re-gluing edge-to-edge panel
Murray
A solid wood panel I built (cherry) partially came unglued. Do I need to plane the edges before re-gluing? Is there a better choice than yellow Elmer's for this application?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
re-gluing edge-to-edge panel
Murray
A solid wood panel I built (cherry) partially came unglued. Do I need to plane the edges before re-gluing? Is there a better choice than yellow Elmer's for this application?
Re: re-gluing edge-to-edge panel
Moses Yoder
Wood does not just come unglued. There was some problem with the joint. What was the problem with the joint?
If a glue joint breaks, it normally breaks the wood beside the joint. Is this the case in your break?
And to Clint Searl, here is another example of a broken glue joint where if the joint was sprung it probably would not have broken.
Re: re-gluing edge-to-edge panel
David Yoho
When you say the panel "partially came unglued", did it come all the way apart or just a split but still together? Did this occur at a glue joint?
Either way, there's a number of reasons this would've happened but fixing it should be easy enough. If it's split but still together, rip it on the tablesaw in two, joint the edges, glue with your yellow glue and clamp.
If it is already in two pieces, joint the edges, glue and clamp. Your edges must mate up without noticeable gaps along the joint line or it can come apart again. Make sure the edges are jointed properly before gluing and clamping. Trying to use the clamps to remove the gap will apply too much pressure and squeeze too much glue out of the joint, which can be a cause of failure.
Re: re-gluing edge-to-edge panel
steve mackay
I would clean it up first. And, just a thought . . . I tried this Gorilla Glue to glue down the top of my tool chest and, watch out, this stuff is massive strong ! While I stick with carpenter's glue %99 of the time, I must admit this stuff now has a place in my life.
Moses
Clint Searl
If you still believe in the Sprung Joint Myth, I have this bridge to Brooklyn you'd be interested in buying. 
Clint
Re: re-gluing edge-to-edge panel
Murray
To Moses and David: it came completely unglued, do to being out in a barn.
Re: Moses
Moses Yoder
I will have to look up my high school shop teacher, Mr. Phil Berkey from Northridge High School in Middlebury, IN, and ask him about the Brooklyn Bridge. If he advises me to buy it, I will take a serious look at your deal. I've never been let down by following his advice so far.
Re: re-gluing edge-to-edge panel
Jesse Cloud
Clean it up nicely and if its going back to the barn, use a water resistant glue like titebond 3 or the gorilla glue mentioned above.
the myth of excessive pressure
Bill Tindall
It is impossible to apply so much pressure to a joint that insufficient glue remains to form a sound bond. As reported by the tech staff at Franklin glue company, they have never been able to repeat this claim nor was I in an experiment reported on WC some months ago. It only takes two molecular layers of glue to form a bond between two surfaces and given the initial viscosity of the glue and the steep climb in viscosity as the wood sucks water from the glue emulsion it would be impossible to squeeze all the glue out of a joint.
More likely this myth began with someone who had a crummy joint and tried to compensate with excessive pressure. Joints fail because of insufficient contact between the surfaces caused by too little pressure or wood surfaces that don't smoothly mate. The glue itself is weak compared to the wood and if all but a thin layer is not squeezed out then the joint will fail within the glue.
Re: re-gluing edge-to-edge panel
Moses Yoder
I wouldn't use Gorilla glue for an edge joint if someone held a gun to my head and said "Glue or I shoot." A good glue like Titebond 2 or 3 is stonger and less visible.
A joint does not just fall apart because it was stored in a barn. A well made piece of furniture can be stored in a barn or an air conditioned house and it won't make any difference in the function of the piece. You can glue two boards together using white Elmer's glue and if properly jointed they will not come apart unless they are soaked in water. Chances are the boards were stored in a way that prevented equalized moisture exchange causing them to warp and split somewhere.
Re: Moses
Clint Searl
Alas, poor Phil! A fellow of infinite jest, of most excellent fancy; he hath sprung one joint too many. 
Clint
Re: re-gluing edge-to-edge panel
John Lucas
I agree with Moses. I have not found anything that gorilla glue will do that epoxy or yellow glue won't do better. It is certainly not as strong. At least in the tests that I ran. I glued up samples both end grain and long grain with all the different glues that I had including Gorilla glue and an offbrand Polyeurethane glue. Then I put a 5lb weight on the arm that was glued to the samples. I slid the 5 lb weight out until the sample broke and recorded the distance. I know it wasn't very scientific and I only had 2 samples of each glue. Well 4 if you count the end grain and side grain samples.
