Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

Posts

Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

#1

JL

Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

JL

Now that I've got the wood and it is sitting in the shop "equilibrating" for a week while I go off to VA for a while.

The shelving will be used to store "boxes" of music. The boxes hold individual pieces of music (about 30-40 pieces) of a couple of sets of music. The boxes can weigh 5-10 lbs.

I'll be realistic. Most of the time the boxes will sit on the shelves. Once in a while, the choir director will get a box down and select pieces for use. So basically, there isn't a lot of repeated wear - just occasional wear. Dust will collect - so there is that problem.

I was thinking with the amount of shelving (three sets of shelves with 7 moveable shelves per set) that I would spray as opposed to anything else.

I was thinking of a 2 part conversion varnish as opposed to anything else. We have a Sherwin-Williams store, so I was thinking about using one of their products. I'll only need a gallon or so.

I was going to go with a vinyl sealer then a top coat of conversion varnish.

I can spray and have the finishing done in a single morning.

I'm asking now so I can make sure the product will be on hand when I need it.

Thoughts??

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

Moses Yoder

We have spent thousands of dollars repairing finishes around sinks where they got a little wet, because of the vinyl sealer. Even after wiping down with a towel there is enough moisture left to lift the finish off the vinyl sealer. I wouldn't use vinyl sealer if someone held a gun to my head and said "Spray or I pull the trigger." You can use the finish itself for sealer and end up with a much better product. I like conversion varnish because it is quick and easy to use, extremely durable, and looks very similar to an oil finish.

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

#3

Clint Searl

I agree

Clint Searl

Vinyl sealer is a waste of time and money! I still have most of a ten year old gallon that you're welcome to drop by and take.

Clint

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

#4

still more agreement except.....

Bill Tindall

Kemvar C looks just like an oiled finish- low build and dull. My wife washes furniture finished with it. It's durable. Kemvar M can look like bright alkyd varnish if it is used as full gloss. If I remember correctly M is available in 4 degrees of luster from bright to dull and it is a higher build finish. I have no experience with the two part finishes. For these shelves I would be using something about like medium rub luster.

JL, it is entirely practical to spray urethane varnish. Dilute it 4:1 with mineral spirits and spray away. On hot day it will be dust free in 30 min.

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

#5

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

FredD

I can't imagine what your doing wrong , but all brands of Pre-Cat Lacquer I have used ,recommend a sanding sealer with added Vinyl, that is their advice based on their R@D departments and if it wasn't correct , they would have a liability.

Anecdotal tales without any substantiation on the use of any product generally can be traced back to faulty work methods or lack of understanding the directions assuming they read them.

FredD

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

#6

Clint Searl

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

Clint Searl

I don't claim experience with anything but one part solvent NC and CAB lacquers, but it's my understanding that all finishes are self "sealing." I put sealing in quotes because whatever it implies is meaningless. It's nothing more than a base coat for the final finish. So why not make the base coat the same as the final coat? The only time, following S-W directions by the way, that I used vinyl sealer under CAB, it added nothing to the final product, but did impose the additional requirements of sanding and restricted overcoat time. Never used it again and have never had a problem without it. One start, one finish, and one cleanup.

Clint

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

#7

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

FredD

Your beating a dead Horse, you don't know whether it added anything to your finish.\or not.

But I know that Vinyl Sanding Sealers give a finish a very high resistance to water vapor acquisition which is the reason they were developed .

i do not like their loading of sandpaper compared to a NC Sanding Sealer , but it is well worth the extra effort.

Since you advocate no Sealers at all , assuming that the finish will serve as well as one over a Sanding Sealer , never minding the fact that your using a expensive finish for a sealer , without the benefits associated with one.

So that makes this conversation meaningless with all due respect .

FredD

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

#8

They used to only sell post cat in 5's

Dick Coers

to limit the use by hobbiest. You may want to check to see if they changed the policy before deciding. 5 gallons is a lot of finish. I add a vote for no vinyl sealer. Post cat only, no thinning through a pressure pot.

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

#9

Re: They used to only sell post cat in 5's

FredD

Gem sells it in gallons .

FredD

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

#10

Clint Searl

"Resistance to water vapor acquisition?"

Clint Searl

What does that mean and why is that important on a piece of furniture that's gonna sit in conditioned space? Cost difference? Pennies per project, if at all.

Clint

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

#11

Clint Searl

Re: They used to only sell post cat in 5's

Clint Searl

The S-W industrial products distributor I deal with only stocks in 5 Gal, but is happy to pour off a Gallon at a time.

Clint

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

#12

The story on vinyl sealer

Bill Tindall

Vinyl sealer is the "shellac" of the synthetic finishes. It sticks to about everything and about everything sticks to it. And, it can be sanded The first of the Sherwin Williams post cat conversions varnishes recommended using it. The reformulated stuff I buy now doesn't.

CAB, especially SW formulated CAB, is picky about what it sticks to. This information is straight from the "Horses Mouth" tech staff person of the company that makes the CAB. I personally had an adhesion problem with CAB lacquer over a stain I once used. Vinyl sealer may well overcome a CAB adhesion deficiency. I quit using it when SW no longer recommended using it under their conversion varnish.

Finishing products are being reformulated with some regularity and they can be complex formulations. "Results may vary". As Fred says, unless you have evidence to the contrary, follow manufacturers recommendations.

