Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Test results on titanium nitride blade-1

Posts

Test results on titanium nitride blade-1

#1

Test results on titanium nitride blade-1

Bill Tindall

Introduction: Let me get some issues out of the way. I have zero stake in any commercial success of this effort. My only stake in this work is the satisfaction that I have contributed to understanding what a high abrasion resistant coating will do on a plane iron. And indeed, that is the primary objective of this work, to see how such a coating performs. My success will be measured against whether any useful information is obtained. If it seems to provide benefit it will be up to others to confirm the benefit and profit from it. If it fails, I want to understand why and how so that others may find a way to overcome the deficiency.

I welcome critique of the experiments or anything else that contributes to better data being obtained. If you find the results interesting provide encouragement to continue. If you think the work a waste of my time, don't waste yours by reading about it.

The objective of today's work was to obtain initial images of the plane iron edge for comparison to the worn edges to be produced by subsequent experiments. To that end I have excellent images of the bevel and back edge at various magnifications. The as-received blade is coated with TiN right to the edge. I observed that the back of the blade was prepared with about a 30-50 micron back bevel before coating. The edge appears sharp, but then would we have expected less of Ron Hock?. I will proceed to see how the as received blade wears while planing some test wood, of species yet to be determined. Any suggestions?

Sharpening burr: I ground a small 1/4" portion of the bevel with 10 micron diamond to determine whether a burr would form with the TiN coating on the back. The TiN was readily removed by one stroke of the 10 micron diamond. Several additional strokes were performed which would have raised a substantial burr on an uncoated blade. No burr was detected in the microscope images. Conclusion: The coated back of the blade will not need to be deburred after sharpening, which of course would remove the coating if it was necessary. This is a favorable result.

Re: Test results on titanium nitride blade-1

#2

Re: Test results on titanium nitride blade-1

FredD

If Hock supplied the coated Plane iron , he must have some R@D info on it , or would it be proprietary ?

The issue interest's you so why not? But I tend to agree with Clint , sounds like a marketing approach, coated metal has been around a long time.

Also I think some of the guys try for a edge that is only apparent microscopically and so frail as to disappear after a pass or two on Hardwoods.

I hope you get a feel for how long the edge last's versus a regular A2 steel iron and if it is significant.

But again, that is just what I think.

FredD

Re: Test results on titanium nitride blade-1

#3

Re: Test results on titanium nitride blade-1

Jesse Cloud

Interesting research! I will follow it with interest. I hate sharpening (there - I've said it, now I feel better)! My hopes are that a coated plane blade would take a sharp edge and hold it. Now thats right up there with sliced bread!

I would encourage you to use a "control" iron that is not coated, and apply all the same tests to both irons. That would mean sharpening both with the same procedure before anything else is done.

Data should include both "objective" measurements and subjective observations, as long as the subjective items are identified as such. For instance, I can't imagine an objective way to characterize the sensation of running the plane across a board (it chatters, it glides, it cuts like butter,etc. are about the best we can do to the best of my knowledge), but the subjective stuff is important.

And to the naysayers, yeah, coated metals have been around for a long time, but so have riving knives and it took an act of congress to get those on saws in the U.S.

Re: Test results on titanium nitride blade-1

#4

Re: Test results on titanium nitride blade-1

doug f, san clemente, ca

Like many others, sharpening is one my least favorite activities in the shop and any advance that lessens the necessity of resharpening is most interesting. Please keep up apprised of your findings and thanks for the time and effort you're putting in.

Would it be possible to post pictures of the various edges as you progress?

Doug

Re: Test results on titanium nitride blade-1

#5

Re: Test results on titanium nitride blade-1

Dave Paine

I am very interested. I purchased a Ron Hock blade for my #5 Record plane. It transformed the plane.

It does not make my work better, but it does make my work easier which I value.

If a Ron Hock blade can be improved, I would consider for some of my other planes, perhaps even an upgrade for the #5.

I have the tools to sharpen blades, but it distracts from other tasks I prefer doing.

The rust resistance is desirable. My garage is my workshop. It is attached, but not directly air conditioned. I have a dehumidifier at the other end of the house.

Please continue to post the results and ideally pictures.

I can get some light rust on surfaces due to moisture from the garage being opened. Easy to remove, but another distraction.

Re: Test results on titanium nitride blade-1

#6

Re: Test results on titanium nitride blade-1

Bill Tindall

Would it be possible to post pictures of the various edges as you progress?

yes

Re: Test results on titanium nitride blade-1

#7

picture example

Bill Tindall


This picture is an example of the pictures we can get. The picture is taken with a Nikon microscope and lens tailored for imaging metal surfaces in reflected light. The reflected light from the metal surface is polarized and the microscope has a polarizing filter. By diddling with polarization better contrast of regions of interest can be visualized. In this case we are focusing our attention on the back bevel that was honed on this blade. The back bevel is the narrow band at the blade's edge. The polarized light makes what is the yellow coating on the back of the blade pink, for reasons I can't explain. Note, the back bevel is yellow from the TiN coating which clearly goes to the edge.

By focusing on this region after sharpening we were able to determine that no burr had formed. What will be of great interest is what the wear pattern looks like and how it differs from an uncoated blade.

Re: Test results on titanium nitride blade-1

#8

Ellis Walentine

Wonderful photo

Ellis Walentine

That microscope rig of yours is excellent. By all means post more photos as appropriate.

Ellis

Re: Test results on titanium nitride blade-1

#9

Re: Wonderful photo

Gary Smyth

While you're at it post a pic of the photo set up as well. Also, how is the magnification field recorded? Do you add it or does the microscope automatically provide that data?

Re: Test results on titanium nitride blade-1

#10

photo scaling

Bill Tindall

A reference slide is used to provide an image of a know distance. The microscope data system is able to use this known distance to scale subsequent images and place a measurement scale on the recorded photo.

Re: Test results on titanium nitride blade-1

#11

Re: Test results on titanium nitride blade-1

Bill Tindall

I now have in hand an uncoated blade from same source, presumably equivalent except uncoated. Hence, I have the means to compare one against the other. Two "quick and dirty" comparisons will be made. Sharpened then coated as received vs uncoated and sharpened. Then, coated then sharpend vs uncoated and sharpened.

These data will offer some guidance as to how to proceed to the more demanding experiments. However, there are some complications. Never-the-less in the end we hope to have a sound comparison of coated vs uncoated for some blade and coating combination. It just may take awhile to reach that goal, but be assured we are working toward it. In the mean time there are worth while questions to answer, for example, how does the wear profile of the coated blade compared to uncoated.