On the endgrain samples the gorilla and Polyeurethane glues were incredibly bad. worse even than CA glue. On side grain they did better, the CA was the worst in that case. The problem was Yellow glue, white glue and epoxy was far better on both end grain and side grain. I did do a slight pre soak of he glue on end grain joints so that I didn't get a starved joint.
Polyeurethane will also not come off your hands with any solvent I have found. Epoxy and yellow glues are easy to get off. CA of course will stick your hand together
Re: re-gluing edge-to-edge panel
FredD
IN a test for FWW , Gorilla glue ranked last.
FredD
Thanks, Bill
David Yoho
Your information is spot-on. However, I think we all would agree using clamps to force a joint with gaps together is ill-fated, and that's the point I was really trying to convey. Should have been more exacting in my reply.
"ill-fated"
Bill Tindall
I like that description of gaping joints.
In this case it looks more like the piece got very wet.
novel glue
Bill Tindall
All that needs to be known about furniture glue is that hide glue and aliphatic glue (white and yellow) fasten together 99.9999....% of all the panels ever used in furniture. So why would anyone use anything else (unless water was involved in the panel application)
Re: "ill-fated"
David Yoho
We only have a small amount of information from the original post and one subsequent post. There's much we don't know about this panel that came apart. That said, Moses is right - it didn't just come apart for no reason.
With the information we do have, I have to wonder if it was due to the joint not being done right, as it seems others were, or maybe it even had something to do with the finish not being balanced on all sides. It could also be a combination of things. Being stored outside in a barn says to me it might not have gotten real wet but the seasonal changes defeated the finish perhaps causing enough movement that the wood let go in the most vulnerable place.
I agree
David Yoho
I only use liquid hide glue, Titebond II & III, and once in a blue moon, epoxy. Polyurethane glue has its applications but I just don't see it for construction of furniture.
The one time I was brought a dining chair to repair the loose back spindles that the owner tried fixing herself with Gorilla glue was enough to convince me it was a bad idea. Cleaning that stuff away was a real pain and made a simple repair more costly!
Re: "ill-fated"
Murray
Hi David,
I would be glad to give a little more information on the piece in question. It was a cradle built for my daughter, and the panels are (were?) at either end. They have a truncated "V" shape. I built it completely with hand tools, including joining the edges.
So, I can see where inadequate clamping pressure was applied because opposite ends of the panel were not parallel. Also, since I don't joint boards very often, the mated surfaces might have not made good contact.
Now, do I just try again? Or buy a cheap doweling jig? My brother-in-law's wife is expecting, and they expect me to have a cradle ready!
Forget the dowels
David Yoho
I'd say forget the dowels. Just be more careful about the jointed edges mating properly before gluing. There are any number of ways to clamp irregular shapes.
If you experienced a problem with that before, your creative side should be able to come up with a way to apply pressure to the end panels the next time. Sometimes something as simple as masking tape can be used to "clamp" together joints when needed. There are others as well.
I bet if you ask a separate question of the group here explaining as clearly as you can what the problem is, you're sure to get some good ideas. To keep it from being mixed up in this thread, post a new question. There are many ways to skin a cat and there's a wealth of knowledge here waiting to help.
Which type of gorilla glue?
AZ in Colorado Springs
Gorilla wood glue? or Gorila ployurethane glue?
Re: re-gluing edge-to-edge panel
Bruce, a MN Galoot
In another post, you mentioned that this was the end panel. Is it sitting cross-grain to another board? That alone could make it split.
Re: I agree
Jesse Cloud
Yeah, me too. Only reason I would even consider poly glue is that it is water resistant.
Lemme get the bottle . . .
steve mackay
Doesn't say. Just "Gorilla Glue". 52427-50008. Looks like syrup though. Certinly not as scary as I'd always heard about though. Pretty easy to use.
Out in the barn alone
North of the Border
couldn't explain why the boards came apart unglued, as no mention was of the temperatures and conditions in the barn.
Has the question of the quality of the glue been mentioned or considered? Has it expired beyond its shelf life, for example?