Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Drawer style replacement

Posts

Drawer style replacement

#1

Drawer style replacement

Gary Smyth

Late last summer I found a chest on chest on chest lying by the road. When I spotted it it appeared to be old, but no. The bottom two chests were salvageable but the third (top) chest was all but destroyed with only enough left to provide basic dimensions. Anyway, I carted the thing home and set out to repair the chest. Last fall I got through cleaning up the bottom two sections. I got shut out owing to winter and only in the last several days got back to it to start again on the top chest. I�m now at the drawers. See pics of an existing middle chest drawer detail. The rear of the drawer is �� box joints. The front is machine made �� dovetails but with a 3/8� offset for an overlay drawer front all around. The sides are 3/8� thick Oak and the front is �� maple. I�m stymied. I can do the box joints with no problem. But I do not know how to do the 3/8� offset with a dovetail jig. Can someone guide me as to what I need to do first? I�m past the point of no return and I definitely want to keep the same form of drawer for the three chests. I have a dovetail jig that will do the work if I set it up correctly, but no directions or manual. If someone has a place for me to start it will be appreciated. Would I rout the offset first?

Re: Drawer style replacement

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Drawer style replacement

Moses Yoder

Step #1) Mill 3/8" x 3/8" rabbet in drawer edges (or match existing)

Step #2) Hand cut dovetails using standard 1/2 blind dovetail procedure (See Tage Frid for info)

Step #3) Put 2 shots Jack Daniels in tall glass, fill to brim with Dr. Pepper, lift and tip at lips.

Re: Drawer style replacement

#3

Re: Drawer style replacement

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Holy Moses, Moses!

I'd have to take the Dr Pepper with a grain of salt. Mixing Jack Daniels with anything wasn't my stile. I haven't tasted the real thing in 25 or 30 years. 8)

George

Re: Drawer style replacement

#4

BTW, I Concur Fully w/Your Fabrication Instructio 

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Re: Drawer style replacement

#5

clarification

Bill Tindall

you are wanting to make a new matching drawer not repair one....?

Re: Drawer style replacement

#6

Re: Drawer style replacement

Jesse Cloud

Moses nailed how to "do it right" (except for the part about Dr Pepper ;) ). However, if you don't know how to hand cut dovetails and don't want to learn right now, just make the basic box (no offset) with your dovetail jig and attach a false front to the box with a couple of screws from the inside of the box. No one, except you, will notice.

Re: Drawer style replacement

#7

Yes, The whole top is new

Gary Smyth



Curves are camera perspective. Still needs mouldings, and some sort of crown which was in original but unknown except for old nail holes and shadow lines.

Re: Drawer style replacement

#8

Jesse.  No offense but a false front

Gary Smyth

is not part of this project. I have a Leigh which I could use for the offset but the dovetails made there, while machine made, will not match the straightforward ones made by the factory on the two lower chests. I have some luxury of time so cutting dovetails could be a different summer project but I want this top chest out of my shop, finished, and in use ASAP. The original was finished with what appeared to be a multicoat colored lacquer so I'm a way away. But the drawers have to match the old ones as much as possible. It will take more time and it's a pain but I couldn't look at it later if I didn't make the effort to do it now..

Re: Drawer style replacement

#9

many way to proceed......

Bill Tindall

You need a lipped drawer. It does not have to be a dovetailed or dovetailed- box jointed drawer.

Step 1...Decide your intermediate plans for developing your woodworking skills and capabilities. If this is the only lipped drawer you intend to ever make then just make it with a dado joint in the rear and a nailed rabbited joint up front.

Or. Dovetail a through-dovetail box for the drawer and fasten an oak front to it

Or, many dovetail jigs will do a lipped drawer. Buy one.

Or, if you aspire to make hand-cut dovetails then this is an excellent opportunity to begin. Step1 here is to buy a good saw (the LV is excellent) and get the Cosman video from Lee Nielsen.

PS I have never see a box joint used in a drawer.

Re: Drawer style replacement

#10

am I understanding correctly.......

Bill Tindall

You have a jig that will make a dovetailed lipped drawer but the problem is that these dovetails will not match in some way those in the original?!? If so you may be the only person in the history of woodworking to fret over a faithful reproduction of a factory made drawer. Some Period Furniture makers strive for a faithful reproduction, but then it is likely a piece where the original is selling for tens of thousands of dollars.

BTW, the dove tails in the picture look like those made with the Porter Cable and similar jigs.

