Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

Posts

Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#1

Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

john lucas

I've sold my Dewalt compound miter and my Craftsman radial arm saw. My intention is to get a sliding miter saw to replace these two. I need something that is accurate and repeatable to do compound miter cuts for segmented turning. I would also like to be able to cut wider boards that are hard to do on my table saw.

My original thought was going with a 12" saw for the increased capacity but several people have mentioned that 10" saws were more accurate.

What do you all think and which models do you like. I still like the Festool 12" Kapex but man is it expensive. I have played with one and really like it but it is almost double in price what the other top of the line saws are. I'm not sure I can justify that. This is still a hobby for now.

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#2

They Don't Come Any Better Than The Makita LS1016

Dave's Not Here

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#3

Take a look at this one  *LINK*

mdclor


Bosch 12" Miter Saw

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#4

Re: They Don't Come Any Better Than The Makita LS1

paul in AZ

If its as good as the older LS 1013 I absolutely agree. I've had a 1013 for >7 years and it still delivers perfectly clean dead accurate cuts every time. Even the factory blade is superb -mine has had a ton of use and I haven't had to sharpen or change it [yet]. A five star winner for me.

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#5

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

Dave Paine

I have a Bosch 10 in Sliding Compound Mitre Saw sitting on the garage floor.

In January this was replaced by a Bosch 12in Gliding Compound Mitre Saw.

So if you are interested in the 10in let me know. Going for a song....

I also wanted to replace my 10in Radial Saw. I felt the 12in Glider was close enough.

The 10in is repeatable. My gripe was the lack of dust collection. If this is not an issue for you, then consider the tool.

The Glider has much improved dust collection. Still needs cleanup, but far less dust.

The Glider mechanism is very smooth. Also the motor is mounted high with gear drive, so tilts about the same both ways.

The Bosch 10in is direct drive so tilts more one way than the other.

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#6

Clint Searl

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

Clint Searl

I've had the Makita LS1013 for over ten years. Lots of use with nary a problem. Original blade and still dead on. Great portable machine. I also have a Hitachi 12" with laser. It'll handle anything, but is fussy to keep accurate and the laser is a PITA to adjust; plus it ain't nearly as portable.

Clint

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#7

Thanks guys, Makita seems liked by many

john lucas

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#8

Moses Yoder

Re: Isn't Festool better than Makita? 

Moses Yoder

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#9

Re: Isn't Festool better than Makita?

Howard Norman

The Festool may be better than the Makita but it certainly will be more expensive.

Too expensive for me.

howard

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#10

Clint Searl

Re: Isn't Festool better than Makita?

Clint Searl

If the Makita does everything as well as the Festool and costs half as much, how can the Festool be better, unless the Festool delivers more self-esteem?

Clint

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#11

Moses Yoder

Re: Isn't Festool better than Makita?  *LINK*

Moses Yoder

I've used Omga chop saws, not sliding, that do everything the Makita does and do it 10 times better. Using a good saw is entirely different from using a mediocre saw. It never ceases to amaze me that someone wants to do fine work like segmented turning but they don't want a good tool. They don't want to spend the money to buy a tool that is made in America. Instead, they buy a saw that's made in China because it's cheaper. If you want a cheap saw that does an okay job, buy a Dewalt. But if you're going to tell me there is no better saw than the Makita, I'm going to draw a line in the sand and call bullshit when I see it. If you want to send more money over to China to see if they can continue adding on to the worlds longest bridge that they just built with our money, so be it. But don't come crying to me because your son can't find a job in the USA.

I was looking to see if I could actually determine where the Makita 1016 was made and found the post below. I'm wondering if this is just a random incident, maybe by someone who abused the saw, or if it's in fact common for cheaper saws?


Makita problems

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#12

Re: Isn't Festool better than Makita?

Thomas S Stockton

Moses

Kapex's aren't perfect either I suggest that you go to www.festoolownersgroup.com and search the festool problems board. I'm not knocking the kapex but putting it out there as another place to do research on tools. Personally I have an old hitachi chop saw that works fine but it spends most of its life stuffed under some other tools gathering dust.

The Omga's are a really nice saw and put all others to shame.

Tom

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#13

Re: Take a look at this one

john lucas

I've looked at the Bosch. Looks and feels sweet. However I can't find anyone who has done fine work with one to be able to answer the question, will it help me do miter cuts for segmented joinery.

