Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

OT Why NOT air test???

Posts

OT Why NOT air test???

#1

OT Why NOT air test???

Barry Irby

Been working on the house I bought at foreclosure. We replaced all of the pluming fixtures except on bathtub and most of the copper pipe under the house because the copper thieves stole what they could get to. We pout CPVC back in place of the copper because I figured they would just steal the copper again if I put it back. Yesterday we turned the water back on and had a leak inside the kitchen wall. I cursed myself for not running an air test on the piping first, but the label on the can of CPVC glue said NOT to test with air.

So, Why not test with air? I'm guessing it is because it could be dangerous. Compressed air stores energy and could Burt the pipes and cause shards to fly. What do you think?

(I put an air test on it after the repair. Only used about 20 psi but that was enough to tell me I did not have anymore major leaks. Really did not like the water running out of the wall thing.)

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

#2

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

Ralph Lipeles

Most compressors are set to turn off at about 125 psi. Many people do not set the max output pressure so maybe they are worried anout overpressuring the pipes.

Ralph Lipeles

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

Moses Yoder

In today's sue happy world, manufacturer's instructions have everything to do with covering there asses and nothing whatsoever to do with common sense. I am not a plumber but I think water runs between 50-70 psi in the pipes. The pipes are not really made to handle 120 psi. Common sense says if you air pressure test at 60 psi you'll be fine. The only problem is if it blows up you can't sue the manufacturer.

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

#4

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

Dave Paine

Barry,

You answered your own question.

When water is pressurized the volume hardly decreases. If a leak happens, a small amount of water is released and the pressure equalizes.

When a gas is pressurized, the volume decreases proportional to the absolute pressure difference. If a leak happens, a large volume of the gas can be released before the pressure equalizes, resulting in potential for damage.

My company makes a very special pressure vessel. The factory uses nitrogen to pressure test, since water would take too long to remove, and in a cryogenic vessel any remaining water would freeze blocking passages,lines etc.

The safety requirements of gaseous pressure testing, even at 150 psi require the vessel to be located behind a bunker.

If the factory could use hydraulic pressure testing, the safety requirements would be less stringent due to reduced hazard from e.g. a weld giving way.

Personally for home water lines, I would not worry about using an air pressure test. As you stated, 20 psi is sufficient to determine if you have a leak.

Many of us use PVC lines for compressed shop air. This is highly debated in the forum from time to time.

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

#5

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

There is a logical reason not to use air for testing plastic - although with reasonable precautions I would use air. The reason is that there is a LOT of stored energy in compressed air. With non-compressible water, if a plastic pipe bursts, the energy is immediately released and the plastic shards will not fly very far. The only energy that remains is the amount of flow in the pipes. However with air, all the energy used to compress the air into the pipes is released and the plastic shards will fly much farther with more impact, possibly severely injuring an eye etc.. However if no one is in the immediate vicinity of the pipes there would be no danger. I agree that the odds of anything catastrophic occurring is very small if normal pressure is used (up to the pressure rating of the piping). I also agree that although the manufacture is aware of the very small possibility of injury, their lawyers certainly made it mandatory to include the warning to preclude any lawsuits. As metal or flexible plastic pipe's failure mode is to split instead of shattering, air can be more safely used.

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

#6

you got it

Gary Camp, Bend Oregon

It's the whole stored energy thing. If youtested it with air and it did fail it would likely be explosively. On the other hand the county required that that I pressure test my water supply line (250 of 2" pvc) of course it was buried.

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

#7

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

Hikmet C. Sakman Victoria, BC CDN

I think their concern is that air may move the uncured glue out of its place in case the test is done before the glue cures. If the glue cures in minutes or rather within a reasonable short time, then they are concerned their pipe may rapture if one uses 100+ psi pressured air. Nothing else makes any other sense about "no test" warning.

Chico...

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

#8

Compressed air not terribly "explosive"

John in NM

And the reason is it remains gaseous when compressed. Chemicals like propane undergo a phase change - gas to liquid - when compressed so the potential volume expansion when pressure is rapidly decreased (say through a leak) is huge, far greater than when there is no phase change.

Compressed air expands something like 10 times between atmospheric pressure and 120 psi, give constant temp. Propane is somewhere up around 300 times across the phase change, and cryogenic gasses like nitrogen and helium are higher still due to temperature changes.

So yes, there is potential for some danger from flying plastic shards if a pvc line broke under air pressure, more so than under water pressure, but it's nothing like the danger involved with critical fluids like propane.

One shop I worked for years ago had white pvc compressed air lines, they broke often where there was sun exposure. It wasn't a huge big deal, but would probably give a liability lawyer fits of glee :D

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

#9

Thanks all,  pretty much what I thought

Barry Irby

The instructions said to wait at least an hour before putting water in the system. I waited overnight. Then put on a twenty pound air test. Let the compressor sit for about an hour and it did not appear to leak down at all. Code requires an air test on new systems. Hmmm.

Nest time, I will air test first. It was a mistake to count on the system being sound in all the concealed spaces. It leaked inside a wall. I suppose it might have frozen or perhaps the Neanderthal that stole all the copper by breaking it off in the crawl space make have wrenched a joint loose indie the wall. Live and learn.

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

#10

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

FredD

The SOP when I was building required a air pressure test that held 20 PSI on the water pipes for twenty hours ,the gauge was at the front of the house where the utilities entered , so the inspector wouldn't get all dusty.

ABS at that time was the DWV pipe and required a ten foot head ,which means that a vent was left high before framing and then filled with water.

Simple test , excellent result if done correctly and if not ,the Plumber got to do it over.

FredD

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

#11

Kneale Brownson

It's the way the plastic fails thats dangerous

Kneale Brownson

The plastic under pressure shatters rather than just cracking and leaking. The bits of plastic can be as harmful as a bullet.

