Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Wood thickness question - thick enough??

Posts

Wood thickness question - thick enough??

#1

JL

Wood thickness question - thick enough??

JL

In my thoughts/plans for some shelving, I have a center upright. The upright is 3/4" thick x 11 3/4" wide. I was planning on using a stopped, sliding dovetail to connect the top, middle and bottom shelves to the side uprights and the center upright.

If I have two dovetails on either side of the center upright, this would give me an area that is ~1/4" thick x ~1/2" tall in the top, middle and bottom of the upright.

Most of the load will be vertical. Probably little or no side load. I will be attaching 1/4" plywood to the back of the center upright, the side uprights and the top, middle and bottom shelves.

Is this thick enough or should I consider making my dovetails less deep? I was planning on making them 1/4" deep.

TIA.

Re: Wood thickness question - thick enough??

#2

Re: Wood thickness question - thick enough??

Hikmet C. Sakman Victoria, BC CDN

What's the 3/4" material? Although, in a foot width, most should be OK, even MDF, which is notorious about sagging when used as shelves.

I'd deepen the dovetails more, 3/8" or 1/2". @ 1/4", you need to cut them so precisely for them to hold well. Then you'll be facing the difficulty of driving (sliding) the shelves into the dovetails that shallow.

Did this answer your question?

Chico...

Re: Wood thickness question - thick enough??

#3

JL

Red oak

JL

I'm dovetailing it on both sides on the center upright. I'll stay with 1/4" for that one.

Re: Wood thickness question - thick enough??

#4

As I understand the question

Nathan

He's got a 3/4" thick center upright that he is dovetailing into from both sides (at the same spot). When material is removed for the 1/4" deep dovetail slots, only 1/4" of material is left.

These are sliding dovetails that extend more-or-less across the entire width of the upright. Question is, will the 1/4" thickness be too thin to avert structural failure under load?

What would failure modalities look like? I can't think of any. Assuming the sliding dovetails are well fitted, the material of the dovetail will functionally replace the removed material.

Try to think where and how it would break.

Re: Wood thickness question - thick enough??

#5

JL

Re: As I understand the question

JL

I would think that it would break at the angle where the "flat" of the dovetail joins the side. I see what you are saying about the glue making things one "unit".

I'm also making this a stopped, sliding dovetail. So there will be a 1-2" section of 3/4" thick wood on the center upright.