There was no way to remove it. So it stayed, hanging off the wall, and during the remodelling work it got damaged.

In this picture you can see the damaged trap hanging (almost obscenely) off the wall:


At that point, I knew I was in trouble.

Of course, when I tried to remove the trap, it broke off along with a big chunk of the fitting in the wall. Since there was brand new ceramic tile on the side of the wall where the bathroom sink is, I chiseled into the aerated concrete from the other side, cut off the damaged fitting and installed the new gasketed type onto the old.

This, of course, is not completely "kosher" since the fittings are on backwards. But supposedly the gaskets hold even when installed this way. (Question is, how long?)

Anyway, I have the sink replumbed now, but it's a case of "one step forward, two steps back", because now I've got a hole in the wall to deal with! Today we stopped at the building yard for a fine mortar mix, which I will combine with plaster and use to patch the hole. After that I'll use a finishing plaster and smooth it with felt. My wife now does most of the wall-painting around here, so at least I won't have to do that part.

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

#17

Re: OK, you asked for it :-)

Joseph Mulherin

OK, you asked for it.... my comment: DIY DISASTER!!! You should get a competent plumber to do the work.

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

#18

Appreciate your input - question

Nathan

I'd be curious to know if any of you have ever seen a wall (or a whole house) built out of aerated cement blocks in the U.S.

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

#19

Re: Appreciate your input - question

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I am not sure what the equivalent term here in the states is for "aerated cement block". Basically I am familiar with 3 types of block used in this area (central Indiana), the first is the Cement block, this is heavy, structurally strong, and is probably the most common block used for all types of construction, foundations, support walls etc.. The second is Cinder block, this is a lighter weight block with volcanic cinder or coal replacing the sand and gravel, this block is used for building construction - may be used for foundations, walls etc. The third, which I personally have not seen used, is Lightweight concrete block, made by replacing the sand and gravel with expanded clay, shale, or slate Then firing at high temperature. This block is not used for load bearing walls. I have seen many houses and outbuildings made from the concrete blocks locally. The normal construction for homes built this way is slab concrete floors, concrete external walls and wooden stud interior walls - the external walls are normally completed with "furring strips" attached to the interior walls, then dry-walled. I have helped construct one of these homes for my Aunt and Uncle in the 1950"s, (house is still in use). The exterior is normally just painted or stucco applied. I have not seen many buildings constructed (other than commercial) using block for several years. I am sure this is due to the labor cost involved in laying the block. Years ago when labor was much lower concrete block homes were actually loser cost than conventional construction and were lower maintenance.

Re: How to replace a board in a captive panel *LINK*

#20

Correct term is "autoclaved aerated concrete" *LINK*

Nathan

Thanks, Larry. I'm familiar with cement block and cinder block (I grew up in Florida and lots of buildings there were made of cement block, and up north it's used in basements), but had never seen lightweight concrete block in the U.S. Here in Europe it is very popular for its insulative properties and the fact that it is easily worked. Special hand saws are used (with carbide teeth), and they cut through it like butter. It can even be used for exterior/structural walls (wall has to be pretty thick for that application, though), and the manufacturers push "systems" which include floors/ceilings made of the stuff.

Anyway, I found the correct English term - it's "autoclaved aerated concrete (AAC), also known as autoclaved cellular concrete (ACC) or autoclaved lightweight concrete (ALC)". The blocks are manufactured to precise dimensions and mostly they are laid on "thin-bed mortar", which is essentially the same stuff as that used to lay ceramic tile.

Your comment on the influence of labor costs on building construction techniques and choice of materials is very interesting, and makes perfect sense. The same economic reasoning takes place here in Central Europe, but there's a psychological resistance to wooden houses. There's a tradition of living in masonry houses that goes way, way back, so I guess people are just willing to pay a premium for bricks (or, nowadays, blocks) and mortar. Not that you can't have a wooden house built - you can, and they are cheaper to build, but very few people opt for them. Roof structures are typically made of wood, of course.

Our house was built in the 1930s and the exterior walls are all red brick. Except the brick is not laid longways, but shortways (the length of the brick dictates the thickness of the wall), and covered with stucco. Typical for houses built in the first half of the 20th century. Earlier buildings are usually built out of stone, with walls about 3' thick.

Here's the Wikipedia entry on autoclaved aerated concrete, if you're interested:


Autoclaved aerated concrete (Wikipedia)