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

#12

Understood, but I disagree... *LINK*

John in NM

It's not as dangerous as a bullet, and I say that with the experience of working around a plastic air piping system that did experience failures, and some experience with ballistics, though not on the receiving end :D

Exaggerating dangers merely invites others to ignore them. Danger is a part of life and work, and better managed through accurate understanding rather than hyperbole.

There are advantages to using compressed air to test water piping, one should not toss out those advantages due to ill informed fears. Rated bursting pressure of schedule 40 pvc is over 1000 psi for sizes used in domestic piping, working pressure is likewise well over the capacity of most single stage air compressors, which is far, far more than needed for a pressure test. All this fretting over air tests is really very silly.

I'll include a link to a chart of pressures vs. size for convenience. If pipe were exposed to UV (sunlight) for more than a couple months, I would toss it and buy new. All failures I've seen around 100 psi involved sun damaged pipe.


PVC pressures

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

#13

Fortunately

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

OSHA disagrees with you as well, as they have banned PVC for gas pressure use unless the plastic is, in turn, wrapped in steel conduit. You may grouse about too much regulation, but the fact is that they rarely move to such rule-making until after people get killed.

Plastic works fine for water although I only use it for waste.

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

#14

Ahhh OSHA... *LINK*

John in NM

The great and powerful OSHA, leveler to the lowest common denominator, with whom one shall never, ever disagree! Begone individual judgement! Do not depend on the cause and effect nature of reality! OSHA knows best, thou shalt follow blindly! :D :D :D

Please note that OSHA is regulating compressed air piping, not air testing of water pipes. Oh wait, OSHA rules must apply universally to anything even remotely similar... this is after all, the internet :D If there is an OSHA reg concerning the subject under discussion rather than just a similar subject, please cite the reg by number or better yet provide a link.

The OSHA technical bulletin I found (link provided) contains the following quote:

". . . the above ground portion of the plastic service line is completely enclosed in a conduit or casing of sufficient strength to provide protection from external damage and deterioration." (emphasis added)

The conduit is to prevent damage and deterioration, not to contain the violent explosion of nuclear proportions that many seem to think is imminent when plastic is subjected to modest pressure from compressed gasses (yes, I too am using hyperbole... such a darn hypocrite! :D )

Please re-read my last post carefully, I am not in any case advocating the use of PVC in the installation of a compressed air system, merely looking at the ASTM standards for pressure in sched 40 PVC pipe and stating that pressure testing with air is both safe and viable. I say again, fretting over the use of air for pressure testing is silly - pressures used are very moderate (see Fred's post), duration is short (a day or less), and pipe is likely to be new and sheltered from sunlight and other damaging conditions.

Lastly, you imply that OSHA must be regulating the use of PVC for compressed gas installations due to many fatalities. If you actually expect me to believe that any PVC failures resulted in a fatality, please provide a link. Lacerations are quite plausible (and easy to find citations), fatalities are not.


OSHA technical bulletin

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

#15

Argue?  With OSHA?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Nah.

But then they were just parroting ANSI/ASME and ATSM who, perish the thought that somebody gets hurt (let alone killed) using "common sense", will frame the parameters used by the insurance company to decide whether to pay for the resulting injuries.

Your hyperbole sounds great, John, until you (and/or your wife) are the ones looking to have the medical bills paid.

"Yeah, I got blinded because the guy I worked for was too cheap to put in good air piping. Then $%#@ insurance company refused pay as well. Something about the damn fine print in the policy written by some liability lawyer."

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

#16

As I said...

John in NM

The subject of discussion is the testing of plastic water lines using compressed air, not the installation of a compressed gas distribution system. Were we discussing the latter, you and I would be 100% in agreement, and this series of posts would never have come up. Any tolerance I may show towards the failure prone compressed air system I mentioned earlier is relative to the claim that PVC gas piping is to be considered as dangerous as a bullet, and not to be construed as a recommendation for that use.

You are mixing two very different subjects that share some common parameters and reaching an erroneous conclusion as a result. The value and utility of OSHA, ANSI, and similar standards and guidelines lies in their specificity, not in their universal application.

Believe it or not, I have yet to find an OSHA reg with which I fundamentally disagree. What gives OSHA a bad name is the common misapplication of regs and misunderstanding of the intent of some standards leading to incorrect conclusions (there's a good example of that in our discussion). When these misapplications are put forth by a workplace safety rep is when the problems start and criticisms start to fly, it's really that rep with whom one cannot argue, not OSHA. The lowest common denominator stuff is just an irritant, not a real flaw :D

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

#17

Back To Tests

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

In my area, every new supply system (gas and water) is to be air pressure tested to at least 30 PSI "hold" for 24 hours. You don't get a CO without it.

On top of that, every licensed installer is required to bleach all interior sections of rigid water pipe (iron, copper, or plastic) and all fittings before installation.

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

#18

Interesting... never heard the bleaching one b4 *LINK*

John in NM

Probably a prudent practice with plastic pipe, but with copper bleaching is carry coal to Newcastle, as copper's anti-septic properties are quite well known. Won't do any harm though, as far as I know.


Copper study

Re: OT Why NOT air test???

#19

Rigid Pipe

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Sits in one warehouse or another and acquires both dust, spores, and bacteria. Put the pipe into wet service without running a wet bleach plug through it, and you're asking for trouble. Second source is the water heater. While new units are sealed, most local codes state that the temps should be set at 110�F. Using non-chlorinated water (well) or contaminated pipe can introduce the Legionnaires bacillus into the system where the 110� light-tight interior of the heater is the optimal place to grow that bacteria. I keep my heater set at 140�.