Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Evaluation of a Titanium Nitride coated plane blad

Posts

Evaluation of a Titanium Nitride coated plane blad

#1

Evaluation of a Titanium Nitride coated plane blad

Bill Tindall

Titanium Nitride TiN) coatings (that yellow coating seen on tooling) are used to provide improved wear to wood bit tooling, for example CNC router bits. It may provide the same benefit to a plane blade, which remains to be tested.

Ron Hock, Hock Tools, provided a coated A2 steel blade for a No. 5 Stanley plane. The blade had been sharpened and the back polished before coating. We do not believe this blade is the best test of the concept of a coated blade but it is a blade in hand and some testing will proceed. In addition we hope to have coated a blade that may provide a better test of concept. I will post on this site results with the Hock blade as we get them. You all are invited to suggest experiments to do on this blade. As seen in the photograph, the blade looks elegant.

Experiment 1 Corrosion resistance

TiN provides a corrosion resistant barrier on steel. In this experiment a spot of water was placed on the coated and an uncoated blade. After a day one can see the orange rust spot on the uncoated blade. One can also see the spot where the water was applied to the coated blade but only a mineral deposit from the hard water is visible. There is no corrosion.

Next photomicrographs of the coated edge will be made, planing tests performed and then photomicrographs made to determine how the blade is wearing. The planing will be repeated after the bevel is sharpened to see how the sharpened bevel performs. (sharpening will remove the coating from the bevel but not the back. In a bevel up plane configuration there will likely be some self-sharpening of the edge. We don't know what to expect on the bevel down Stanley plane configuration.

Steve Elliot and Bill Tindall

Re: Evaluation of a Titanium Nitride coated plane blad

#2

Clint Searl

Re: Evaluation of a Titanium Nitride coated plane

Clint Searl

My impression is that this is another woodworker version of How Many Angels Can Dance on the Head of a Pin evaluation that extends the obsession with all the different steel compositions, having no impact on the esthetic quality of the furniture one creates. Whatever the "results" of the testing, a gold colored blade in one of those Bugatti-looking block planes will surely raise the self-esteem of the owner.

Clint :D

Re: Evaluation of a Titanium Nitride coated plane blad

#3

Re: Evaluation of a Titanium Nitride coated plane

Jesse Cloud

My question would be - wouldn't the TiN come off on the first sharpening?

Maybe Ron wishes to sell disposable plane blades. ;^)

Re: Evaluation of a Titanium Nitride coated plane blad

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: The solution to polution

Moses Yoder

I wish everyone had that kind of attitude. Then there would be no pollution because we would all still be driving buggies with horses pulling them. :D

Re: Evaluation of a Titanium Nitride coated plane blad

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: Evaluation of a Titanium Nitride coated plane

Moses Yoder

There is a whole discussion on this on the hand tool side. The fact that the blade back was polished before coating makes a big difference. The back of the iron is what actually hits the wood in a regualr bench plane, bevel down. So technically you have the full thickness of the TiN coating as the leading edge of the iron, no matter how many times you sharpen.

Re: Evaluation of a Titanium Nitride coated plane blad

#6

Clint Searl

Re: The solution to polution

Clint Searl

I have a 10"x40 combination blade with solid TiN/TiC teeth for my table saw. Maybe it's sharper and holds an edge longer than my Forrest or Ridge blades, but does it make my creations any more beautiful? Nah! In fact, I swapped it out for a Freud 8" blade that works just as well for 90% of what I do, and when it dulls too much, I'll throw it away and get another one.

Clint

Re: Evaluation of a Titanium Nitride coated plane blad

#7

The solution to horse pollution was....

Barry Irby

the automobile. Just before cars became the rage New York City was about to bury itself in horse manure. There were huge piles of it down both sides of he street. When it rained the juice ran down the streets. They could not figure out where to put it or how to get it there. Then cars came along and the amount of horse droppings diminished to manageable proportions and then pretty much disappeared. So we traded poo for smog.

I'll be interested in the outcome of the Tin test.

Re: Evaluation of a Titanium Nitride coated plane blad

#8

If people don't do these kinds of tests

Phil Joines

we'll never know if it's worth while or not.

How many tests did Edison's lab people run to come up with the light filament?

Re: Evaluation of a Titanium Nitride coated plane blad

#9

Clint Searl

Re: If people don't do these kinds of tests

Clint Searl

It's another marketing gimmick to separate a gullible woodworker from his money. It might make sense in a high volume production machinery situation, but for the frequenter of this forum, it means zip.

Clint

Re: Evaluation of a Titanium Nitride coated plane blad

#10

Moses Yoder

Re: The solution to horse pollution was....

Moses Yoder

I live in Amish country, and work in the center of Shipshewana, IN. One day our cleanup guy was going along with a wheel barrow shoveling up all the horse manure, and a lady tourist said "Eww, that stinks." The shoveler looked at her and said "You could eat this stuff and it wouldn't hurt you, but try sucking on a tail pipe."

Re: Evaluation of a Titanium Nitride coated plane blad

#11

Re: Evaluation of a Titanium Nitride coated plane

Steve Schoene

But you need to chaise the burr from back to bevel as part of the sharpening process. The back does get honed, albeit only with the finest stone. At least how I was taught.