Re: Drawer style replacement

#11

Re: Jesse.  No offense but a false front

Barry Irby

As Bill said those look like the dovetails made by the Porter Cable jig. I have a version of it made by Stanley. I also have the Stanley router and have had both for forty years. I have almost never used the jig but I did make shop cabinets with it and those are the dovetails it makes. I also have a Leigh jig and it will not make those. If I understand the Leigh jig, it will not close down far enough to make them that small.

Go to the Porter Cable site and look at the jig. You will see that the fingers are fixed and about half inch wide. The guide bushing fits the slots exactly. Also, whatever the angle is on tours, its pretty steep.

Making a drawer with a lip would be a question of cutting the lip first and then setting up the jig to cut the sockets, missing the lip and cutting the tails in a separate operation. I do not have the instructions for the Stanley Jig, but I have them for the Leigh jig. I would think you could print out the instructions for the Porter Cable jig. The Stanley jig is based on "fiddling it in". You can cut both the pins and tails at eh same time. You raise and lower the bit until you find the sweet spot and then cut both pieces. You would need a number of scraps to practice on. The instructions for the Leigh jig include how to do it on a lipped drawer, but again, they won't match.

Where are you? I would loan you my Stanley jig. There is some damage on it but it could be repaired.

Re: Drawer style replacement

#12

Barry, Thank you.  Not necessary.

Gary Smyth

I have a old Sears dovetail jig around with equally spaced dovetails. I haven't the directions nor have I used it for a very long time, but what the heck, I'm trainable.

Re: Drawer style replacement

#13

Re: am I understanding correctly.......

Gary Smyth

I agree, mostly. However, this time I want it the way the rest was originally. I set out to build it back and I'm too stubborn to ease off now. Yes, the original was factory mass furniture made, but it was made correctly (or maybe just differently). When I repaired/rebuilt the first two chests I found them to be fairly complicated. It's like a jig saw puzzle in there where everything is mortised, rabbeted, dadoed into something else and the only metal found thus far were brads to hold the uprights for the rear of the drawer runners and two screws to lock the front to the base. The dust panels are key as they fit into dados in the rear of the front rails and those are mortised into the chest sides...well, you get the idea. As much as this is a pain, I'll stick with it as there are only six drawers and once set up it should be a breeze. I have what I need to do the drawers, but not the directions. I'll test until I get it.

Re: Drawer style replacement

#14

the Sears will do it

Bill Tindall

I have one and before I gravitated to hand cut I used it to make dozens of lipped drawers that basically look like those pictured. There is a set screw that gets moved depending on whether its lipped or not and I suppose the bit size is critical. If you can't find directions on internet I can have someone scan mine and email.

Re: Drawer style replacement

#15

Moses Yoder

Re: Machine lipped dovetails

Moses Yoder

To make a lipped dovetail with a jig, the side of the drawer is first installed in the jig and routed. Then the front is installed in the jig, pushed forward further than normal so the router routes a flat section on the edge. The Leigh jig may be a little different than the craftsman I hardly ever use but I am assuming it would be a similar setup. Normally both pieces are routed at one time but to do a lipped front you route the sides then the front.

Re: Drawer style replacement

#16

Thank you.  I'll do the on line search.

Gary Smyth

Re: Drawer style replacement

#17

PS

Bill Tindall

you will need a guide bushing for the size slots in the jig.

Re: Drawer style replacement

#18

Oh yes, now it's coming back.  It's that

Gary Smyth

three legged "tin" piece that attaches to the older Sears router base. If I remember correctly it requires a 1/4" shank on the router bit too.

Re: Drawer style replacement

#19

Easy Way

David Yoho

This may not work for what you're wanting to accomplish as far as matching the old but...

I've set up my 12-inch Porter Cable jig to create half blind rabbeted dovetailed drawer boxes before but learned a much more effective and quicker way I use whenever I can now. I also own a newer 24" Leigh Super jig but it's more trouble to get the setup right on any of these jigs than I like.

In a nutshell, what I do is make the drawer box with a secondary wood for the sides and back but the front piece is from the species seen on the outside. I use 1/2" stock. It's quicker and easier to setup my jig for standard through dovetails. So after cutting the joints, I assemble the drawer box. I mill a piece of wood for a false front 1/4" thick with a bead profile around the outer edges large enough for the right overlap all the way around. Then I attach the front to the box.

In the end it looks like it was made from 3/4" stock with all that fussy setup of a jig. By using the same species of wood for the box front and false front, they look like they were done the other way but much easier.

This picture below is an example of a drawer box made from QS sycamore with tiger maple front. Can you tell where the two front pieces went together?


img