Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Rechargeable Battery questions Again

Posts

Rechargeable Battery questions Again

#1

Rechargeable Battery questions Again

Barry Irby

I have three 12 volt Makita drills and an Impact driver. I had the batteries rebuilt and they have worn out again. I am considering either buying a pair of new batteries or have a couple rebuilt. Seems a shame to trash the tools. So, would you go with NiCad or Nickle Metal Hydride? Any better ideas? Ebay has a lot of choices. Any experience there?

Re: Rechargeable Battery questions Again

#2

Re: Rechargeable Battery questions Again

Gary Smyth

Taken from Garrett French (Internet) (Link did not work)

Compare Nicad, Li ion, NiMH

Criteria for Making Your Power Tool Battery Decision

According to Building a Better Power-Tool Battery you should be looking at a battery's run time, life cycle, volts and amp-hour rating.

Run Time:

Quite simply run time is the amount of work a tool can do before its charge runs out.

Life Cycle:

Life cycle is how many times the battery can be recharged during its life time.

Volts (Power):

Volts will determine work output of the tool. John Sara, cordless product manager for Milwaukee Electric Tool, says "Individuals currently using a 18-volt NiCad battery, should see 2 - 21/2 times more work output from a V28."

Amp-Hour Rating

The higher the Amp-Hour rating the longer the battery lasts - be aware that power tool batteries of the same voltage will often have different Amp-Hour ratings.

NiMH vs. NiCad vs. Li Ion: Picking What's Right for You

Nickel metal hydride (NiMH) Batteries:

I don't think I could define it better than wiki pedia: 'A nickel metal hydride battery, abbreviated NiMH, is a type of rechargeable battery similar to a nickel-cadmium (NiCd) battery but has a hydrogen-absorbing alloy for the anode instead of cadmium. Like in NiCd batteries, nickel is the cathode.'

Nickel metal hydride (NiMH) advantages:

-- lighter than NiCad

-- 2-3X capacity to equal size NiCad

Nickel metal hydride (NiMH) disadvantages:

-- fewer life cycles compared to NiCad

-- shorter run time

-- performs the worst in cold temperatures, so keep that in mind if you plan to use tools powered by NiMH outdoors in cold weather

-- higher self-discharge level than NiCad

-- voltage drop at near-discharged levels

Nickel cadmium (NiCd) Batteries:

According to Wiki pedia: the 'nickel-cadmium battery (commonly abbreviated NiCd and pronounced 'nye-cad') is a popular type of rechargeable battery for portable electronics and toys using the metals nickel (Ni) and cadmium (Cd) as the active chemicals.'

Nickel cadmium (NiCad) advantages:

-- longer life cycles

-- performs in cold temperatures (perform well to 20F)

-- lower self-discharge level than NiMH

-- no voltage drop at near discharged levels

Nickel cadmium (NiCad) disadvantages:

-- Heavy, making it harder to use for longer periods of time

-- May suffer from 'Memory Effect' or 'False Bottom Effect' if constantly discharged half-way and then recharged (wiki pedia)

The Lithium ion (Li-Ion) Battery:

The new comer to power tool batteries, Lithium Ion are hot because they have 'one of the best energy-to-weight ratios, no memory effect and a slow loss of charge when not in use,' according to Wiki pedia.

Lithium ion (Li-Ion) advantages:

-- High performance in cold weather - to 0F - great for winter outdoor use

-- Light weight. You can lift tools powered by Lithium Ion over your head all day.

-- Increased life cycles over NiCad and NiMH, so it keeps going past other batteries

-- more rapid charge times that get you back on the job more quickly

Lithium ion (Li-Ion) disadvantages:

-- less tested than other battery formats - in early stages of development

-- has a shelf life based on life of battery, not related to charge or charge time

-- can sometimes erupt or explode in high heat - hot cars, direct sunlight, etc, or sometimes after tampering. a more dangerous battery than the others

-- permanent damage to battery if stored at too-low discharge level, so be careful and keep these charged well

What battery is right for your power tool decision? Clearly there are many different options, and many different pluses and minuses for each battery type. That's why it's imperative that you come to your purchase prepared with knowledge that will help you make the right decision for your situation.

Only you can decide what is best for your work. Is it worth extra dollars for the tool for a better battery. Your call.

Re: Rechargeable Battery questions Again

#3

Re: Rechargeable Battery questions Again *LINK*

del schisler

have you tried to zap your batteries?? I have done that to lot's of them and you can get a lot more use from them . You can do a google search and find lot's more. Here is a u tube video


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g0JbNX4K4fQ&NR=1

Re: Rechargeable Battery questions Again

#4

Re: Rechargeable Battery questions Again

Joseph Mulherin

Thank you, Gary, for that explanation on the different batteries we use on our tools. I. too, have some issues with my batteries and this explanation showed me what to seek in new batteries. Again, thanks.

