Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Another lumber peev . . .

Posts

Another lumber peev . . .

#1

Another lumber peev . . .

steve mackay

Went in yesterday (to get my one measly board). No conversion factor. While we were all talking I was going through the skid looking for that one board to fall in love with and I noticed something else. My guys were HELPING me go through the skid. We were down about eight layers by the time I liked one. I've always heard about the yards that won't let you go beyond three or four layers down. Greatfull I don't have to buy lumber I don't want there. But, then again, I wouldn't buy there.

Re: Another lumber peev . . .

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Another lumber peev . . .

Moses Yoder

So two guys @ $17 per hour were helping you go through a stack of lumber for 45 minutes to buy a $20 board. I think if I did the calculation you would make out out pretty good on that one :b Maybe the yard was owned by Warren Buffet? I hear he needs tax write offs.

Re: Another lumber peev . . .

#3

Re: Another lumber peev . . .

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

It's too bad that your retailer didn't have better product. At retail prices one should not have to go that many layers to find a suitable board.

Re: Another lumber peev . . .

#4

McKinneyMike

Re: Another lumber peev . . .

McKinneyMike

Steve,

I feel for you, but I know how difficult it is for the lumber sellers too. They get what they get from the lumber mills, as long as it makes grade, the mills are happy. Now the lumber seller has to deal with what is allowed that "makes grade" and they are expected to sell it as cheaply as possible too.

It is amazing what "makes grade" from the mills these days. Sap is almost in all cases no longer considered a defect, but show me one customer that will buy a board with much sap on it. I think that you will see more and more lumber sellers going under as the mills could care less as they will get their money regardless whether the lumber sellers customers will buy it or not.

I gave up selling "commodity woods" like Red Oak, Ash, Polar, Maple, etc as the grading standards have nothing to do with appearance, except to the consumer and the lumber seller is left holding the bag. Be kind to those folks when you can. They may not be around much longer unless their customers get less picky, as the large commercial sawmills could care less :)

I only buy lumber from "insiders" these days as they will sort and select the best available materials for me for a premium, but that is money well spent. I just do not see how any lumber sellers can survive given what they are forced to accept from the commercial mills these days.

Small sawmill operators can be a great source, but many do not have the expertise to dry different varieties of lumber correctly and so its a crap shoot for anyone needing large volumes of materials to stay in business.

I feel your pain, but there is always another side to every coin.

Re: Another lumber peev . . .

#5

Re: Another lumber peev . . .

Jesse Cloud

The three rows deep rule peeves me too, but it works both ways. One yard here lets you spend all day going through the stack if you want. This works great if they have had a recent delivery. A week after a delivery though, all the good stuff is gone and you have to wait for someone to buy whats left before they restock, may be a few months.

If I have to have really good lumber, I may wind up going to two or three yards to get enough to build a chair.

Re: Another lumber peev . . .

#6

Once again I rise to the defense of the lumber pur

Bill Tindall

It is a fact that lumber is manufactured and graded to meet the needs of large buyers, for example furniture factories. The retail market as represented by you all is minuscule. By and large there is no other source of lumber for a retailer to buy from(there are minor exceptions). So, if I am in the business of selling hardwood lumber, as I once was, this is my source of supply. I can specify grade and maybe I can specify a range of lengths. For example, suppose I order some cherry to sell and I ask for a pack (about 500 bdft) of 10' lumber in the highest grade available.

Here is what I get to sell from: I will get about 500 bdft or lumber and it will be mostly 10' 2" but some will be 9'2" and it will be random widths from 3 1/2" and wider, with most 5 1/2" and wider. This pack of lumber will be composed of the top 4 grades- firsts, seconds, firsts and seconds 1Face and Selects with a yield of clear cuttings of 83% fromt he best side and 66% from the worst side. Sap is not a defect in cherry so how much sap is in the pack will depend on how big the logs were. The pack would have cost me about$3.00/bdft in my area of TN, as of 1/14/2007(the last Market Reporter I have kept). And, I will be billed for 1.08 times more lumber than what is measured in the dry state.