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

#13

Moses Yoder

Re: Laquer versus conversion varnish

Moses Yoder

Newer laquers might be different from old laquers, but old laquers were not very resistant to moisture. For instance, if you set a glass of water on a laquer surface for a couple hours you would get a white ring. Conversion varnish is a much better, tougher, finish than laquer. Of course laquer is generally cheaper and a little easier to work so most shops spray laquer. We take a lot of pride in our work and want it to have the best available finish that lasts a long time so we spray conversion varnish. It is entirely possible that laquer adheres to a vinyl sealer differently than conversion varnish does.

Following is our story on vinyl sealers. I am not going to go into specific brand names due to liability for Ellis. We have a supplier here in Shipshewana, IN that is very good. They have several guys that work the lab making color matches and training their customers how to use the product. To answer your question above, they do read the directions. A few years back they came to us with a "new" vinyl sealer. It was cheaper than our current sealer, and easier to sand than our current sealer, saving money in labor costs. So we switched and started using vinyl sealer. 6 months later our customers started sending our salespeople text messages with pictures of pealing paint attached. Irate, or course. If you spent $50,000 on a kitchen and 6 months later the paint was peeling you would wonder what the manufacturer was smoking. We immediately went to our vendor and asked what the hell was going on. They told us we were sanding the wood too smooth so the sealer wouldn't adhere, we were letting the sealer dry too long before top coating, etc. etc. So we started making sure we only sanded to 180 grit, and also started writing the seal coat time on the cart and everything that was sealed in the morning had to be topcoated that day, sealed in the afternoon was topcoated next morning. Then we started doing our own tests, putting some water on the edge of a door and seeing what happens. The next morning the paint peels right off. With a catalyzed sealer that costs a little more and is a little harder to sand, no paint peeling. Cheap vinyl sealer, paint peeling. Thus after spending thousands of dollars repairing kitchens that were supposed to last a hundred years, when we see a can of vinyl sealer we use it for target practice, usually with a Remington 30-06 rifle.

Like I said, you may have a very different experience with laquer.

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

#14

Re: "Resistance to water vapor acquisition?"

FredD

What do it mean? Lemme see heah.

Clint, I know damn well you are familiar with the expansion and contraction of Wooden Furniture due do the increasing and decreasing of MC Summer to Winter and like that.

The use of Vinyl Sealer under a finish nearly eliminates that problem.

FWW ran a published test on every common finish and Lacquer formerly a very poor performer at resisting water vapor , rose straight to the top of the list when used with a Vinyl Sanding Sealer. End of that story

The cost of using a expensive finish for it's own sealer may be pennies if your doing trinkets, in a shop where a average set of Kitchen cabinets takes one gallon of Sealer and two of Lacquer , one can see how that would add up and like I said , that doesn't even include the advantages lost by not using a Sealer.

If you are pleased with your approach to finishing without the use of a Sanding Sealer that's fine, but you mislead people who aren't experienced with finish application by inferring that is the accepted way of doing it.

A reasonable person who is aware of the R&D departments in Paint and Varnish companies ,staffed with Coatings Chemists would assume they have a edge, knowledge wise, over him and follow directions.

FredD

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

#15

Re: "Resistance to water vapor acquisition?"

FredD

What do it mean? Lemme see heah.

Clint, I know damn well you are familiar with the expansion and contraction of Wooden Furniture due do the increasing and decreasing of MC Summer to Winter and like that.

The use of Vinyl Sealer under a finish nearly eliminates that problem.

FWW ran a published test on every common finish and Lacquer formerly a very poor performer at resisting water vapor , rose straight to the top of the list when used with a Vinyl Sanding Sealer. End of that story

The cost of using a expensive finish for it's own sealer may be pennies if your doing trinkets, in a shop where a average set of Kitchen cabinets takes one gallon of Sealer and two of Lacquer , one can see how that would add up and like I said , that doesn't even include the advantages lost by not using a Sealer.

If you are pleased with your approach to finishing without the use of a Sanding Sealer that's fine, but you mislead people who aren't experienced with finish application by inferring that is the accepted way of doing it.

A reasonable person who is aware of the R&D departments in Paint and Varnish companies ,staffed with Coatings Chemists would assume they have a edge knowledge wise over him and follow directions.

FredD

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

#16

Clint Searl

Re: "Resistance to water vapor acquisition?"

Clint Searl

Fred, you're addressing a hypothetical problem that doesn't exist. I live in PA where the RH varies between 20 and 90 in my house over the seasons. So what if the wood moves a smitch; proper construction prevents any problem. Everything I've made and finished with lacquer, straight or over stain, there's never been an issue with adhesion or anything else, especially expansion and contraction. Can you cite an instance or example which illustrates the purported value of vinyl as a vapor barrier?

I think it does this audience a disservice to promote a process which complicates but doesn't add value to their work. I'll defer to experience.

If I were inclined to employ a base coat clear coat program, which I ain't, I'd start with shellac.

Clint

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

#17

Re: "Resistance to water vapor acquisition?"

FredD

Here you go Clint , the remarks of a leading finish manufacturer.

Look under Precat Lacquer and Vinyl sealer. Happy Fourth of July. :D

www.mlcampbell.com/products/categories/clear_sealers

Re: Finishes for shelving... Conversion varnish?

#18

Clint Searl

Marketing assertions (hype)

Clint Searl

Without documented claims, not to mention proof, of what calamity would befall if those products weren't used.

My tried and true schedule for lacquer:

1. Sand progressively to 180 and finish with 220 drywall screen.

2. Wet wipe with naptha or lacquer reducer.

3 Vacuum or soft brush when dry.

4. Brush or spray a reduced base coat.

5. Rub back with maroon pad to smooth and de-nib.

6. Spray multiple coats to get the desired build.

7. Spray a mist coat of reducer to even out the sheen.

Clint