Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Yet more on walnut color and staining

Posts

Yet more on walnut color and staining

#1

Yet more on walnut color and staining

Bill Tindall


This picture shows the back of the top for the French Footed bow font I am making. The over-hanging edges have been stained with my usual recipe of burnt umber oil stain. The unstained portion has been freshly planed and it shows the fleeting hues some desire in this wood. It would appear that staining has dramatically altered the color of this walnut and for this reason some eschew staining walnut.


This picture shows this same back after a coat of clear shellac has been applied. The back has also "aged" several days in indirect sun light. By close examination one can still make out the stained edge. But now the color difference is not great. The mineral pigment stain, which won't fade, will maintain this same color, thereby largely preserving the original walnut color. So rather than altering the color by staining, I am preserving it from fading over time.

Re: Yet more on walnut color and staining

#2

One point I would like you to clarify

DizD

I reviewed the previous posts and it seems you are using stain directly on bare wood in these examples, rather than over a base coat of shellac or other sealer. Is this correct? I'll soon start finishing a walnut dresser and would like to incorporate this technique. Thanks.

Re: Yet more on walnut color and staining

#3

to answer.....in detail

Bill Tindall

Now the pressure is on t yield success if someone is actually going to try to follow something I write about.

With out any hard evidence to support the claim, I think sanding is the problem with staining. Staining brings out the worst of sanding. It isn't necessary to sand to some minuscule grit size, but it is essential to sand away all the machining defects and burnish and each grit size must remove the scratches of the previous grit.

I begin walnut with 100, or 120 if I can get by with the smaller grit. Sand until the surface has a uniform dullness. Places that are more dull are catching sanding dust and they will in turn catch stain and be blotchy. My typical sequence for walnut is machine100/hand120/hand180, or machine120/hand120/hand180. About 80% of the time is spent on the first grit size for it will be this step that is working to remove machining defects. I hand sand 120 and finer. I like the control, I can spot problem areas and I can see the proper surface developing as I hand sand.

After sanding I blow off the dust and stain on the bare wood. An exception would be a crotch figure that I wanted to keep from going too dark. In this case I would apply a thin coat of shellac and then stain. If the edges are properly sanded to a uniform luster they will stain the same depth as the flat grain. If the end grain is dull it means there are torn fibers exposed and catching the sanding dust which will catch stain and turn dark.

Practice on a scrap piece first......ALWAYS.

Re: Yet more on walnut color and staining

#4

Thanks

DizD

I understand what you're trying to accomplish and agree with the approach. I asked because of my experience with a friend/mentor who had a refinishing shop and used to say that nobody should be allowed to put stain on a piece of wood which did not have a basecoat. From his perspective of refinishing, this would be correct - the concept of reversibility applied to finishes. In the case of walnut, the uv blockage is paramount. Starting this morning on wiping it down!