The main customers for this lumber, furniture factories for example, don't care how much sap is in the pack or what the widths are. They cut this lumber up into smaller pieces, glue it into panels and assemble furniture from it.

Fundamental fact: you can't sell what you can't buy. Now imagine you are a business that is selling this lumber, of widely differing desirability to the retail customer, to the "board at a time" customer. Picture in your mind what becomes of this stack of lumber after the 1st, 2nd, 10th, 25th customer picks through it for their board.

Some customers think it is wonderful that a retailer lets them pick though a pile. These same people may then heap abuse on the retailer when the lumber they are picking from isn't up to their expectations when they become the 10th person to pick the stack. And the cabinet shop that then orders 200 bdft off the top of the stack at the same price as the 1st picker gets screwed.

I think it is amazing that anyone bothers with the board at a time customer. There is no way to make a profit selling lumber to them and you wind up screwing your profitable customers.

I am off to visit the brand new granddaughter, well actually the mother, so I will not be available to endure the response. Happy woodworking.............

Re: Another lumber peev . . .

#7

Re: Once again I rise to the defense of the lumber

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Some good points there Bill and it helps to see the other side of the coin. For me, I don't buy retail. I buy from brokers or mills...usually hundreds of feet at a time. Rule of thumb is that there is no sorting or picking thru. You assess the lot and buy it. You accept that there are a few bad boards in the lot. In my business I call them "secondary wood".

Tom

Re: Another lumber peev . . .

#8

This Time I'm With You *LINK*

Bob Lang

I can't imagine a more difficult business to try to make a living in than selling lumber at a retail level. There are two ways I approach buying lumber for a specific project. The first is to call up a supplier who mainly deals with wholesale customers, specify a quantity that's a lot more than I need and have it delivered. If it's a species I use on a regular basis, I want the better price and I understand that there will be a lot of boards in the stack that are less than ideal, but still make the grade.

Or I go to a place that's mainly retail with my cutlist in hand, root through their pile and pay a lot more. I'll have hardly any leftovers and on a project by project basis my overall cost is about the same.

But the poor guy selling retail winds up with all the skinny, knotty, gnarly pieces that no one wants.

Bob Lang


From The Popwood Blog

Re: Another lumber peev . . .

#9

I'm  feeling blessed

Randy Johnson

Since I got hooked on turning I don�t buy very much hardwood lumber anymore, but�.

I have always been more than happy with any and all dealings with the place I buy when I buy, Wilhelm�s near St. Leon in southeastern Indiana.I think there are a few others at Woodcentral that buy there as well. I�ve never bought huge amounts of wood there but I�m always treated like I�m one of the biggest customers they have. Sorting has never been a problem.

It�s not a huge operation. Maybe that�s why they are so easy to deal with.

BTW, I�ve never done business with them (yet) but for those of you in the SE Indiana/SW Ohio another hardwood source you would never find by accident is Carson�s Lumbermill. It is off of North Dearborn road near New Alsace, IN. This guy seems to be starting out but his prices seemed reasonable.

Re: Another lumber peev . . .

#10

Re: Once again I rise to the defense of the lumber

FredD

What Bill says about picking the stack is true and that is the major reason when I bought a unit was make sure it was still banded.

Lesser quantities were hand picked by me and scaled by the yard worker.

Since I always bought FAS there wasn't any hassle from Higgins, it either met the grade or it didn't.

FreDD

Re: Another lumber peev . . .

#11

Shhhh Randy.

Ray - Middletown, In

Wilhelm's is a secret. My new favorite place to buy lumber.

Ray

Re: Another lumber peev . . .

#12

Re: Shhhh Randy.

steve mackay

Shout it from the rooftop and keep 'em in business.