Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

Posts

OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

#1

OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

Ray - Middletown, In

Anyone use it? results? I've been pricing decking material and some of the composites are way to expensive. South American hardwoods are not available here in the vast wasteland so that is out. I did find cypress but have no knowledge about it. I've used Trex and have been less than impressed. The deck will be in full sun so I have some concerns about UV fading and such. Doing maintenance is also out. I built the house to be maintenance free and am not doing it on the deck either. I've about decided to use Trex and just cuss at it once in a while.

Ray

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

#2

Clint Searl

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

Clint Searl

I decked the dock on my pond with Lowes composite stuff several years ago, and it's held up very well with no apparent fading under full exposure. I'd use it again.

Clint

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

#3

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

Dick Coers

I would think that western red cedar would splinter quite easily, and my body doesn't react well to cedar splinters. I've also read that the currently harvested cedar and redwood do not have near the rot resistance that the old growth did. Do you have any local mills that could provide some air dried white oak? I don't have any experience with composites.

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

#4

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

FredD

Maintenance free is probably a unattainable goal unless you have a staff that keeps up the home and yard.

Western Red Cedar is pretty soft for deck material, but another Cedar, called Alaskan Yellow Cedar is hard and makes a good deck, though not maintenance free.

This wood started coming into California when Redwood got beyond most peoples budget. I did about three decks with it and the only thing I didn't like about it was the smell when cutting it.

FredD

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

#5

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

Bill Howatt

During our last reno about 7 yrs ago I used Trex and after both pine or spruce and red cedar there is no way I'd abandon Trex or perhaps a similar product. The Trex is as smooth, flat and crack-free as the day it was laid which I certainly couldn't say about the wood. Cooks in the summer and freezes in the winter just fine.

Bill

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

#6

The newest decking product on the market

DizD

is Thermally Modified Wood Decking. I've seen the products but never used any. You can do a search and find companies and comments on this.

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

#7

Ellis Walentine

Don't rule out Ipe

Ellis Walentine

I know you said you can't find South American hardwoods locally, Ray, but ipe has pretty good distribution nationwide, notably through specialty decking/landscaping outlets. I Googled an outfit called Gettum Associates near Indy that could probably steer you to a local supplier.

Ipe, when left to weather, takes on a lovely silver color and smooth texture, with no splinters. It needs to be predrilled for screws or nails because it splits if you look at it cockeyed. The endgrain needs to be sealed well with paraffin, too, to prevent checking. Other than that, it's fireproof, harder than concrete, murder on carbide router bits, a little bit expensive, but it'll last 50 years with zero maintenance.

My 2�,

Ellis

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

#8

Re: Don't rule out Ipe

Howard Norman

I agree with Ellis about ipe. It is a fantastic deck material imho.

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

#9

Re: Don't rule out Ipe--Indy source

Ron Jones

Try Carter-Lee Lumber in Indianapolis 1-800-344-9242. The last time I checked with them they carried Ipe at a reasonable price. Reasonable Ipe is still a little pricey tho. However, that may have been more then 2 years ago. They are open Monday through Friday and delivery is available. Good people in my opinion.

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

#10

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Ray, you may want to call Hollingsworth lumber at Russiaville http://hollingsworthlumber.com They also have a store in Peru. I know they stock several types of decking and did carry IPE. Don't know what the decking prices are as I haven't checked, but they are pretty reasonable on their other woods.

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

#11

Found one source for Ipe - yikes

Ray - Middletown, In

$4.75 lin ft. but that was from a specialty store. I'm am going to try Carter-Lee and Hollingsworth next week. Thanks for all the replies. The boss didn't want to hear that it turned gray with age.

Ray

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

#12

Re: Found one source for Ipe - yikes

FredD

Ray, the only practical solution , long term for deck color is Paint..

