Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Routing grooves in red oak?

Posts

Routing grooves in red oak?

#1

JL

Routing grooves in red oak?

JL

I'm routing several grooves in a piece of red oak.

I've got an old 3/16" HSS round bottom veining bit - which has really never been used. Routing with the grain is no problem (of course). There is a minor bit of roughness routing cross-grain.

This is an old bit with a single "flute". I have no problem with buying a new bit for this project - as it would be under $20.

I can sand the grooves moderately well - but I don't want to lose too much detail on the edge.

Should I consider a new bit? Should I sand the grooves in a different fashion?

Re: Routing grooves in red oak?

#2

Re: Routing grooves in red oak?

Gary Smyth

What does it look like on a test piece?

Re: Routing grooves in red oak?

#3

Alan Young

uumm Try this

Alan Young

Take a sharp chisel,or exacto knife and score along the cut lines before routing the grooves.

Re: Routing grooves in red oak?

#4

JL

Re: Routing grooves in red oak?

JL

It is groovy of course :b .

I'm getting a little "roughness" in the cross-grain direction as I said - but just on the bottom. The sides of the grooves look good (in both directions)- but I want the bottom "smoother". I'd be happy if I could sand the bottom without touching the sides.

Re: Routing grooves in red oak?

#5

Re: Routing grooves in red oak?

woodenleg

I have taken steel rod and put sandpaper on it using spray glue ( like for patterns) and then sanded. I have never tried 1/8 " using this method.

Good Luck, Dave

Re: Routing grooves in red oak?

#6

Re: Routing grooves in red oak? *LINK*

del schisler

You need a new bit if you are doing a lot of this work get this one from whiteside. They have the best bit's. This will save you lot's of sanding. You should get a snooth cut. I do lot's of router work. here is the link


http://www.amazon.com/Whiteside-WSSC39-Flute-Bottom-Veining/dp/B000K2G6DS

Re: Routing grooves in red oak?

#7

If you were to purchase your red oak

Gary Smyth

moulding from a vendor it would probably be rough exactly where you report your roughness is -- probably for the same reason, and that is that the bit is not as sharp as you would wish it to be. Depending on the amount of wood or the number of passes as in fluting you have to push through I would get a new bit, or two, with at least two flutes and carbide. If the stock is held down and the freedom of movement is controlled from the side and pushed through with the router at the correct speed and at a consistent rate, you should get the best you can get from the router and bit. If pushed through by hand you may still get burning somewhere along the length. As for sanding, a long rod with abrasive paper at less than the diameter of the rounded groove is the best solution I can think of. That way the edges should stay crisp. With red oak take multiple passes and save the final pass as very light with no stopping.

Re: Routing grooves in red oak?

#8

Re: Routing grooves in red oak?

Bill Tindall

If you are not staining apply a first coat of finish and then sand the rough end grain. The finish will stiffen the fibers and they will cut off easier with sanding. A sharp bit should leave an acceptable finish.

Re: Routing grooves in red oak?

#9

JL

I'll use coat hanger

JL

Re: Routing grooves in red oak?

#10

Moses Yoder

Re: If you were to purchase your red oak

Moses Yoder

I doubt you could get a 3/16" veining bit with carbide edges, it would probably have to be a solid carbide bit. The other thing I want to mention, I did a lot of fluting on a cnc router and tried routing in 2 passes with the last pass being .005 deep and did not really notice any difference in the smoothness of the flute if it was routed in one pass.