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#14

Re: Isn't Festool better than Makita?

john lucas

Moses Those might be fabulous saws but I am really having trouble thinking about $1300 for the Festool. $1800 for Omga is far beyond what I can do. Probably the same reason I'm driving a Honda instead of a Mercedes.

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#15

Moses Yoder

Re: Isn't Festool better than Makita?

Moses Yoder

That's fine, buy what you want to. It is really smart to buy the best you can afford, affordability being the key word. I just hate to see more jobs go to China every time something gets bought. It just kind of got my goat when somebody posted there was no saw better than the Makita.

An article I read about segmented turning suggested making a sled for the table saw to cut the segments. It seems to me if you tried to cut these on any motorized miter saw except the Omga you would have little bits of wood sashaying all over the shop.

I drive a Dodge Neon (a car that was given to us when my wife's sister died) instead of a Mercedes because we have a rabbit, six dogs, 3 cats, a horse, and 3 birds to feed. Nevermind the money I spend on my shop.

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#16

Re: Isn't Festool better than Makita?

john lucas

Moses I'm with you on the China thing but unfortunately on my budget I have to go that way more than I like.

I do use a homemade sliding table to do segments on the table saw. my problem is my table saw also isn't high grade. I tried. I bought a Powermatic Artisan saw. I figured it was made 40 miles from me in McMinnville, Tn. It came drop shipped from Taiwan. Bummer. I was going through a buy American phase and every tool I ordered from an American company was actually made in Taiwan or China. During that same period I purchase a Chevy Citation and Dodge Ram 50. Both American I thought. The Chevy was an Isuzu reject I guess because it was a piece of crap. The Dodge was a Mitsubishi. I put 3 heads and 2 transmissions in it in 100k. Needless to say my next vehicles were a Honda and toyota. both made mostly in the US.

Anyway back to the compound miters on the table saw. I have always had trouble doing those dead on accurately with this saw. I guess it's just not high enough quality to do that. I have friends who do the compound miters on chop saws of various types and can do them successfully. Of course the models they have are not made any more which is why I'm asking for opinions in several boards so hopefully I will get what works.

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#17

Re: Take a look at this one

Dave Paine

John, I got the Bosch Glider in December. Like many models, it will be repeatable for mitres. The fence is calibrated to be right angles to the blade. Mine was slightly off. May have been factory, may have been shipping.

If calibrated, I feel this unit can be almost as accurate as my Incra mitre gauge.

I have not done much compound cutting. The bevel adjustment is better than my previous Bosch model. Very useful to be able to bevel same degree on both sides.

I tihnk this model and others could be used to cut pieces for segmented turning. From the little I have read, it seems to be common for some sanding of pieces.

I have a desire to try some segmented turning later, and hope to be able to cut either on this model or my table saw with Incra mitre gauge and not need to do any sanding for fit.

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#18

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

Jesse Cloud

From some of my previous posts, you many know that I own and enjoy several Festools, including the Kapex.

Whether the high price is worth it to you is totally subjective. There is no way anyone can answer that for you.

Here are my own thoughts on Kapex pros and cons.

The price is high, but Festool resale value is outrageous. I have bought a couple of Festools that wound up not getting much use - just didn't fit the way I work. I easily sold them for more than I paid (after a couple of annual Festool price increases). So I don't worry too much about buying a Festool and not liking it.

There are some very nice features, but they are incremental improvements over other miter saws. The Kapex is not a game changer like the Domino, the MFT, or the track saw.

Among the nice features are accuracy. I make compound miter cuts in 8/4 hardwood that are accurate enough for chair joinery.

The saw is easy to adjust and calibrate, including the laser. Once calibrated it keeps its settings. (Disclaimer: I do all my work in my garage shop. Can't say if this would be true in a portable/job site environment).

Dust control is easily the best I have seen on any miter saw, but not as good as on other Festool products. I would guess it picks up 90 percent - so you still need to do cleanup at the end of the day. By comparison the Domino gets so close to 100% that I can't see any dust at the end of the day.

For the hobbyist, it is fun to use. The bevel setting mechanism is brilliant, very precise, easy to dial in just what you need. It cuts cleanly and resets to exactly 90 degrees easily.

It is, however, still a miter saw. It is not a safe way to cut small pieces. Small cutoffs can go flying about.