Re: Rechargeable Battery questions Again

#5

Re: Rechargeable Battery questions Again

Joseph Mulherin

Thank you, Del, for the "youtube" video on recharging a dead battery. shall try this on my batteries and report how it works out.

Re: Rechargeable Battery questions Again

#6

Like all things Wikipedia.....

Bill Tindall

There are some truths, half truths and misinformation in the article. The problem with any such discussion is that there are a great variety of details within a battery type that affect many of the battery attributes of interest. The result is that it is impossible to make general comparisons for many of the important attributes unless one is comparing specific batteries.

The main property that has rendered NiCd's nearly extinct is the potential toxicity of cadmium, which is a disposal issue in some places. Otherwise NiCd and NiMh battery types are more similar in performance than they are different. The NiCd can be more prone to "memory effect" but with a quality charger the effect will never be experienced. First generation Pacemakers powered by NiCd have lasted decades and the Prius is powered by NiMH so each can be a reliable battery type if properly made and charged.

The life you get from the replacement will greatly depend on how you use the batter, the quality of the charger and the quality of materials used to make the battery. In general batteries don't like to be charged or discharged when hot; it will shorten life.

Were it me I would go to Home Depot and buy a guaranteed for life Rigid tool powered by a Li ion battery and junk your antiques.

Re: Rechargeable Battery questions Again

#7

and......

Bill Tindall

you can explode the battery as well with this process.

Re: Rechargeable Battery questions Again

#8

Re: and......

Joseph Mulherin

Understood, Bill, shall just search for new batteries instead of using the welder to refurbish the old ones.

Re: Rechargeable Battery questions Again

#9

Re: Rechargeable Battery questions Again

Bill Howatt

I've seen various refurb tricks mentioned over the years and some do seem to work for some people for a period of time but they don't always work.

It reminds me of what we used to do years ago with car batteries that weren't up to the job: Connect to a trickle charger overnight or even build a small one in under the hood. Buy a battery blanket and keep it warm so it's electro-chemistry would be better. These tricks were usually employed in the winter and they often worked or they did at least until the car wouldn't start in the middle of nowhere because you couldn't plug the gizmos in or the battery totally died in spite of the hospice care it was getting.

The real issue was that the battery was past its prime and was failing and all these tricks did was slightly prolong the inevitable passing or the battery.

Bill

Re: Rechargeable Battery questions Again

#10

Use 24 volt with any battery below 24 volt

del schisler

I have redone probly a doz and what i done was use two 12 volt car battery's to make 24 volt. Of coursr you don't leve it hook up all the time all you are doing is flashing it. I guess anything could happen. Not saying do it but this work's for me and a couple other guy's. Now with a welder that sound's like a over kill. you put it on the lowest setting. I belive 2 batteries would be better. Do a google search and you will see lot's more way's with battery's. On some older charger's below 3 volt the charger will not charge. So when you flash the battery it will charge and work. When it get week again do the flashing again. More life or at least it work's for me. good luck and use your good sence??

Re: Rechargeable Battery questions Again

#11

that's right

Bill Tindall

You are right on that the typical mode of battery death is not reversible by any means. For a car battery the expected failure is corrosion of the positive terminal. The lead grid supporting the lead dioxide corrodes away and the plate falls to the bottom of the battery cutting the connection to the terminal.

However, these batteries work much better when warm, not hot, whether they are being charged or discharged to start the car. A battery at 10 below in MN has significantly less car starting power. The starting voltage may be as low as 8 volts and the current also reduced. To add insult to injury, battery life is also reduced at low (or high) temperatures. So warming an almost "dead" battery in MN could get enough juice flowing to get a start.

Re: Rechargeable Battery questions Again

#12

Antiques? ANTIQUES????

Barry Irby

If these be antiques, almost everything I own is an antique.

This is sort of funny, about as much a study in personal psychology as it is in batteries. I have had some of these tools for about twelve years, and had the batteries rebuilt once, so I guess they are antiques. When I got them I thought they were small, compact and powerful. I have scoffed at others who wanted 18 volt tools or others with more power. These were clearly powerful enough.

For Christmas my family gave me some of the Bosch tools that run on the small 12 volt batteries. The batteries are so small they fit inside the handle. I have been using them since Christmas on the houses we have been working on and was thinking of restoring the batteries on the old tools so I could use them in the shop. A funny thing has happened. The old tools appear HUGE now. It just goes against my grain to throw away my old friends because the batteries are weak.

Re: Rechargeable Battery questions Again

#13

The winning strategy

Bill Tindall

BEFORE the rebuilt batteries completely die, as evidenced that they need charging more often, sell the tool. Then buy guaranteed for life batteried tools from Rigid.