Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Shelving - solid hardwood or plywood??

Posts

Shelving - solid hardwood or plywood??

#1

JL

Shelving - solid hardwood or plywood??

JL

Cost of materials:

Red oak (12" width and greater) - $2.40/board foot for 4/4 nominal

Red oak plywood - $55/sheet

So the plywood is running ~ $1.72/board foot (nominal).

The shelves will be used to hold the music "boxes", hymnals and whatnot for the choir. I estimate the weight of one of the music storage boxes to be on the order of 10 lbs. They are about 11 1/2" deep x 7 1/4" high x 6" wide or so. So figure on at least 20 lbs per foot.

The Sagulator calculations say plywood would work nicely - but southern red oak would also work fine.

So the question - solid wood or not?

If I do plywood, I'd have to put an edging strip on the shelves. I'd either have to put a face frame on the uprights and outer shelves or put an edging strip.

I'm thinking that the labor would probably be more for the plywood. The lumber is S2S and straight line ripped. I'm thinking that I would need on the order of 140 board feet (possibly less) for the needed lumber. I'd need at least 4 sheets of plywood and edging material if I went the plywood route.

I'm really leaning towards solid wood. I'd have 1/4" plywood backing.

Thoughts??

TIA

Re: Shelving - solid hardwood or plywood??

#2

Re: Shelving - solid hardwood or plywood??

Gary Smyth

As you said, the spread is not of concern for sagging and you can face the plywood with solid to make it stronger. Still, if the money is there the solid wood will present a nice product and you'll be happier too. Go with the solid oak.

Re: Shelving - solid hardwood or plywood??

#3

Re: Shelving - solid hardwood or plywood??

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I would use solid wood. The last few sheets of plywood I have purchased - some from Borgs - some from specialty lumber yards, have all been below what I would consider "good" grade. The sheets have warped while standing on edge in my heated and air conditioned shop. This includes some supposedly genuine Baltic Birch. The veneer is so thin on some of the sheets you are taking a risk of sanding through using 300 grit and a quick sanding. The cost will soon be forgotten but the shelves will be there a long time.

Re: Shelving - solid hardwood or plywood??

#4

Spend the money . . .

steve mackay

I hate plywood. It has a place but it ain't shelves. Board oak is forever.

Re: Shelving - solid hardwood or plywood??

#5

Re: Shelving - solid hardwood or plywood??

Jesse Cloud

From the description of the load they will carry and what I guess to be the relatively high frequency with which the load will be moved around (read slid over the shelf or thrown down on the shelf), the shelves will take a lot of wear and tear. Ply is going to gouge and delaminate fairly soon. Hardwood will show some wear, but can be repaired with a few minutes on the sander.

I wouldn't put a fancy finish on them, whatever you use.

Re: Shelving - solid hardwood or plywood??

#6

Re: Shelving - solid hardwood or plywood??

FredD

I used Red Oak for our Library, the look is neater then a plywood shelf with a rail and the beauty of the solid wood shelf is ,you can turn it over it if it develops a little sagosis.

I wouldn't go beyond thirty six inches for the span between uprights.

FredD

Re: Shelving - solid hardwood or plywood??

#7

JL

Solid it is - they okayed the $

JL