When it was first introduced it had a problem with the miter swivel sticking. That has been fixed.

As for the whining you see on Festoolownersgroup.com, to me it seems that much of it is hobbyists who think that if they pay a lot for a tool, it should always produce perfect cuts whether the user knows what he is doing or not.

Hope this helps.

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#19

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Not to open a can of worms, but....

Jesper, Denmark

As I see the�r web site, Omga is made in Italy. From a US perspective, does it matter if made in Italy or China? My guess is that there is currently no US manufacture of chop saws - sliding or otherwise.

This brings the discussion back on track: What is the best quality saw, that I can afford? No matter where it is made. From a global perspective - both geographicaly and principally, that IS the right question.

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#20

Moses Yoder

Re: Not to open a can of worms, but....

Moses Yoder

Yes, Omga and many other saws like General are also foreign made. Lee Valley is based in Canada. The difference seems to be that Italy, Germany, Switzerland, and Canada make fine tools and China makes cheap crap. I really don't like to support people who make cheap crap, and if possible, I would like the USA to make stuff I can buy and use to keep jobs here. When did our economy start going down hill, and how long before that was the NAFTA agreement signed?

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#21

The Chinese can make good stuff too...

John in NM

Its just that few companies pay them to do that. They make most of the computers we use these days, you can't tell me they aren't capable of making good tools too if they can do that.

Don't blame the Chinese, blame Harbor Freight and our tolerance for cheap disposable items where there used to be "durable goods" :D

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#22

Consider the Joint Maker Pro *LINK*

charlie belden

Been thinking about the safety issues of cutting small parts for segmented turning with a miter saw or compound miter saw, slider or not. There's a lot of kinetic energy involved with a power tool like these. To reduce the potential for some or most of that kinetic energy from being translating into a flying piece of wood traveling in an unpredictable direction - at Mach 3 - both the stock and the cut off must be secured.

THAT's where things get tricky with CMS and SCMS. If the fences aren't adjustable to minimize the gap between them - into which a cut off can be pushed - you need to make an add on sacrificial fence and figure out a way to secure it to the saw's fence. The hold downs that come with these saws, or are "accessories" for these saws aren't designed for getting in close to the cut on short pieces, especially angles cuts and compound angle cuts. The hold ins have the same problem.

AND - cuts INTO or at a shallow angle to end grain (a rip cut) are a recipe for "bullet wood". I BROKE one of my Makita SCMS fences - and nearly a finger - trying that one. Never did find the cut off bullet.

Even if both the stock and cut off are secured - so neither can move fore/aft, up/down or rotate, it's best to let the blade come to a complete stop before raising it out of the cut -or risk experiencing bullet wood.

If you want precision AND safety - consider the Joint Maker Pro. How this thing works and what it CAN do is difficult to describe with words - tthe attached link to a video does a far better job.

Not "inexpensive" - but if you want precision AND safety - this may be the answer.


Joint Maker Pro

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#23

Re: Consider the Joint Maker Pro

Barry Irby

Min I like the looks of that thing and if I had some money I wasn't using for stupid stuff like food, electricity and mortgage payments I would get one.

If you made one of those pieces that and like 1920 segments think of the arms you would have.

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#24

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Not to open a can of worms, but....

Jesper, Denmark

So, happily, the aversion is against poor�y made stuff at discount prices. I can fully agree with that aversion. The root cause is that "people" are cheap and buy the stuff. We have the discount businesses here too with the same problem.

My personal preference is that I want the best tool that I can afford - no matter where it is made.

Globalization is here to stay - we all better get used to it and adapt to it. That means that high wage countries like North America and Western Europe have to change their manufacturing to something where the value of the goods is not mainly the labor content and/or reduce the cost of labor.

That is a painful transition - particularly for large economies and large companies, where quick change is difficult. Isolationism and trade barriers are not the solution. The shift started long before NAFTA - think VW Beetle, which took Detroit by surprise.

Re: Advice on sliding miter saw purchase

#25

Re: Consider the Joint Maker Pro

charlie belden

The blade on this thing is MUCH thinner than even a thin kerf power saw blade. And rather than left and right set teeth as found on a circular saw blade, or a "western" push to cut saw - this is more like a japanese "pull saw" with more complex teeth - that have almost no set - so VERY little wood is being removed - so very little muscle power is needed to make a cut.