If that makes you grit your teeth,consider this, the best Landscape Architect I ever worked with was Bob Morris in California and the first time I did a beautiful and very expensive Redwood Deck for one of his clients, he had it stained a very light grayish color with maybe a slight blueish tinge and stated the reason for doing that, was he did not like dusty footprints showing on the deck , which they didn't with that color.

Since the client approved , who was I to say Hey!

FredD

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

#13

Ellis Walentine

Maintenance of exterior woodwork

Ellis Walentine

I mentioned the graying process because it is the default condition if you let the wood weather naturally, and it's distinguished looking in its own way. But, you don't have to let the weathering occur. If you're willing to mop on a coat of some kind of deck oil faithfully, you can keep the rich brown color indefinitely. When I say faithfully, I mean at least once per season and ideally two or three times.

When I first laid down my ipe decking on our back porch, I wanted to finish it and keep it looking like finished wood, so I coated it with Cabot's Australian Timber Oil (I think that's what it was called). It was essentially a linseed-oil based varnish product. I made the mistake of leaving too much of a film on the wood, and it took forever to dry; and, by then, it had dog footprints, bugs, tree droppings, etc. all over it. I don't know if ipe is one of those woods like rosewood that keeps finishes from ever drying, but it acted that way for me. I found that only a thin wiped coat, wiped almost dry, would do; and that's not enough to protect very long from exposure. You'd have to do it religiously over the course of the year to keep the wood color saturated.

Mark Mandell coated his decking with Penofin, which I still am unable to locate, and he swears by it. I don't know if it penetrates into super-dense woods like ipe, but I aim to give it a try if I ever find a store that sells it. Trouble is, once the wood has grayed, you need to sand it back to fresh wood if you want to restore the brown color.

Ellis

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

#14

Re: OT - Decks -Locust?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Ray, don't know if you can find it - Hollingsworth was out of it a year or so ago, but I understand it makes a more durable deck than either Redwood or Cedar. It is damn hard and almost indestructible. Hollingsworth told me they sold a lot of it for decking - and it is fairly cheap. Probably wear out a set of steel planer blades if you planed enough for one small deck though. Having built a vanity and some other things with it, I've found it to be a really attractive wood. It would have to be coated (like about everything else) to keep it from turning grey. Hollingsworth may have it back in stock by now if they have cut any recently. One thing to watch for - they keep Black and Honey locust in the same bin without any difference in identification - Black Locust is yellow golden after planing while Honey locust can be grey with pink streaks - totally different appearance. Both are very durable.

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

#15

Re: OT - Decks -Locust?

FredD

My experience with Honey Locust, Larry was the kansas hardwood mill gave me some to try.

I used it to replace the boards on a outside bench , thinking that if it had the same long lasting character of Black Locust which is used for fence posts around here , it would be good.

Very pretty wood , very similar in color to Red Oak and it split and cracked all to Hell in one Kansas Summer. ;-((

FredD

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

#16

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

Jim Dillon

Ray,

We have used western red cedar extensively as trim (top of railings, fascia, and bench surrounds) on two of our decks. One deck is 15 years old and the other 10. Thought it would look nice, and it did, at least for a week >( . The rest of the deck was preserved wood. Using a linseed oil based sealer (Behr) turned the cedar very, very dark. Then, with age, the cedar turned gray and now matches the rest of the deck. Very light pressure washing brings back some of the color, but regular deck maintenance is pretty far down on my list of priorities. The woodpeckers seemed to like the stuff (or insects inside) and have done some real damage - at least on one deck. Stainless steel screws/nails are also mandatory with cedar. It is somewhat soft, but that isn't a problem for us as we don't have it on the deck per se. All-in-all, I probably wouldn't use it again, plus it has gotten very expensive for good stuff - which this was.

Jim

Re: OT - Decks - Western Red Cedar

#17

Thanks Jim

Ray - Middletown, In

That is the kind of info I was looking for in Cedar. I think composite, PVC, or Ipe will be the final choice. I was curious about cedar since it is by far the cheapest, excepting treated. On the phone tomorrow afternoon still looking.

Ray