Evaluation titanium nitride coated plane blade 2
Bill Tindall
Evaluation of Titanium Nitride Plane Blade- Results 2
In the previous installment we found that titanium nitride (TiN) provides excellent corrosion resistance and an attractive gold coating to a plane blade. Additionally, it was found that sharpening the bevel of this blade does not raise a burr on the back side that would have to be removed, which in turn would remove the coating. This installment will focus on dulling.
Objective of Work- There are many objectives one might hope to achieve in the evaluation of TiN coatings. The most desirable would be to gain a quantitative assessment of dulling of a TiN coated blade vs one that was uncoated. I don�t have the ability to achieve this objective. We can hope to determine how the coated blade wears and perhaps begin to gain some assessment of whether the wear is dramatically different.
Experiment- Two Hock A2 blades were compared, one sharpened at the Hock factory and then coated with TiN. The blade was sharpened with about a 40 micron back bevel. I sharpened a second A2 blade by my usual technique that ends with 1 micron diamond on cast iron and does not use a back bevel. The planing test was done on a 1 M long piece of maple, 0.924� in width. The plane was a Stanley 605 with a Hock chip breaker. A test blade was mounted in the plane and the blade adjusted by using a short narrow test piece of walnut to cut about a 0.001� thick uniform shaving. Then 10 planing passes were done on the maple. The surface of the shaving as well as the surface of the test piece were examined with a hand lens at 15X after each 10 passes. After 10 passes the blade was removed and the edge examined at 15X with a hand lens. The alternate blade was then installed and the process repeated. A total of 5 rounds of 10 pass planing each was done for a total of 50M of planing for each balde, in each case alternating the coated and uncoated blades after each 10 planing passes.
Results- The TiN coating is done at 750-800 degrees F. This temperature will lower the hardness of the A2 blade for its initial value of Rc60 to something less. A test of this TiN coated A2 blade found it to be Rc 54, a substantial lessening of the hardness.
Fortuitously the maple test piece had a pin knot and grain reversal at the far end. It was this area that first showed a difference in behavior between the blades.
After 10 planing passes (10M) the surface of the maple was judged equivalent for both blades. Under 15X magnification there was no grain tear and the surface was bright and glass smooth in each case. After 40 passes (40 M of planing) there appeared to be some wear of the TiN coating and there was obvious damage beginning to occur on the uncoated edge. After 50 passes the area of the grain reversal began to show grain tear under 15X magnification. The grain tear was significantly worse for the uncoated blade. There must have been a micro chip developed on the TiN blade for it began to leave a �track� just visible with the hand lens on the test piece after 30 M of planing.
Conclusions: The coated blade may be dulling more slowly. But, I must emphasize that a lot more repetitions would need to be made to confirm this preliminary indication.
Future: When it can be arranged the two blades will be inspected by microscopy. One would expect from the planing result that the uncoated blade will show a greater wear bevel than the coated blade but that possibility remains to be confirmed. After this round of microscopy both blades will be sharpened, which in the case of the coated blade will remove the coating from the bevel but not the back, and the experiment repeated.



